Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-vdxz6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T21:49:50.539Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Costs of Pew-renting: Church Management, Church-going and Social Class in Nineteenth-century Glasgow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 March 2011

Callum G. Brown
Callum G. Brown
Affiliation:
Department of History, University of Strathclyde, McCance Building, 16 Richmond Street, Glasgow G1 1XQ
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The letting of pews was virtually a universal practice in the churches of nineteenth-century Britain. Although letting and private ownership of seats were well known before the 1700s and have continued in the present century, the renting of fixed seats for use during divine service reached its height in the Victorian period. Worshippers paid anything from one shilling to thirty shillings or more to reserve a seat for one person for a year. It thus became a considerable expense to accommodate a large family. By its ubiquity it is clear that the practice was accepted by church-goers as a facet of ecclesiastical life and was accepted by church authorities as a necessary feature of congregational management. But the fact that the system was generally introduced and operated at the discretion of individual congregations or their owners and patrons, with little or no interference from denominational authorities, has meant that comparatively meagre attention has been paid to how it worked in practice and to what its effects were on congregational life.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 38 , Issue 3 , July 1987 , pp. 347 - 361
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1987

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 It is notable that one of the most detailed expositions of the system's effects came in a local study (of Sheffield): Wickham, E. R., Church and People in an Industrial City, London 1969, 42–3,Google Scholar 47-9, 57-8, 72-3, 114-15, 142-3 and appendix III. See also Inglis, K. S., Churches and the Working Classes in Victorian England, London 1963, 48–57,Google Scholar 96-7, 106-8, 129-30.

2 A vociferous opponent in Scotland was the Revd James Begg who campaigned for the new Free Church of 1843 to be free of the system: Begg, J., Seat Rents Brought to the Test of Scripture, Law, Reason and Experience, Edinburgh 1838;Google Scholaridem, Reasons why no Seat-rents should be in the Free Church, Edinburgh n.d.

3 Inglis, loc. cit.

4 MacLaren, A. A., Religion and Social Class: the Disruption years in Aberdeen, London 1974, 132–6;Google ScholarScott, D., Annals and Statistics of the Original Secession Church, Edinburgh 1886, 460–2;Google ScholarJohnson, C., Developments in the Roman Catholic Church in Scotland 1789-1829, Edinburgh 1983, 142–5Google Scholar.

5 Chartist Circular, quoted in Purdie, J., ‘The religion and politics of Scottish Christian Chartism 1839-43’, unpublished BA diss., University of Strathdyde 1980, 39Google Scholar.

6 Brown, C. G., ‘Religion and the development of an urban society: Glasgow 1780-1914’, unpublished PhD diss., University of Glasgow 1982, i. 182–4.Google Scholar

7 Bridges, J., Patronage in the Church of Scotland Considered, Edinburgh 1840, 42.Google Scholar

8 McPherson, J., The Kirk's Care of the Poor, Aberdeen n.d. (c. 1941), 79–84;Google ScholarLindsay, J., The Scottish Poor Law: its operation in the North-east from 1745 to 1845, Hfracombe 1975, 125–6Google Scholar.

9 The position was uniquely complicated in Edinburgh by the addition of the Annuity Tax on property which provided parish ministers' stipends, , Begg, Seal Rents, 40–6;Google ScholarBurleigh, J. H. S., A Church History of Scotland, London 1960, 326–7Google Scholar.

10 For instance, the pauper children in two city hospitals were accommodated in the College Church, and the hospitals paid the seat rents, Extracts from the Records of the Burgh of Glasgow, ed. Renwick, R., Glasgow 1914-1916, ix. 635–6Google Scholar.

11 Ibid. x. 75.

12 Ibid. viii. 241.

13 Ibid. viii. 625.

14 ‘A True Representation of the Case of John Spreul… In Reference unto a Seat in his own Parish Church‘, c. 1710, in Burns, j. W. (ed.), Miscellaneous Writings of John Spreull, Glasgow 1888, 75–88,Google Scholar at p. 76; Glasgow Town Council, Committee on Churches and Churchyards, MS minutes (hereinafter cited as Committee Minutes), 27 Nov. 1840, Strathclyde Regional Archive c.2.7.1.

15 , Burns, op. cit. 83, 87.Google Scholar

16 Slaven, A., The Development of the West of Scotland 1750-1960, London 1975, 79–134;Google ScholarLythe, S. G. E. and Butt, J., An Economic History of Scotland 1100-1039, Glasgow-London 1975. 245Google Scholar.

17 , Renwick, Extracts, viii. 76–7,Google Scholar 294, 509-10; ix. 592-3, 635.

18 Ibid. ix. 512, 515.

19 Ibid. viii. 510.

20 Ibid. ix. 564-5.

21 Ibid. ix. 541, 556-7, 562; x. 50-1, 69, 70, 120-1, 329-30.

22 Ibid. ix. 137-8; x. 50. In 1803, £2 was needed for ‘the extraordinary expense of cleaning the [Tron] Church for the Sunday evening lectures’, ibid. ix. 351. Pew-renting as a hygiene measure was also advanced in England, see , Inglis, Churches, 106Google Scholar.

23 Letter quoted in , Renwick, Extracts, x. 326Google Scholar.

24 Ibid. x. 564; Brown, S. J., Thomas Chalmers and the Godly Commonwealth, in Oxford 1982, 115, 145Google Scholar.

25 , Renwick, Extracts, X. 75.Google Scholar

26 Ibid. x. 416.

27 Glasgow Town Council, City Chamberlain's Office, MS plans of seat-price arrangements in the City Churches (hereinafter cited as MS Plans), 10 Feb. 1870, Mitchell Library, Glasgow G285.2.

28 Bell, J. and Paton, J., Glasgow: its municipal organisation and administration, Glasgow 1896, 411;Google Scholar, Renwick, Extracts, x. 226–8Google Scholar.

29 Ibid. x. 120, 170, 190, 192-4, 197-8, 202-5, 319, 324-6, 330, 333-4, 343, 348-9, 416,5 29-30. 533-5.

30 Ibid. xi. 71.

31 Glasgow Town Council, MS minutes (hereinafter cited as Council Minutes), 15 Aug. 1850, Strathclyde Regional Archive c 1.2.24.

32 , Brown, ‘Religion’, i. 337–86;Google ScholarBrown, C. G., ‘The Sunday-school movement in Scotland, 1780-1914’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society xxi (1981), 3–26, passimGoogle Scholar.

33 Glasgow City Mission, First Annual Report, 1827, 6, 8.Google Scholar

34 , Bell and , Paton, Glasgow, 411.Google Scholar

35 , Renwick, Extracts, ix. 541,Google Scholar 547, 557; x. 51, 70, 120-1, 631.

36 Ibid. x. 673, 676-7; xi. 8-9, 22, 34, 70-1.

37 Committee Minutes, 14 Mar. 1836, 9 Mar. 1842, and 6 and 7 Apr. 1852, c 2.7.1-2.

38 Council Minutes, 19 Sept. 1844, c 1.2.21.

39 These and all subsequent references to seat-price statistics in the City Churches, except those for 1870, are compiled from data in the following: annual accounts of the Ecclesiastical Department given in Council Minutes, 3 Sept. and 29 Oct. 1846, 23 Oct. 1850, 6 Apr. 1853, 2 Apr. 1857, 6 Apr. 1859, 10 Apr. 1862, 5 Apr. 1865, 11 Apr. 1867 and 4 Apr. 1868, c 1.1.64-9; annual accounts in Committee Minutes, 5 Mar. 1833, 15 Dec. 1876, 14 Dec. 1877, 14 june 1880 and 19 May 1886, c 2.7.1-3; Gibson, J., Remarks on the Speech of A. C. Dick Esq., Advocate. With the Expenditure of the Glasgow City Churches, Glasgow 1833, 13–15.Google Scholar The complete data are given in tabulated form in , Brown, ‘Religion’, ii. 296–9Google Scholar.

40 Balfour, F., Life and Letters of the Reverend James MacGregor D.D., London 1912, 13–15;Google Scholar Committee Minutes, 18 Mar. 1870, c 2.7.2.

41 Council Minutes, 2 and 17 Nov. 1843, 9 May 1844 and 3 Sept. 1846, c 1.1.63-4, c 1.2.21.

42 Proposal for Building Twenty New Parochial Churches in the City and Suburbs of Glasgow, Glasgow 1834, 8.Google Scholar

43 All references hereinafter to seat-price arrangements in the City Churches in 1870 are derived from MS Plans. The complete data are given in tabulated form in , Brown, ‘Religion’, ii. 308–10Google Scholar.

44 Minutes of Town Council and Committees, etc., relative to negotiations between the Corporation and Presbytery regarding thefuture administration of the City Churches, 1889-93, Glasgow n.d.