Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T20:09:04.935Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘A Solemn Purification by Fire’: Responses to the Great War in the Scottish Presbyterian Churches, 1914–19

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 February 2009

Stewart J. Brown
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

During the Great War, leaders in the two major Presbyterian Churches in Scotland – the established Church of Scotland and the United Free Church – struggled to provide moral and spiritual leadership to the Scottish people. As National Churches which together claimed the adherence of the large majority of the Scottish people, the two Churches were seen as responsible for interpreting the meaning of the war and defining war aims, as well as for offering consolation to the suffering and the bereaved. At the beginning of the war, leaders of the two Churches had been confident of their ability to fulfil these national responsibilities. Both Churches had experienced a flowering of theological and intellectual creativity during the forty years before the war, and their colleges and theologians had exercised profound influence on the Reformed tradition throughout the world. Both had been active in the ‘social gospel’ movement, with their leaders advancing bold criticisms of the social order. The two Churches, moreover, had been moving toward ecclesiastical union when the war began, a union which their leaders hoped would restore the spiritual and moral authority of the Church in a covenanted nation.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 45 , Issue 1 , January 1994 , pp. 82 - 104
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Withrington, D.J. ‘“A ferment of change”: aspirations, ideas and ideals in nineteenth-century Scotland’, in D. Gifford (ed.), The history of Scottish literature, 3, Aberdeen 1988, esp. pp. 52–63;Google ScholarSell, A. P. F., Defending and declaring the faith: some Scottish examples 1860–1920, Exeter 1987.Google Scholar

2 Smith, D. C.Passive obedience and prophetic protest: social criticism in the Scottish Church 1830–1945, New York 1987, 245–325.Google Scholar

3 See, for example, Lewis Grassic Gibbon's novel, Sunset song, London 1932, particularly the portrayal of the Revd Stuart Gibbon, who preaches a fierce patriotism and is rewarded with a call to a wealthy church in New York City after the war (esp. pp. 190–5, 247).

4 For studies of the English Churches and the war see Wilkinson, A., The Church of England and the First World War, London 1978;Google ScholarMarrin, A., The last crusade: the Church of England in the First World War, Durham, NC 1974;Google ScholarMews, S., ‘Religion and English society in the First World War’, unpubl. PhD diss. Cambridge 1973.Google ScholarHoover, A. J. God, Germany, and Britain in the Great War: a study in clerical nationalism, New York 1989, gives some attention to Scottish responses, though the emphasis is mainly on England and Germany. One of the few recent studies of the impact of the war on the Scottish Churches is P. Matheson, ‘Scottish war sermons’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society 17 (1972), 203–13. There is also some discussion of the Scottish Churches and the war in Smith, Passive obedience, 356–62.Google Scholar

5 Williamson, A. Wallace sermon in St Giles, Edinburgh, 9 Aug. 1914, cited in British Weekly, 13 Aug. 1914;Google ScholarKernohan, R. D.Scotland's life and work, Edinburgh 1979, 91–2.Google Scholar

6 Drummond, A. L. and Bulloch, J.The Church in late Victorian Scotland 1874–1900, Edinburgh 1978, 219–20;Google ScholarCheyne, A. C.The transforming of the Kirk, Edinburgh 1983, 72.Google Scholar

7 In this severing of religious and cultural links, the experience of Scottish clergy and academics follows a larger British pattern. See Hoover, God, Germany and Britain, 3, 19, 36; Wallace, S.War and the image of Germany: British academics 1914–1918, Edinburgh 1988, 29–42.Google Scholar

8 Reports on the schemes of the Church of Scotland, 1915, 535; Layman's book of the General Assembly of 1915, ed. H. Smith, Edinburgh 1915, 7; Smith, G. A.Our common conscience: addresses delivered in America during the Great War, London 1918, 43.Google Scholar

9 Williamson, Wallace sermon in St Giles, Edinburgh, 9 Aug. 1914, cited in British Weekly, 13 Aug. 1914.Google Scholar

10 Matheson, ‘Scottish war sermons’, 205–6.

11 Muir, J.War and Christian duty, Paisley 1915, 20; ‘Some aspects of the Great War’, Life and Work (Oct. 1914), 299.Google Scholar

12 See the sermon by John Kelman of Free St George's, Edinburgh, cited in British Weekly, 5 Sept. 1914.

13 Hoover, God, Germany and Britain, 30–1.Google Scholar

14 ‘The war of ideals’, Life and Work (Nov. 1914), 323.

15 Mursell, W. A.The bruising of Belgium, Paisley 1915, 23.Google Scholar See also Maclean, N.The great discovery, Glasgow 1915, 33–4.Google Scholar

16 Henderson, A. to A. Martin, 10 Sept. 1914, Alexander Martin Papers (uncatalogued), New College Library, Edinburgh.Google Scholar

17 Walker, G.For the great cause: some bits of spiritual “munition-work” in heaven's “Great Cause” and our own, Aberdeen 1915, 20.Google Scholar

18 ‘The right shall win’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church (Nov. 1915), 463.

19 ‘Christ and War’, Life and Work (Sept. 1914), 258.

20 See, for example, Reid, H. M. B.The cleavage in the Scottish Church, Glasgow 1914, 7–9.Google Scholar

21 See, for example, the reports of the joint Church of Scotland/United Free Church intercessory prayer meetings and services in the British Weekly, 27 Aug., 5, 10, 17 Sept. 1914.

22 Maclean, N.In our parish, Edinburgh 1915; the articles were again reprinted in his The great discovery, Glasgow 1915.Google Scholar

23 This is the impression gleaned from a survey of parish histories. See, for example, Tennant, E.Bon-Accord United Free Church, Aberdeen, Aberdeen 1928, 104–5;Google ScholarMurray, E. G.The church of Cardross and its ministers, Glasgow 1935, 164;Google ScholarLee, J. R.Greyfriars Glasgow, Glasgow 1938, 92;Google ScholarDickie, W.History of Dowanhill Church, Glasgow 1926, 132–3.Google Scholar

24 Gallagher, T.Glasgow: the uneasy peace, Manchester 1987, 86.Google Scholar

25 ‘Christ and war’, Life and Work (Sept. 1914), 258.

26 See, for example, the final report of the Church of Scotland Commission on the Religious Condition of the People in Reports on the schemes, 1896, 747–868.

27 Maclean, The great discovery, 13, 76–7.Google Scholar

28 British Weekly, 5 Sept. 1914.

29 Paterson, W. P.In the day of the muster, London 1914, 44.Google Scholar

30 Adams, J.The great sacrifice or the altar-fire of war, Edinburgh 1915, 36.Google Scholar

31 Denney, J.War and the fear of God, London 1916, 27.Google Scholar

32 For discussion of the role of rumour and legend in the war, see Fussell, P.The Great War and modem memory, Oxford 1975, esp. pp. 114–25.Google Scholar

33 Hynes, S.A war imagined: the First World War and English culture, London 1990, 53–5.Google Scholar

34 ‘In the trenches’, Life and Work (May 1915), 131. For reports of the intense interest in the story, see Ibid. (July 1915), 196–7; (Nov. 1915), 335; and Kernohan, Scotland's life and work, 94–5. For the collection of stories seeGoogle ScholarLeathern, W. H.The comrade in white, London 1915.Google Scholar

35 Warr, C. L.The unseen host: stories of the Great War, Paisley 1916. For t h e success of the volume see Warr's autobiography, The glimmering landscape, London 1960, 96–7.Google Scholar

36 Adams, Great sacrifice, 4–5, 9, 10.Google Scholar

37 Nichol, W. J. Service, War and the peace of God, Glasgow 1915, 145.Google Scholar

38 Robertson, J. D. ‘The war and the Church’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church (Oct. 1914), 438.Google Scholar

39 G. J. B. Davis ‘Winning our soldiers for Christ: the story of a remarkable campaign in Scotland’, Ibid. (June 1915), 239–41.

40 Johnston, T. to R. E. Muirhead 11 Mar. 1915, Muirhead Papers, National Library of Scotland, Ace. 3721/149/4.Google Scholar

41 Forward (Glasgow), 17 Oct. 1914; and also 29 Aug. 1914; 16 Jan. 1915.

42 Barr, J.Lang Syne, Glasgow 1948, 57–67; The Church and war, Glasgow 1932, 40.Google Scholar

43 ‘Conscience and the war’, Life and Work (May 1916), 135.

44 Cited in Barr, The Church and the war, 38.

45 British Weekly, 13 Aug. 1914.

46 Layman's book, 132.

47 Gallagher, Glasgow, 87.

48 Reith, G. M.Reminiscences of the United Free Church General Assembly, Edinburgh 1933, 180.Google Scholar

49 ‘The drift from the Church’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church (Sept. 1916), 225–6; ‘The Church and the nation’, Glasgow Herald, 30 May 1917, 6.

50 Maclean, N. to White, j. 21 Dec. 1915, John White Papers, box 2.Google Scholar

51 Livingstone, W. P.The new outlook, London 1917, 4.Google Scholar

52 Robbins, K.The abolition of war: the ‘Peace Movement’ in Britain 1914–1919, Cardiff 1976, 70–92;Google ScholarWilkinson, Church of England, 46–56.Google Scholar

53 Smith, G. A.The war, the nation and the Church: two addresses to the General Assembly of the United Free Church of Scotland, May 1916, London 1916, 17–27.Google Scholar

54 Reith, Reminiscences, 171;Google ScholarSmith, , Our common conscience, pp. vii-ix, 1–3.Google Scholar

55 Barr, J.The conscientious objector: a lecture delivered in St Mary's United Free Church, Glasgow, London 1916, 30–2.Google Scholar

56 See, for example, the reports in the Glasgow Herald, 2, 8, 10 May 1918.

57 The Diaries of W. P. Paterson, ed. C. L. Rawlins, Edinburgh 1987, 133; Lord Sands /C. N. Johnston/, Life of Andrew Wallace Williamson, Edinburgh 1929, 281.

58 Warr, C. L.Echoes of Flanders, London 1916.Google Scholar

59 Black, J. ‘Our soldiers: the influence of the war on their religious ideas’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church (Apr. 1917), 82.Google Scholar

60 ‘The Church and the soldier’, Ibid. (Nov. 1917), 213.

61 Maclean, N. and Sclater, J. R. P.God and the soldier, London 1917, 205–8; see also Hoover, God, Germany and Britain, 110.Google Scholar

62 Herbert, A. Gray, As Tommy sees us: a book for church folk, London 1917, 6–43.Google Scholar

63 Ibid. 6.

64 The responses, for example, were discussed in the United Free Church General Assembly on 25 May 1917: Proceedings and Debates of the General Assembly of the United Free Church, 1917, 182–4.

65 The army and religion, ed. D. S. Cairns, London 1919, 238–56.

66 Ibid. 160–5.

67 Ibid. 125–54.

68 Ibid. 207–10.

69 Ibid. 212.

70 Gray, As Tommy sees us, 12Google Scholar; Idem, ‘Fellowship in the army and the Church’, The Church and the war: tracts for to-day, no. 6, Edinburgh 1917, 43–5.

71 Winter, J. M.The Great War and the British people, London 1986, esp. pp. 154–212.Google Scholar

72 ‘The Church and the nation’, Glasgow Herald, 30 May 1917, 6.

73 Wotherspoon, H. J.Some spiritual issues of the war, London 1918, 15, 18.Google Scholar

74 Wilkinson, Church of England, 70–3; F. A. Iremonger, William Temple, Oxford 1948, 204–7.Google Scholar

75 Layman's book, 55, 56.

76 Reports on the schemes, 1917, 723–58.

77 Ibid. 740.

78 Ibid. 741.

79 Ibid. 753.

80 Proceedings and debates of the General Assembly of the United Free Church, 1917, 166–70.

81 United Free Church, The Church and the war: tracts for to-day, Edinburgh, 1917–18.

82 Paterson, W. P. and Watson, D. (eds), Social evils and problems, Edinburgh 1918.Google Scholar

83 Richardson, C. M. ‘A plea for the industrial drudges’, The Church and the war: tracts for to-day, no. 11, Edinburgh 1917, 82–3.Google Scholar

84 Reports on the schemes, 1918, 629.

85 Ibid. 621.

86 Reid, H. M. B. to J. White, 16 Dec. 1916, John White Papers, box 42.Google Scholar

87 J. H. Dickie to J. White, 30 Oct. 1917, Ibid., box 1.

88 D. Young to J. White, 11 Jan. 1918, Ibid., box 26; Scottish Presbyterian difficulties with the conception of corporate repentance were similar to those experienced in England in response to the National Mission of 1916: Lloyd, R.The Church of England 19O0–1965, London 1966, 226–31.Google Scholar

89 ‘The Church and the nation’, Glasgow Herald, 30 May 1917, 6.

90 Proceedings and debates of the General Assembly of the United Free Church, 1917, 166–191, esp. pp. 170–2, 180.

91 Reith, Reminiscences, 188.Google Scholar

92 Wotherspoon, H. J.James Cooper, London 1926, 282–3, 285;Google ScholarReith, Reminiscences, 188.Google Scholar

93 ‘The Church's outlook’, Glasgow Herald, 30 May 1918, 4.

94 ‘Report of the committee on church life and work’, Reports to the General Assembly of the United Free Church, 1919, 4–5.

95 ‘The cloven foot once more’, Life and Work (June 1918), 84.

96 Warr, The glimmering landscape, 118–19.Google Scholar

97 Fleming, J. R.A history of the Church in Scotland, 1875–1929, Edinburgh 1933, 98;Google ScholarReid, Reminiscences, 208–9.Google Scholar

98 ‘National rededication’, Glasgow Herald, 21 Dec. 1918, 6.

99 See the folder on the National Mission of Rededication in the John White Papers, box 16.

100 Reports on the schemes, 1919, 645, 661.

101 Paterson, W. P.Recent history and the call to brotherhood, Edinburgh, 1919, esp. pp. 5–16, 20–33.Google Scholar

102 See, for example, letters from disappointed mission supporters in the Glasgow Herald, 17, 21 April 1919.

103 Cited in ‘The mission of national re-dedication: after-impressions’, John White Papers, box 16.

104 ‘The position of the Churches’, Glasgow Herald, 16 Jan. 1919, 4; Sands, Andrew Wallace Williamson, 289–90;Google ScholarMuir, A.John While, London 1958, 185–6.Google Scholar

105 Winter, Great War, 103–53, 213–45.Google Scholar

106 Fleming, History of the Church in Scotland, 238.