Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-03T20:44:31.506Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

British Sunday Schools: An Educational Arm of the Churches, 1900–39

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2019

Caitriona McCartney
Caitriona McCartney*
Affiliation:
University of Durham
*
*67 Rykneld Rd, Littleover, Derby, DE23 4BH. E-mail: [email protected].
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Throughout much of the twentieth century, Sunday schools in Britain played a significant role, both disseminating and forming Christian faith. There was near universal attendance at the schools, and as a result there was widespread exposure to Christian teaching and hymnody. Despite this, their role as an educational arm of the churches is under-researched. This article considers the experience of the schools from the beginning of the century until the outbreak of the Second World War. It examines how and what Sunday schools taught during this time, and the extent to which they adopted pedagogical developments. The article also considers the responses of the schools to the various education acts passed in this period. In addition, it examines what the schools themselves, their scholars and the churches thought of their effectiveness, and reflects upon the tensions that arose between the schools and the churches. The article concludes that Sunday schools were an integral part of the churches’ educational reach in society and therefore deserve much more thorough examination by historians.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 55: CHURCHES AND EDUCATION , June 2019 , pp. 561 - 576
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Laqueur, Thomas, Religion and Respectability: Sunday Schools and Working Class Culture 1780–1850 (London, 1976), 245Google Scholar.

2 McLeod, Hugh, Religion and Society in England, 1850–1914 (London, 1996), 78CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Field, Clive, Secularization in the Long 1960s: Numerating Religion in Britain (Oxford, 2017), 45CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 McLeod, Religion and Society in England, 36; Sarah Williams, Religious Belief and Popular Culture in Southwark, c.1880–1939 (Oxford, 1999), 142; Dorothy Entwistle, ‘“Hope, Colour, and Comradeship”: Loyalty and Opportunism in early Twentieth-Century Church Attendance among the Working Class in North-West England’, JRH 25 (2001), 20–38, at 24.

5 Frank Prochaska, Christianity and Social Service in Modern Britain: The Disinherited Spirit (Oxford, 2006), 41.

6 Philip Cliff, The Rise and Development of the Sunday School Movement in England 1780–1980 (Redhill, 1986), 205–18, 219–37.

7 Laqueur, Religion and Respectability.

8 Malcolm Dick, ‘The Myth of the Working-Class Sunday School’, HE 9 (1980), 27–41, at 36.

9 Keith Snell, ‘The Sunday-School Movement in England and Wales: Child Labour, Denominational Control and Working-Class Culture’, P&P 164 (1999), 122–68, at 133.

10 Mark Griffiths, One Generation from Extinction: How the Church connects with the Unchurched Child (Oxford, 2009); Naomi Stanton, ‘From Raikes’ Revolution to Rigid Institution: Sunday Schools in Twentieth-Century England’, in Ruth Gilchrist et al., eds, Reflecting on the Past: Essays in the History of Youth and Community Work (Lyme Regis, 2011), 71–91; Naomi Thompson, Young People and Church since 1900: Engagement and Exclusion (London, 2017).

11 Griffiths, One Generation, 23–48, 57–61.

12 Stanton, ‘Raikes’ Revolution’, 77–89.

13 For example, see Richard Schweitzer, The Cross and the Trenches: Religious Faith and Doubt among British and American Great War Soldiers (London, 2003), 6; Alan Wilkinson, The Church of England and the First World War (London, 1996), 239; James Kitchen, The British Imperial Army in the Middle East: Morale and Military Identity in the Sinai and Palestine Campaigns, 1916–18 (London, 2014), 75. For a reassessment of the importance of Sunday school education during the First World War, see Caitriona McCartney, ‘British Sunday Schools and the First World War’, Kirchliche Zeitgeschichte / Contemporary Church History 31/1 (2018), 107–17.

14 Jeffrey Cox, English Churches in a Secular Society: Lambeth 1870–1930 (Oxford, 1987), 95–7.

15 S. J. D. Green, Religion in the Age of Decline: Organisation and Experience in Industrial Yorkshire, 1870–1920 (Cambridge, 1996), 215.

16 W. H. Watson, The First Fifty Years of the Sunday School (London, 1862), 6.

17 Cecil Northcott, For Britain's Children: The Story of the Sunday Schools and of the National Sunday School Union (London, 1952), 13.

18 Griffiths, One Generation, 43.

19 Northcott, Britain's Children, 13.

20 Ibid. 14.

21 Cliff, Rise and Development, 2.

22 Griffiths, One Generation, 37.

23 Northcott, Britain's Children, 17.

24 Stanton, ‘Raikes’ Revolution’, 74.

25 Stephen Orchard, ‘Introduction’ to idem and John Briggs, eds, The Sunday School Movement: Studies in the Growth and Decline of Sunday Schools (Bletchley, 2007), xiii–xix, at xvii. The impact of the Education Acts on the Sunday schools will be explored further below.

26 John MacKenzie, Propaganda and Empire: The Manipulation of British Public Opinion 1880–1960 (Manchester, 1984), 206.

27 ‘The Sunday School: The People's University’, Sunday School Chronicle (hereafter: SSC), 10 May 1923, 286.

28 Albert Dunning, ‘Report of the International Lesson Committee’, in The World's Third Sunday School Convention: Held in London, July 11th to July 16th, 1898 (Chicago, IL, 1898), 137–40, at 137.

29 Gerald Knoff, The World Sunday School Movement; The Story of a Broadening Mission (New York, 1979), 35.

30 Cliff, Rise and Development, 230.

31 Barrow-in-Furness, Barrow Archive and Local Studies Centre, BDFCBWM/11/7/1, Vickerstown Sunday School Teacher's Minute Book 1908–1922, 73 (5 February 1913); London, LMA, ACC/1361/05/002, Ferme Park Baptist Church, Sunday School Minute Book 1912–1918, 13 January 1912; Edinburgh, National Records of Scotland, CH11/21/10, Roxburgh Primitive Methodist Church, Sunday School Teacher's Minutes 1907–1916, 5 December 1912.

32 London, CERC, SSI/2/1/10, Sunday School Institute General Committee Book 1914–1922, 384 (1 July 1919).

33 Church Missionary Society, Sunday School Missionary Lessons (London, 1900), 1–7.

34 CERC, SSI/2/1/8, Sunday School Institute General Committee Book 1900–1907, 412 (7 February 1905).

35 ‘Temperance Notes’, SSC, 4 January 1900, 13; ‘A Pledge Signing Campaign’, SSC, 29 May 1924, 330.

36 ‘How to celebrate Armistice Sunday in the Sunday School’, SSC, 30 October 1930, 842.

37 Manchester, JRL, Methodist Archive, DDEy/7/1, Wesleyan Methodist Sunday School Department General Committee Minutes 1908–24, 270 (9 October 1919).

38 Birmingham, CRL, National Christian Education Council (hereafter: NCEC), Part 1, D10, Volume containing annual reports for 1906–7 to 1909–10, report for 1907–8, 40; ‘Studying the Child’, SSC, 7 January 1904, 18; Miss Huntley, ‘Sunday-School Work’, in Mundesley: Verbatim Report of Sermons and Lectures (London, 1910), 185–286, at 189–99.

39 M. Smith, ‘Froebel and Religious Education’, Early Child Development and Care 12 (1983), 303–17, at 303.

40 Meike Baader, ‘Froebel and the Rise of Education Theory in the United States’, Studies in Philosophy and Education 23 (2004), 427–44, at 431.

41 Smith, ‘Froebel’, 311.

42 Ibid. 312.

43 Sang-Wook Lee, Roy Evans and Peter Jackson, ‘Froebel in the Sunday School Movements of England and the USA’, Early Child Development and Care 110 (1995), 89–99, at 97.

44 ‘Studying the Child’, SSC, 7 January 1904, 18; Miss Huntley, Sunday-School Work, 199–214.

45 The Manual of the Wesleyan Methodist Sunday School (London, 1912), 35–6.

46 Cardiff, Glamorgan Archives, DECONG10/23, Windsor Road Congregational Church, Sunday School Teacher's Minutes 1907–28, 13 February 1907; ‘The Graded Sunday School: Need for Teachers’, Burnley Express, 23 October 1912, 6.

47 CERC, SSI/2/1/8, General Committee Book 1900–7, 549–50 (6 November 1907).

48 Ibid., SSI/2/1/9, General Committee Book 1907–14, 365–7 (5 December 1911).

49 Cliff, Sunday School Movement, 230.

50 Ibid. 231.

51 Griffiths, One Generation, 231.

52 Stanton, ‘Raikes’ Revolution’, 75.

53 Clive Field, ‘“The Faith Society”? Quantifying Religious Belonging in Edwardian Britain, 1901–1914’, JRH 37(2013), 39–63, at 58.

54 Clive Field, ‘Gradualist or Revolutionary Secularization? A Case Study of Religious Belonging in Inter-War Britain, 1918–1939’, CHRC 93(2013), 57–93, at 86.

55 Stanton, ‘Raikes’ Revolution’, 75.

56 ‘The Sunday School Teacher's Turn’, SSC, 9 November 1922, 277.

57 ‘Sixteen Years of Sunday School Leadership’, SSC, 12 July 1923, 431.

58 Barrow Archive and Local Studies Centre, BDFCBWM/1/4/1, Barrow Wesleyan Methodist Circuit Sunday School Council Minute Book 1912–48, 2–3 (3 June 1912); BDFCPM/1/6, Barrow-in-Furness Primitive Methodist Circuit Sunday School Committee Minutes 1900–17, 1 September 1900.

59 NCEC report for 1907–8, 37–9.

60 Sunday School Institute General Purposes Committee 1907–14, 278 (6 December 1910).

61 For example, see James Murphy, Church, State and Schools in Britain, 1800–1970 (London, 1971); N. R. Gullifer, ‘Opposition to the 1902 Education Act’, Oxford Review of Education 8 (1982), 83–98.

62 Murphy, Church, State and Schools, 2.

63 Ibid. 1.

64 James Munson, The Nonconformists: In Search of a Lost Culture (London, 1991), 246.

65 Murphy, Church, State and Schools, 92.

66 Ibid. 90.

67 ‘The Rights of the Child’, SSC, 5 June 1902, 397.

68 Glamorgan Archives, DBAP49/3/1, Splott Road Baptist Church, Sunday School Minute Book 1896–1911, 30 September 1902.

69 Prochaska, Christianity and Social Service, 150.

70 ‘The Education Act: Are the Churches Preparing’, SSC, 5 December 1918, 583.

71 ‘The Sunday School Teacher's Turn’, SSC, 9 November 1922, 277.

72 Stanton, ‘Raikes’ Revolution’, 75.

73 On the interplay between church day schools and Sunday schools, see, in this volume, Grant Masom, ‘Fighting the Tide: Church Schools in South Buckinghamshire, 1902–44’, 545–60.

74 ‘Sunday School Convention’, Aberdeen Press and Journal, 19 September 1910, 6.

75 Hayes, Ernest, Raikes the Pioneer: Founder of Sunday Schools (London, 1930), 122Google Scholar.

76 ‘The Education Bill: The Opportunity of the Sunday School’, SSC, 11 December 1902, 851.

77 London, LPL, Davidson papers, vol. 496, fol. 165.

78 CRL, NCEC, Part 1, D157, Guidance Leaflet for the Sunday School Advance Campaign (c.1930s), ‘Sunday School Advance: The Adolescent Campaign, Your Sunday School Job: A Survey and a Challenge’, 4.

79 London, London School of Economics, Booth/B350, ‘George H. Duckworth's Notebook: Police and Publican District 7 [Mile End Old Town and Spitalfields], District 8 [Aldgate, St George's in the East, Shadwell], District 9 [Bethnal Green, North and South], District 10 [Bethnal Green East], District 11 [Poplar and Limehouse]’ (online edn, 2016), 122, at: <http://booth.lse.ac.uk/notebooks/b350#?cv=61&c=0&m=0&s=0&z=-18.679%2C0%2C2493.358%2C1483>, accessed 29 December 2016.

80 Stanton, ‘Raikes’ Revolution’, 78; Griffiths, One Generation from Extinction, 268.

81 ‘Sunday Schools Conference at Exeter’, Exeter and Plymouth Gazette, 10 April 1913, 4.

82 Currie, Robert, Gilbert, Alan and Horsley, Lee, Churches and Churchgoers: Patterns of Church Growth in the British Isles since 1700 (Oxford, 1977), 128–9Google Scholar, 167.

83 Ibid. 133–4, 169–70, 172–3, 142–3, 178–9, 149–50, 181–90.

84 Griffiths, One Generation, 46.

85 Thompson, Young People, 32; Doreen Rosman, ‘Sunday Schools and Social Change in the Twentieth Century’, in Orchard and Briggs, eds, Sunday School Movement, 149–60, at 151.

86 Rosman, ‘Sunday Schools’, 151.

87 Thompson, Young People, 44.

88 LPL, Davidson papers, vol. 88, fol. 57 (18 February 1903).

89 Church Assembly Report of the Commission on Religious Education appointed by the Archbishops of Canterbury and York (London, 1929), 18.

90 Holloway, H. J., ‘The Church's Attitude to the Youth of To-Day’, in Methodism: Its Present Responsibilities. The Proceedings of the Methodist Church Congress (London, 1929), 111–15Google Scholar, at 112.