No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Choirboys and Choirgirls in the Victorian Church of England
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
Extract
Although the roles played by children in recent centuries in English church music have varied enormously, it is probably fair to say that choirs with at least some boys’ or girls’ voices have proven more important in musical, ecclesiastical, and social developments than those with none. The most obvious example of this is the choir of men and boys, which has constituted a conspicuous feature of cathedral and some collegiate music since the Middle Ages, except, of course, during the Commonwealth. As women and girls have until very recently been regarded as inappropriate in such music, it is difficult to imagine that the breadth of achievement in musical composition and performance standards associated with these choirs would have been possible if they had contained only men and no boys.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1994
References
1 Temperley, N., The Music of the English Parish Church, 2 vols (Cambridge, 1979), 1. pp. 102, 116, 132. 134.Google Scholar
2 Helmore, F., Church Choirs, containing Directions for the Formation, Management and Instruction of Cathedral, Collegiate and Parochial Choirs Being the result of 22 years’ experience in Choir Training (London and Stratford-on-Avon, 1865), p. 9.Google Scholar
3 Temperley, , Music of the English Parish Church, l, pp. 157–8.Google Scholar
4 Ibid., p. 162.
5 Helmore, Church Choirs, p. 58.
6 ‘Ladies’ surpliced choirs’, The Musical Times [hereafter MT], 30 (1 Sept. 1889), p. 526.
7 ‘The social aspect of the church choir’, The Choir and Musical Record [hereafter CMR], 16 (4 Oct. 1873), p. 207.
8 B. Rainbow, ‘Music in education’, in Temperley, N., ed., Music in Britain, The Romantic Age (London, 1981), p. 43.Google Scholar
9 Mackeson, C., Guide to the Churches of London and its Suburbs for 1884 (London, 1884), p. 171 Google Scholar.
10 Temperley, , Music of the English Parish Church, 1, p. 279.Google Scholar
11 Mackeson, Guide to the Churches of London, p. 171.
12 Prestige, G. L., St Paul’s in its Glory: a Candid History of the Cathedral 1831-1911 (London, 1955), p. 154 Google Scholar; London, St Paul’s Cathedral Library, ‘Chapter Minute Book 1874-1889’, p. 320 (25 June 1887).
13 ‘Church music’, The Musical Standard [hereafter MS], ns 17 (6 Sept. 1879), p. 154.
14 For sixteen shillings, see E. West, ‘How to raise a choir, and keep it’. The Organist and Choirmaster, 3 (15 July 1893), p. 51; for two pounds, J. S. Curwen, The Boy’s Voice. A Book of Practical Information on the Training of Boys’ Voices for Church Choirs, &c. (London, 1891), p. 21; for £5-£10, Fleming, G., A Treatise on the Training of Boys’ Voices, with Examples and Exercises and Chapters on Choir-Organization, Compiled for the Use of Choirmasters (London, 1904), pp. 75, 80 Google Scholar, and Advertisements: Wood-street, MT, 14 (12 Apr. 1870), p. 609.
15 ‘Educational [Trent]’, The Rock, no. 1,102 (27 Aug. 1886), p. 1.
16 For St Paul’s Cathedral, see ‘St Paul’s Choir Boys. Sir George Martin vindicates their absence’, MS, illus. ser. 16 (24 Aug. 1901), p. 120; for Eastbourne, ‘The Warden’, ‘Choir schools’, The Musical World, 59 (15 Oct. 1881), p. 669.
17 For St Paul’s, see Misc.: St Paul’s, The Church Times [hereafter CT], 18 (26 Nov. 1880), p. 801; for Margaret Street, Misc.: Street, Margaret, CT, 24 (15 Jan. 1886), p. 47.Google Scholar
18 For Chapel Royal, see ‘Clerical and organists’, CT, 26 (23 Nov. 1888), p. 1,029; for Bournemouth, Advertisements: Bournemouth, MS, 3rd ser. 19 (11 Dec. 1880), p. 365; for Torquay, Advertisements: Torquay, , MT, 21 (21 Aug. 1880), p. 377.Google Scholar
19 For Magdalen, see Misc.: Magdalen, , CT, 23 (2 April 1885), p. 279 Google Scholar; for King’s, Advertisements: King’s, , MS, 4th ser. 20 (7 May 1881), p. 289.Google Scholar
20 ‘Our leading organists. XIV.—Dr Huntley at St Peter’s, Eaton Square’, Church Bells [hereafter CB], 26 (29 May 1896), p. 800.
21 For Paddington, see Advertisements: Paddington, , CT, 10 (26 April 1872), p. 195 Google Scholar; for West Brompton, Advertisements: Brompton, West, CT, 10 (22 Nov. 1872), p. 535 Google Scholar; for Clifton, Advertisements: Clifton, , CMR, 16 (19 July 1873), p. 33.Google Scholar
22 For Blackfriar’s Road, see Advertisements: Blackfriar’s, , CT, 17 (21 Nov. 1879), p. 738 Google Scholar; for Holborn, , ‘St Alban’s, Holbom’, CT, 17 (20 June 1879), p. 391 Google Scholar: for Brighton, Advertisements: Brighton, , CT, 13 (8 Oct. 1875), p. 507 Google Scholar; for Vassall Road, Advertisements: Vassall-road, , MT, 15 (1 Oct. 1871), p. 248 Google Scholar.
23 For Malvern, see Advertisements: Malvern, , CT, 16 (19 July 1878), p. 415 Google Scholar; for Dunster, Advertisements: Dunster, , MT, 22 (1 July 1881), p. 337 Google Scholar; for Street, Wells, ‘Church news. St Andrew’s, Wells-street’, CT, 27 (13 Dec. 1889), p. 1,175 Google Scholar; for Liverpool, Advertisements: Liverpool, , MT, 21 (1 May 1880), p. 211.Google Scholar
24 For Street, Bryanston, see ‘Lay workers, organists, &c. [Bryanston-street]’, CT, 38 (6 Aug. 1897), p. 146 Google Scholar; for Bournemouth, , ‘Church and organ music [Bournemouth]’, MT, 42 (1 May 1901), p. 317 Google Scholar; for Newland, Chadwick, O., The Victorian Church, Part II, 2nd edn (London, 1972), p. 180.Google Scholar
25 Hopkinson, T., ‘Sunday choral festivals’, MS, ns 7 (8 Aug. 1874), p. 88 Google Scholar, and Parliamentary Papers 1854, xxv, p. 27.
26 Hopkinson, ‘Sunday choral festivals’, pp. 77-8, 88.
27 For number of choristers, see Salisbury, Salisbury Cathedral Library, Chapter Acts Books, xxvi, p. 46 (22 Nov. 1864), and York, York Minster Library, MS Add. 157/2 (Scrapbook 1859-1908), p. 341h (1874); for Ely, Curwen, The Boy’s Voice, p. 80; for St Paul’s, ‘St Paul’s Choir Boys. Sir George Martin vindicates their absence’, p. 120.
28 Box, C., Church Music in the Metropolis: Its Past and Present Condition (London, 1884)Google Scholar, passim; Temperley, Music of the English Parish Church, 1, p. 282.
29 Fleming, A Treatise on the Training of Boys’ Voices, pp. 25-6.
30 For Leeds, Sheffield and Halifax, see Spark, W., Musical Reminiscences: Past and Present (London, 1892), pp. 69, 179, 193 Google Scholar; for Soho, , Curwen, J. S., Studies in Worship Music (First Series) Chiefly as Regards Congregationat Singing, 2nd edn (London, 1888), p. 376 Google Scholar; for Marylebone, , ‘Chats with the clergy. The Rev. Canon Baker, Rector of St Marylebone’, CB, 30 (8 June 1900), p. 581.Google Scholar
31 ‘Canon Pennefather and his work. St Mary Abbotts, Kensington: the church, the vicar, and the parish’, CB, 29 (13 Oct. 1899), p. 956.
32 Jebb, J., The Choral Service of the United Church of England and Ireland: being an Enquiry into the Liturgical System of the Cathedral and Collegiate Foundations of the Anglican Communion (London, 1843), p. 246 Google Scholar; Dickson, W. E., Fifty Years of Church Music (Ely, 1894), p. 23 Google Scholar; ‘Laicus Oxoniensis’, ‘Church music at Oxford’, The Parish Choir [hereafter PC], no. 22 (Oct. 1847), p. 54.
33 For Norwich, see Rainbow, B., The Choral Revival in the Anglican Church 1839-1872 (London, 1970), p. 245 Google Scholar; for Durham, ‘Alto’, ‘Report on church music in the Diocese of Durham’, PC, no. 17 (May 1847), p. 135, and W. Hillsman, ‘Trends and aims in Anglican church music 1870-1906 in relation to developments in churchmanship’ (Oxford D.Phil, thesis, 1985), p. 309.
34 For distribution, see ‘J.A.’, ‘Defects in the cathedral service’, PC, no. 6 (July 1846), p. 47; for entry, Jebb, Choral Service, p. 229; for cassocks and surplices, Rainbow, Choral Revival, p. 253.
35 For Ely, see ‘Cathedral musical enquiry, no. 1—Ely Cathedral’, MS, ns 9 (2 Oct. 1875), p. 223; for Chester, P. C. Moore, ‘Cathedral worship in England from the Reformation to the nineteenth century’ (Oxford D.Phil, thesis, 1954), p. 371; for Westminster Abbey, ‘Musical opinion’, MS, ns 1 (27 May 1871), pp. 44-5.
36 For Commissioners, see Parliamentary Papers 1854, xxv, p. 42; for Norwich, Kitton, F. G., Zechariah Buck, Mus. D., Cantuar. Organist and Master of the Choristers at Norwich Cathedral 1817-1877. A Centenary Memoir (London, 1899), p. 62 Google Scholar.
37 For merged schools, see York, York Minster Library, ‘Chapter Minutes 1883-1909’, p. 101 (5 Oct. 1887), and F. A. G. Ouseley, ‘On the education of choristers in cathedrals’, in Howson, J. S., ed., Essays on Cathedrals. By Various Writers (London, 1872), pp. 216–17 Google Scholar; for boarding arrangements, see Bumpus, J. S., The Organists and Composers of S. Paul’s Cathedral (London, 1891), pp. 185–6 Google Scholar; for reduced cathedral income, see York, York Minster Library, MS Add. 157/2, Scrapbook 1869-1908, p. 371b(14 Jan. 1887).
38 For Salisbury and Lincoln, see The Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Magazine (Dec. 1937-Dec. 1939), p. 214, and Parliamentary Papers 1854-5, xv. PP. 74-9; for Wesley, , Wesley, S. S., Reply to the Inquiries of the Cathedral Commissioners, relative to the Improvement in the Music of Divine Worship in Cathedrals (London, 1854), p. 16 Google Scholar; for Done, , Barrett, P., ‘English cathedral choirs in the nineteenth century’,JEH, 25 (Jan. 1974), p. 34 Google Scholar; for Canterbury, Parliamentary Papers 1871, lx, p. 199.
39 Ouseley, ‘On the education of choristers in cathedrals’, p. 225.
40 Venables, E. M., Sweet Tones Remembered: Magdalen Choir in the Days of Varley Roberts (Oxford, 1947)Google Scholar. preface, pp. vii-ix.
41 For Winchester, see W. R. W. Stephens, ‘Cathedral choristers’, The Guardian [hereafter GD], 53 (20 July 1898), p. 1,142; for Worcester, , Woodward, H. H., ‘Cathedral choristers’, GD, 53 (20 July 1898), p. 1,142 Google Scholar; for Bristol, Moore, ‘Cathedral worship’, p. 372; for Salisbury, , Robertson, D. H., Sarum Close: A History of the Life and Education of the Cathedral Choristers for 700 Years (London, 1938), p. 3’9 Google Scholar; for the Temple, , Lewer, D., A Spiritual Song: The Story of the Temple Choir and a History of Divine Service in the Temple Church, London (London, 1961), p. 224 Google Scholar; for Lincoln, ‘Dotted Crotchet’, ‘Lincoln Cathedral’, MT, 45 (1 May 1904), p. 299; for Oxford, , Tenbury, and Royal, Chapel, Fisher, H., The Musical Profession (London, 1888), p. 16.Google Scholar
42 Pine, E., The Westminster Abbey Singers (London, 1953), p. 228.Google Scholar
43 For standards, see ‘Cathedral progress’, MS, 4th ser., 39(11 Oct. 1890), pp. 301-2; for men’s-voice services, Cambridge, Cambridge University Library, EDC 2/1/8 ([Ely] ‘Dean & Chapter Order Book 1863 to 1888’), pp. 349-50 (14 June 1888); for holidays, Lichfield, Lichfield Joint Record Office, ‘Lichfield Chapter Acts Book vol. 16 1896-1908’, p. 136 (7 March 1902).
44 Gorham, D., The Victorian Giri and the Feminine Ideal (London and Canberra, 1982), pp. 8, 51.Google Scholar
45 Burstyn, J. N., Victorian Education and the Ideal of Womanhood (London and Totowa, NJ, 1980), p. 42.Google Scholar
46 Coleman, L., ‘The music of the English Church’, The Church Magazine (Sept. 1886), p. 234.Google Scholar
47 Church Music in Town and Country. By ‘The Stranger Within Thy Gates’ (London, 1881), p. 34; L. Coleman, ‘The music of the English Church’, p. 234; and Walker, C., Three Months in an English Monastery: A Personal Narrative (London, 1864), p. 58.Google Scholar
48 Personal letter to the author from the Revd Brian Findlay of Bolton, 17 June 1993.
49 For High-Church foundations, see Avery, G., The Best Type of Girl: A History of Girls’ Independent Schools (London, 1991), p. 155 Google Scholar; for Wantage, ‘Reminiscences of Wantage’, S Mary’s School [Wantage] Magazine (Christmas 1908), p. 17, and Sr Phyllis, C.S.M.V., St Mary’s School: a Personal History (Wantage, 1973), p. 12; for Ascot, ‘School notes’, Heathfield School Magazine [hereafter HSM] (1899-1901), p. 5, and G. O. F. Griffith, ‘The Chapel of the Ascension’, HSM (1903), p. 44.
50 Macpherson, V. M., The Story of S Anne’s, Abbots Bromley, 1874-1924 (Shrewsbury, 1924), pp. 123, 128.Google Scholar
51 Ibid., p. 124.
52 Hillsman, ‘Trends and aims’, p. 165.
53 Ibid., p. 164.
54 Much of the information in this paragraph is drawn from conversations with Denis Townhill of Edinburgh (20 July 1993), Paul Trepte of Ely (19 July 1993), and Richard Seal of Salisbury (13 July 1993).
55 R. Gledhill. ‘Girls strike a sour note in the cloisters’, The Times (17 July 1993), p. 8.