Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T22:07:18.441Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Comparison between Brain Death and Unstable Life: Shi'ite Perspective

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 April 2015

Saeid Nazari Tavakkoli
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Death comes to us all. It is a reality that grips us all because we become separated from our loved ones. In all cultures, there is the hope that when death comes, it will be swift and will allow us to depart without prolonged suffering. There is also a social dimension to this inevitable event in human life: we hope that our death will not force hardship on family and friends, making them pay both financially and emotionally due to an uncertain condition that is created by a lingering spirit that does not sever its ties to the body. It is at such moments that we realize the importance of having a clear definition of death.

Brain death as a way of measuring when death comes is an issue that has recently been under scrutiny throughout the world of medicine, but it has also been hotly debated in Islamic jurisprudence as well. Thanks to advanced medical technology, it has now become possible to transplant body organs of a person suffering from brain death into the body of a needy ill person, but for the most part, successful transplantation must take place before the emergence of traditional death symptoms. Physicians and ethicists have struggled with the difficulty in offering a medical definition for brain death. The question that has arisen for Muslim jurists is whether, from the point of view of Islamic jurisprudence, someone suffering from brain death should be considered as dead for purposes of permitting transplantation of organs, or whether Muslims must treat a brain-dead patient as a living person from a legal and ethical perspective.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of Law and Religion , Volume 23 , Issue 2 , 2008 , pp. 605 - 627
Copyright
Copyright © Center for the Study of Law and Religion at Emory University 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Irrespective of the cellular life which any living organism possesses, the human-rational life of man begins when life is given to the fetus. Referring to various stages of the development of the fetus, the Qur'ān speaks of another creation of human being in the following verse: “Then We made the sperm into a clot of congealed blood; then of that clot We made a (fetus) lump; then we made out of that lump bones and clothed the bones with flesh; then we developed out of it another creature. So blessed be Allah, the best to create!” Q. 23: 14.

2. Describing death, the Qur'ān applies the verb WFY and its derivations. The word means “to complete a task.” When it is applied to describe death, it carries the meaning of the soul's departure from the body at time of death. Thus we read: “He is the irresistible, (watching) from above over His worshippers, and He sets guardians over you. At length, when death approaches one of you, Our angels take his soul, and they never fail in their duty.” Q. 6:61.

When the soul is separated from the body, the body remains in the physical world and disintegrates, but the soul passes into the intermediate realm (barzakh). Barzakh refers to a realm between this world and the resurrection; it is the passage for souls from this world to another after death. Human souls continuously enter the intermediate realm until the world comes to an end and the human being is resurrected on the Day of Judgment.

3. Because of the eminent position of man in Islam, harming the fetus in the process of fertilization when a male's sperm and female's egg fuse together and produce a single cell developing into an adult organism is forbidden. Moreover, the criminal is also responsible for the payment of blood money (dīya) as compensation for an injury or death. Although inflicting any injury to the fetus before it is completely gestated is forbidden, it can not be considered “homicide”(qatl al-nafs) until the fetus is ensouled after about four months. After that time, any action that causes abortion before birth, is considered homicide. For more information, see Muhsini, Muhammad Asef, al-Fiqh wa al-Masāil al-Tibbīyya 59–80 (n.d. Matbaat Yaran)Google Scholar.

4. Qaysari, Dawud ibn Mahmud, Matlao khosus Al-kalim fi ma'ani Fosus Al-Hikam, vol. 1, 113 (Anwar al-Huda 1416/1995)Google Scholar writes:

Know that from the point of its substance, its disengagement from substratum, and its existence the spirit (al-ruh) belongs to the world of the spirits, disengaged changing in the forms of corporeal body, linked to it, a linkage connected with governing and exercising free disposal, self-subsistent, not in need of it for its survival and for its support.

5. al-Hasan, Saffar Muhammad Ibn, Basa'ir ̀al-darajat al-kobra 483, Hadith no. 12 (Baqi, Mirza Mohsen Koche ed., Al Aalami Inst. 1404/1984)Google Scholar.

6. Razi, Fakr al-din Muhammad, al-Tafsir al-kabir, vol. 21, 45 (n.d. Dar al-Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi)Google Scholar.

7. See Kulayni, Muhammad ibn Yaqub, Al-Kafi, vol. 6, 13–14 & vol. 7, 347 (Dar al-Kutub al-Islamia 1388/1968)Google Scholar.

8. Babuya, Muhammad ibn Ali Ibn, ‘Ilal al-sharayi, vol. 1, 107–108 (Maktabat al-Heidareia 1385/1965)Google Scholar, relates a tradition on the authority of the sixth Imam al-Sadiq which reads:

Such is the creation of a human being. He is created for this world and the next. Hence, when God combines for him the two it becomes his life on earth because he has forgone the heaven for the sake of the world. Thus when God puts separation between the two, that separation becomes death. The matter reverts to the heaven, and in this way life on earth and death in the heaven due to the separation between the spirit and the body.

9. Shirazi (Mulla Sadra), in his explanation of natural death, says:

The basis for this is the freedom of the spirit from its inherent life and abandonment of using the bodily tools gradually until it becomes isolated by itself and frees itself totally from the body so that it can develop into the one commanding an act.

Shirazi, Sadr al-Din Muhammad (Sadra, Mulla), al-Shawahid al-Robubiyya fi al-Manahij al-solukiya 89 (1st ed., Ashtiani, Sayyid Jalal al-Din ed., Mashhad U.1386/1966)Google Scholar.

10. Hisham ibn al-Hakam asked the Imam al-Sadiq if the spirit is other than the blood. The Imam replied: “Yes, the spirit, as I have explained to you, is the substance from the blood. When the blood becomes cold [upon death] the spirit leaves the body.” See Tabarsi, Ahmad ibn Ali, al-Ihtijaj vol. 2, 97 (Dar al-Numan Inst. 1386/1966)Google Scholar.

11. Shi'ite jurists have discussed these criteria in their sections on blood money (diyat), due for destruction of a fetus, inheritance of a fetus, and so on. See e.g. al-Hilli, Jafar ibn al-Hasan Muhaqqiq, al-Mukhtasar al-Nafl' fi Fiqh al-Imamiya 274, 239 (Al-Beasa Instn. 1410/1989)Google Scholar; al-Hilli, Al-Hasan ibn Yusuf Allama, Tahrir al-Ahkam vol. 1, 278, vol. 2, 174Google Scholar; (Aal-ul-Bayt Instn., litho); Tusi, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, al-Mabsut fi fiqh al-Imamiah vol. 7, 200 (Kashfi, Muhammad Taqi ed., Al-Maktabat al-Murtazavi 1387/1967)Google Scholar; Mamaqani, Abdullah, Manahij al-Muttaqin fi Fiqh Aemmah al-Haqq wa al-Yaqin 530 (Aal ul-Bayt Instn. 1404/1984)Google Scholar; Khonsari, Ahmad, Jami' al-madarik fi Shark al-Mukhtasar al-Nafi' vol. 5, 371 (Maktabat al-saduq 1355/1936)Google Scholar.

12. Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 7, 342-343; Tusi, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, Tahdhib al-Ahkam Fi Sharhe Al-Muqne, vol. 10, 282, Hadith no. 1102 (Dar al-kotob al-islamia 1390/1970)Google Scholar; Mufid, Muhammad ibn Numan, al-Irshad fi ma'arifa hujaj Allah alal 'Ibad 119 (n.d. Al-Aalami Instn.)Google Scholar.

13. Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 6, 13-14 & vol. 7, 346-347.

14. Tusi, Tahdhib al-Ahkam, supra n. 12, at vol. 10, 281, Hadith no. 1100; vol. 1, 48, Hadith no. 1875; vol. 9, 392, Hadith no. 1398; vol. 9, 57, Hadith no. 238; Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 7, 345 & vol. 7, 155.

15. Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 7, 3432, Hadith no. 2.

16. Mufid, supra n. 12, at 119.

17. For detailed examination of various reports and the ultimate conclusion regarding the period of ensoulment, see Tavakkoli, Saeid Nazari, al-Tarqi' wa zar' al-a'da' fi al-fiqh al-islami 207–211 (Islamic Research Found., Astan Quds Razavi 1422/2001)Google Scholar.

18. Tabarsi, supra n. 10, at vol. 2, 97; Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 3, 134-135 & 3, 161-163; Ibn Babuya, ‘Ilal al-sharayi’, supra n. 8, at vol. 1, 309, § 261.

19. Nazari Tavakkoli, supra n. 17, at 212-216.

20. Q. 67:1-2.

21. Life and death are not contradictory; for death is not the absence of life. Rather, life is conceivable in two forms: in the physical and nonphysical (intermediate) body. The condition for entrance into the nonphysical world and living in any immaterial body is the spirit's passing from the physical body which is only possible by death. On account of this, death is not taking life away, but it is the separation of the soul from the body, the soul which once breathed into the body during the embryonic period, causes the human life to begin. Given such an approach, the Quran uses the term “creation” to account for death and life.

22. Razi, supra n. 6, at vol. 30, 54, writes:

It is said that life is a description for a person inasmuch as he can learn and act; the matter of death is different. Some say that it is actually a negation of this ability [to learn and to act]. We are of the opinion that this is a description of existence contrary to life and we argue that God, the Exalted says: “He is the one who created death,” because non-existence (al- ‘adam) is not creatable [on its own]. This is the conclusion.

23. See e.g. Tusi, Tahdhib al-Ahkam, supra n. 12, and other major works on Shi'ite jurisprudence cited in this article.

24. Tusi, al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at vol. 7, 203, 6, 260, 1, 390, 4, 124; Qudama, Abdullah ibn Ahmad Ibn, al-Mughni vol. 9, 373, no. 7717 (Dar al-kitab al-arabi n.d.)Google Scholar; al-Hilli, Muhammad ibn Mansur Ibn Idris, al-Sara'ir al-Hawi li Tahrir al-Fatawi, vol. 3, 96, 108–109 (Islamic Publg. Instn. 1410/1989)Google Scholar; Sarakhsi, Shams al-Din, al-Mabsut, vol. 12, 5 (Dar al-Maarefa 1406/1986)Google Scholar and numerous other juridical sources mention this distinction between “stable” and “unstable” life.

25. al-Hilli, Al-Hasan ibn yusuf Allama, Qawa'id al-Ahkam fi al-maarefat al-halal va al-haram, vol. 2, 155 (Manshurat Al-Razi)Google Scholar.

26. Ardabili, Maula Ahmad, Majma' al-Fa'ida wa al-Burhan fi sharhe Irshad al-azhan, vol. 11, 107 (Jameato al-modarresin 1403/1983)Google Scholar.

27. Khu'i, Al-Sayyed Abu al-Qasim al-Musawi, Mabani takmilat minhaj al-Salihin, vol. 2, 19 (Matbaah al-adab 1407/1987)Google Scholar; Tusi, al-Mabsut, fi fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at vol. 1, 390; al-Hindi, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan Fadil, Kashf al-litham vol. 2, 74 (Maktabat Al-Seyed Al-Marashi 1405/1985)Google Scholar.

28. al-Awwal, Muhammad ibn al-Makki Shahid, al-Durus al-shar'iyya fi Fiqh al-Imameia 277 (Al-Lazoardi, Al-Sayyid Mahdi ed., Maktaba Al-Sadeqi n.d.)Google Scholar.

29. Ardabili, supra n. 26, at vol. 11, 112.

30. Signs of Death, 1 Sci. J. Leg. Med. Org. Iran 46 (07 1994)Google ScholarPubMed.

31. Allama al-Hilli, Qawa'id al-Ahkam fi al-maarefat al-halal va al-haram, supra n. 25, at vol. 2, 336.

32. Khonsari, supra n. 25, at vol. 5, 371.

33. Goodarzi, Faramarz, Pizishki Qanuni 3 (Faculty of Jud. Police of Iranians Islamic Republic 1410/1989)Google Scholar.

34. al-Tarablosi, Ibn al-Barraj, al-Muhadhdhah, vol. 2, 463 (Islamic Publg. Instn. 1407/1987)Google Scholar; al-Hilli, Muhammad ibn Mansur Ibn Fahd, al-Muhadhdhab al-bari fi Sharh al-Mukhtasar al-Nafei', vol. 4, 169–170 (Islamic Publg. Instn. 1407/1987)Google Scholar.

35. Allama al-Hilli, Tahrir al-Aahkam, supra n. 11, at vol. 2, 159.

36. Ardabili, supra n. 26, at vol. 11, 121.

37. Ibn Idris al-Hilli, supra n. 24, at vol. 3, 108-109.

38. Tusi, al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at vol. 4, 124.

39. Fadil al-Hindi, supra n. 27, at vol. 2, 75; Najafi, Muhammad Hasan, Jawahir al-Kalam fi shark Shraie al-Islam, vol. 36, 148 (al-Quchani, Shaykh Abbas ed., Dar al-Kutub al-Islamia 1400/1980)Google Scholar; al-Nawawi, Mohie al-Din ibn al-sharaf Ibn, al-Majmu' fi sharh al-Muhadhdhab, vol. 9, 89 (Dar al-Fikr n.d.)Google Scholar; Amili, Sayyid Muhammad Jawad, Miftah al-Karama fi sharh qawa 'id al-Allama, vol. 46, 8 (Aal ul-Bayt Instn. n.d.)Google Scholar.

40. Najafi, supra n. 39, at vol. 36, 149.

41. Id.

42. Amili, supra n. 39, at vol. 8, 244.

43. Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 7, 8, Hadith no. 7, 1.

44. Babuya, Muhammad ibn Ali Ibn, al-Amali 125 (Al-Aalami Lil-Matbuat Instn.)Google Scholar.

45. Ibn Qudama, supra n. 24, at vol. 8, 300; Tusi, al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at vol. 6, 259, and other sources on Islamic juridical corpus.

46. Ardabili, supra n. 26, at vol. 11, 121.

47. A Definition of Irreversible Coma, 205 J. Am. Med. Assn. 337–340 (08 5, 1968)CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

48. Id.

49. Korein, Juliuset al., Radioisotopic Bolus Technique as a Test to Detect Circulatory Deficit Associated with Cerebral Death, 51 Circulation 924–939 (05 1975)CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

50. Mohaqqiq al-Hilli, al-Mukhtasar al-Nafe i 'fi Fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at 274.

51. Mamaqani, supra n. 11, at 530; al-Hilli, Allama, Tahrir al-Ahkam, vol. 2, 174Google Scholar.

52. Tofiqi, Hasan, Brain Death, 8 Sci. J. Leg. Med. Org. Iran 68 (06 1996)Google Scholar.

53. Tusi, al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at vol. 6, 275.

54. Tofiqi, supra n. 52, at 45.

55. Id. at 58-59.

56. Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 3/209-210; Tusi, Tahdhib al-Ahkam fi Sharhe Al-Muqne, supra n. 12, at vol. 1, 337, Hadith no. 988.

57. Tofiqi, supra n. 52, at 73.

58. Id. at 59-65.

59. Id. at 73.

60. As a result, in circumstances in which an individual has an unstable life, because of the lack of potential for continuation of life, he or she is regarded as dead. However, if one has suffered brain death, in view of the fact that the body still has the potential for continuation of life, the separation of the soul from the body is not certain and the individual is considered as alive. On this basis, the rules of the Islamic jurisprudence concerning a dead body apply to anybody with unstable life as well, but not to one who has suffered brain death.

61. Kulayni, supra n. 7, at vol. 7, 7, Hadith no. 1, 2, 7, 9.

62. Tusi, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, Al-Khilaf, vol. 4, 164, no. 18 (Islamic Publg. Instn. 1407/1986)Google Scholar; Allama al-Hilli, Qawa 'id al-Ahkam fi al-maarefat al-halal va al-haram, supra n. 25, at vol. 2, 444.

63. Tusi, al-Mabsut fi Fiqh al-Imamiah, supra n. 11, at vol. 4, 43-44; Nazari Tavakkoli, supra n. 17, at 231-232.

64. al-Hilli, Al-Hasan ibn yusuf Allama, mukhtalaf al-Shi 'iafi ahkam al-sharia, vol. 5, 383 (Manshurat Al-Razi)Google Scholar; Al-Sayyid, Ruh Allah al-Musawi Khumayni, Tahrir al-wasila, vol. 1, 649, no. 6 (Dar al-kotob al-ilmyya 1409/1983)Google Scholar.

65. Najafi, supra n. 39, at, vol. 32, 274.

66. Allama al-Hilli, Qawa'id al-Ahkam, supra n. 25, at vol. 3, 588; Tusi, al-Mabsut, supra n. 11, at vol. 7, 203; al-Thani, Shahid, Masalik al-Afnam fi Sharh shrai al-Islam, vol. 15, 92 (Maarif al-Islamia Instn. 1413/1993)Google Scholar; al-Hilli, Jafar ibn al-Hasan Mohaqqiq, Shraie al-Islamfi Masail al-halalva al-haram, vol. 4, 976 (Isteqlal 1409/1983)Google Scholar.

67. Khu'i, Al-Sayyed Abu al-Qasim al-Musawi, Minhaj al-Salihin, vol. 2, 356, no. 1727 (Madinah al-Eilm 1410/1989)Google Scholar.

68. Nazari Tavakkoli, supra n. 17, at 228-229.