In cattle, the chemical composition of the carcass is usually evaluated from one of three reference methods (rib dissection, specific gravity or a combination of easily obtained measures) or is estimated from proxy traits (USDA yield grade (YG), subcutaneous fat thickness (SFT)). Objectives were to evaluate if the relationships between the chemical composition of the carcass and each of the proxy traits (YG, SFT) differed depending on the reference method. The study was conducted by meta-analysis from published results using 25 publications that reported carcass composition and proxy traits (53%, 31% and 16% of the data were based on rib dissection, specific gravity and combination of easily obtained measures, respectively). Results showed that the amounts of carcass fat or protein that can be predicted from a given proxy trait (YG or SFT) differ significantly with the reference method used to determine carcass fat or protein.

A total of 252 lambs was subjected to two contrasting growth rates (high and low) for 7 weeks commencing at 6 weeks of age, factorially arranged with two contrasting growth rates (high and low) from 13 weeks to slaughter. Growth rate was controlled either by weaning lambs at 6 weeks and feeding indoors throughout on differing levels of a concentrate diet (84 lambs in experiment 1) or by grazing at differing sward heights up to weaning at 13 weeks after which weaned lambs were grazed at differing sward heights and where necessary housed from early October and offered differing levels of concentrate and silage (168 lambs in experiment 2). Lamb slaughter weights on each growth rate treatment covered the range 40 to 48 kg live weight.

Increasing the growth rate between 6 and 13 weeks from 213 to 320 glday in experiment 1 and from 191 to 291 g/day in experiment 2 did not significantly affect the fat depth measured at various locations throughout the carcass, the weight of perinephric and retroperitoneal fat, fat grade or the total lipid content of soft tissue dissected from the shoulder joint when lambs were taken to slaughter weights. Increasing the growth rate between 13 weeks and slaughter from 136 to 338 g/day in experiment 1 and from 99 to 146 g/day in experiment 2 significantly increased the depth of carcass fat and fat grade but, though lipid content of the tissue in the shoulder also increased, this difference was not significant.

Carcass fat depth, perinephric and retroperitoneal fat, fat grade and lipid content of the shoulder tissue increased as slaughter weight increased. The effect of carcass weight on carcass fat was greater on the high plane of feeding from 13 weeks than on the low plane. For example, mean fat depth increased by 0·52 mm/kg increase in carcass weight on the high plane compared with 0·13 mm/kg on the low plane.

Comparing the effect of plane of feeding and carcass weight on carcass fat depth the high finishing plane of feeding had an effect equivalent to an increase of 3·8 kg carcass weight. The equivalent figure for the depth of tissue over the 12th rib was 2·8 kg while in relation to fat grade the effect was smaller at 1·0 kg carcass weight.