A distributed mass-balance model is used over a 10-year period for the re-analysis of a glaciological mass-balance time series obtained from Brewster Glacier, New Zealand. Mass-balance modelling reveals glaciological mass balance has been overestimated, with an average mass loss of −516 mm w.e. a−1 not captured by observations at the end of the ablation season, which represents 35% of the annual mass balance. While the average length of the accumulation season (199 days) remains longer than the ablation season (166 days), melting is not uncommon in the core part of the accumulation season, with 2–32% of total snowfall being melted. Refreezing of meltwater is also important, with 10% of surface and subsurface melt being refrozen in the present climate. Net radiation, driven primarily by net shortwave radiation, is the main contributor to melt energy, with melt variability mainly influenced by the turbulent heat fluxes, net longwave radiation and the heat flux from precipitation in the ablation season. Snowfalls in summer are an important moderator of melt, highlighting the critical role of the ice-albedo feedback and phase of precipitation on seasonal mass balance. A complete homogenisation of the long-term glaciological mass balance for Brewster Glacier is still required.