Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T02:17:20.952Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘School Milk’ in the Context of the Australian Dairy Industry

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 March 2016

VIRGINIA THORLEY
VIRGINIA THORLEY*
Affiliation:
School of Historical and Philosophical Inquiry, Room E306, Forgan Smith Building, The University of Queensland, St Lucia, QLD 4072, Australia [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Australia, as with a number of other countries with dairy industries, established a national school milk scheme which operated from 1951 to the beginning of 1974 at no cost to the children's families. The scheme, funded by the federal government and administered by the states, ended abruptly after costs blew out, with resultant losses by the industry. This article describes the limited provision of milk in schools in two states prior to the national scheme and how, after the cessation of the national scheme, dairy industry initiatives in some states were gradually developed to market liquid cow's milk, including flavoured products, at subsidised prices to school children who were perceived as potential lifelong consumers. The article traces the rise and decline of these schemes in the late twentieth century within the context of moves towards dairy deregulation and its effects on the industry.

Keywords

dairy industrydairy marketingschool milkdairy deregulation
Type
Research Article
Information
Rural History , Volume 27 , Issue 1 , April 2016 , pp. 103 - 117
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. Thorley, Virginia, ‘Australian School Milk Schemes to 1974: For the Benefit of Whom?’ Health and History, 16:2 (2014), 63–86 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2. Welshman, John, ‘School Meals and Milk in England and Wales 1906–45’, Medical History, 41 (1997), 6–29 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

3. Ibid.

4. Goldsmith, M. J., ‘Pressures within Pressures’, Political Studies, 13 (1965), 235–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5. Atkins, Peter J., ‘Fattening Children or Fattening Farmers? School Milk in Britain, 1921–1941’, Economic History Review, 58 (2005), 57–78 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Atkins, Peter, ‘The Milk in Schools Scheme, 1934–45: “Nationalisation” and “Resistance”’, History of Education, 34 (2005), 1–21 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Welshman, ‘School Meals and Milk’, 6–29.

6. Martiin, Carin, ‘Swedish Milk, A Swedish Duty: Dairy Marketing in the 1920s and 1930s’, Rural History, 21 (2010), 213–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7. Peter J. Atkins, ‘The Pasteurisation of England: The Science, Culture and Health Implications of Milk Processing, 1900–1950’, in D. F. Smith and J. Phillips, eds, Food, Science, Policy and Regulation in the Twentieth Century (2000), 37–51; Atkins, Peter J., ‘White Poison: The Health Consequences of Milk Consumption, 1850–1930’, Social History of Medicine, 5 (1992), 207–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8. Atkins, Peter J., ‘School Milk in Britain, 1900–1934’, Journal of Policy History, 19:4 (2007), 395–427 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9. Atkins, ‘Milk in Schools Scheme’, 1–21.

10. ‘Nutrition – Milk’, Appendix A, in ‘Milk for School Children’, federal cabinet documents, File No. C660 [1996]; A. J. Forbes, ‘Milk for School Children, Submission’, No. 47, clause 9(d), File No. 660, December (1969), National Archives of Australia (hereafter NAA).

11. Ibid.

12. ‘War-Time Marketing of Australian Primary Products’ [feature article], Year Book Australia, 36, 1944–45 (Canberra, 1945), 1105.

13. ‘Free Milk for Children: Big Federal Scheme’, Sydney Morning Herald, 1st July 1950, 7.

14. Ibid.

15. Bridge, Carl, ‘Page, Sir Earle Christmas (1880–1961)’, in Australian Dictionary of Biography (Melbourne, 1988)Google Scholar, volume 11.

16. State Grants (Milk for School Children) Act (1950).

17. Social Welfare Branch, Prime Minister's Department, ‘Milk for School Children’, Notes of Cabinet Submission No. 47, File No. C660, 30th December 1969, NAA.

18. Earle Page, Second Reading Speech, ‘States Grants (Milk for School Children) Bill 1950’, House of Representatives, [Personal Papers of Prime Minister Page], Series No. M4330, NAA.

19. New Zealand Milk Board, New Zealand's Milk in Schools Scheme 1937–1967 (Wellington, New Zealand, 1978)Google Scholar.

20. Forbes, ‘Milk for School Children’, Submission No. 47, clauses 9(a), 11. File No. 660, December (1969), NAA; Cabinet Notebook 1/9 (1950), NAA: A11099, 1/9, 2.

21. ‘Free milk for school children’, Cabinet Minute, Decision No. 1756(WEL), 10th December 1973, Series No. A5931, NAA.

22. Atkins, ‘School Milk in Britain, 1900–1934’, 395–427.

23. Atkins, ‘White Poison’, 207–27.

24. C. L. Hewitt to Prime Minister [Robert Menzies], letter, 6th January 1970. CLH:RM. C660, NAA; Social Welfare Branch, Cabinet Submission No. 47, NAA; Meadmore, Peter, ‘No Nonsense, No Frills: Recounting State Schooling in Post-War Queensland’, in Colin Symes and Robyn Sheahan-Bright, School's Out: Learning to be a Writer in Queensland: An Anthology in Six Lessons (Kelvin Grove, QLD, 1998), 101 Google Scholar; Queensland Government, Department of Education, Training and Employment, ‘Free milk scheme’, 2. Available at http://education.qld.gov.au/library/edhistory/topics/milk.html

25. Social Welfare Branch, Cabinet Submission No. 47, NAA.

26. Block, Daniel Ralston, ‘Hawking Milk: The Public Health Profession, Pure Milk, and the Rise of Advertising in Early Twentieth-Century America’, in Walker, H., ed., Milk: Beyond the Dairy: Proceedings of the Oxford Symposium on Food and Cookery 1999 (Totnes, Devon, 2000), 86–92 Google Scholar.

27. H. Morrow Brown, ‘The Health Hazards of Milk’, in Walker, ed., Milk: Beyond the Dairy, 259–67.

28. Thorley, Virginia, ‘“There's Absolutely NO SUBSTITUTE for Fresh Milk”: Dairy Marketing in Australia, Twentieth Century’, International Journal of Liberal Arts and Social Science, 2:2 (2014), 1–14 Google Scholar.

29. Dairy Authority of New South Wales, 1974 Annual Report (Sydney, 1974); Mr [Michael] Ahern, question on ‘Proposed Abandonment of Free Milk Scheme for Schools’, Queensland Hansard, 25th September 1973, 678; Mr Tooth [Minister for Health], Queensland Hansard, 16th October 1973, 956.

30. Margaret Henderson, ‘Downturn at the Dairy (Part 4)’, Richmond River Historical Society (2002). http://www.richhistory.org.au/district_history_dairy_4.htm, accessed 18th February 2015. No pagination.

31. Edwards, Geoff, ‘The Story of Deregulation in the Dairy Industry’, Australian Journal of Agriculture and Resource Economics, 47 (2003), 75–98 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32. Ibid.

33. John Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW: Past and Present’, NSW Parliamentary Library Research Service, Briefing Paper No. 23/99 (1999), 8.

34. Cockfield, Geoff and Botterill, Linda, ‘Rural Adjustment Schemes: Juggling Politics, Welfare and Markets’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 65:2 (2006), 70–82 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; David Godden, ‘A Century of Agricultural Progress in Australia’, 43rd Annual Conference, Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, Christchurch, New Zealand, 20th-22nd January 1999, 4–5, 14.

35. ‘The Australian Dairy Industry’, in Year Book Australia, 2004 (Canberra, 2004), 446–56Google Scholar.

36. ‘War-Time Marketing of Australian Primary Products’, 1105.

37. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 3–4.

38. Henderson, ‘Downturn at the Dairy’.

39. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 2.

40. Henderson, ‘Downturn at the Dairy’; Godden, ‘A Century of Agricultural Progress’, 13, 17.

41. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 10; Camden News, 9th July 1931, 1.

42. Maitland Daily Mercury, 22nd October 1932, 4; Singleton Argus, 24th October 1932, 3; The Shoalhaven Telegraph, November 1932, 8.

43. ‘Zone System: “selfish request”: Milk Inquiry’, Northern Star (Lismore), 16th May 1936, 14 Google ScholarPubMed.

44. ‘Malanda Milk: To Townsville by Road’, Townsville Daily Bulletin, 7th February 1946, 4; ‘Road-Rail Still for Malanda Milk’, Townsville Daily Bulletin, 8th February 1946, 7; ‘Malanda Seeking Milk Rail Tanker’, Townsville Daily Bulletin, 6th January 1948, 2; ‘Fresher Milk Delivery for Townsville’, Townsville Daily Bulletin, 4th April 1952, 6.

45. Trisha Fielding, ‘Malanda Milk – A Household Name’. http://northqueenslandhistory.blogspot.com.au/2014/06/malanda-milk-household-name. . . ., accessed 18th February 2015.

46. Ayrshire Dairy, advertisement, Sunday Times (Perth), 27th June 1937, 22.

47. Godden, ‘A Century of Agricultural Progress’, 9.

48. Anderson, Jan, ‘Dairy Deregulation in Northern Queensland: The End of Traditional Farming?’ Anthropological Forum: A Journal of Social Anthropology and Comparative Sociology, 14 (2004), 269–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

49. Edwards, ‘Story of Deregulation’, 75–98.

50. Cocklin, Chris, and Dibden, Jacqui, ‘Taking Stock: Farmers’ Reflections on the Deregulation of Australian Dairying’, Australian Geographer, 33 (2002), 29–42 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

51. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 6–7, 24–6, 29–31, 32–3.

52. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 36.

53. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 37.

54. Cockfield and Botterill, ‘Rural Adjustment Schemes’, 70–82.

55. Anderson, ‘Dairy Deregulation’, 269–82.

56. Cockfield and Botterill, ‘Rural Adjustment Schemes’, 70–82.

57. Ibid.

58. Wilkinson, ‘Dairy Industry in NSW’, 37.

59. Lewis, Meredith Kolsky, ‘The EU's protectionist problem’, Georgetown Journal of International Affairs, 29 (2009), 23–9Google Scholar.

60. Ibid.

61. Carter, Colin A., ‘Some Trade Implications of the 2014 Agricultural Act’, Choices: The Magazine of Food, Farm, and Resource Issues, 29:3 (2014), 1–4 Google Scholar.

62. Alston, Margaret, ‘Who is Down on the Farm? Social Aspects of Australian Agriculture in the 21st Century’, Agricultural and Human Values, 21 (2004), 37–46 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63. Ibid.

64. Queensland Government, ‘Free Milk Scheme’, 2–3.

65. George Davey, ‘The Rise and Fall of Australian School Milk Programs’, presented at a conference on School Milk, Canada, June 2001. Speaker's notes, p. 16.

66. J. H. Snow (federal member of Eden-Monaro), speaking on Appropriation Bill (No. 1) 1994–95: Second Reading 1st June 1994, Federal Hansard, 1135; Davey, ‘Rise and Fall’, p. 8.

67. Davey, ibid.

68. [Ian] Causley, ‘Milk in Schools – Pilot Program’, New South Wales Hansard, 16th March 1994, 812; [Richard] Amery, ‘The Milk in Schools Program’, New South Wales Hansard, 4 April 2000, 4034.

69. Amery, ‘Milk in Schools Program’, 4034.

70. ‘School Milk Program in Jeopardy’, Sydney Morning Herald, 5th April 2000.

71. [Ian Douglas] Trezise, address-in-reply, Victorian Legislative Assembly, 9th November 1999.

72. New Zealand Milk Board, New Zealand's Milk in Schools Scheme 1937–1967 (Wellington, New Zealand, 1978)Google Scholar; I. A. Baker, P. C. Elwood, J. Hughes, M. Jones, P. M., Sweetnam, ‘School Milk and Growth in Primary School Children’, Lancet, North American edition, 2, issue 8089, 9th September 1978, 575.

73. Davey, ‘Rise and Fall’, 8.

74. Tasmanian Dairy Authority, ‘Marketing Activities: School Milk Project’, 1999 Annual Report, TA1096, AE633/1/21 (Tasmanian Archives).

75. Ibid.

76. Queensland Dairyfarmers’ Organisation, ‘School is Out!’, 1.

77. Frost, Fred, ‘The Changing Role of Governments’ Involvement in the Dairy Industry: A Delphi Study of its Future Role’, Journal of Contemporary Issues in Business and Government, 6:2 (2000), 42–54 Google Scholar.

78. Davey, ‘Rise and Fall’, 12; See also Tasmanian Dairy Industry Authority, ‘Marketing Activities’.

79. George Davey, ‘Making the Most Out of Milk: The History of Milk Marketing (NSW) Pty Limited’, July 1989 to June 2000 (Sydney, 2000), 7, 11.

80. Davey, ‘Making the Most’, 14–20.

81. Davey, ‘Rise and Fall’, 20–21; Davey, ‘Making the Most’, 1–16. See also J. H. Snow (Eden-Monaro), Appropriation Bill (No.1), 1994–1995: Second Reading. 1st June 1994. Federal Hansard, 1135.

82. Davey, ‘Rise and Fall’, 9.

83. Ibid., 8, 16.

84. Tasmanian Dairy Industry Authority, ‘Marketing Activities’.

85. Ibid.

86. Martiin, ‘Swedish Milk’, 213–32.

87. Amery, ‘Milk in Schools’, 4034.

88. Dick Adams (Lyons, ALP), ‘Private Members Business: Citrus Industry’, 6th August 2001, 29149 (House Hansard).

89. Vernon, Keith, ‘Milk and Milk Products’, in Kiple, Kenneth F. and Ornales, Kriemheld Coneè, eds., The Cambridge World History of Food (Cambridge, 2000), Volume 1, pp. 692–702 Google Scholar; see also Thorley ‘NO SUBSTITUTE for Fresh Milk’, 1–14.