Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T20:27:58.988Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Bank Miṣr and Foreign Capitalism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 January 2009

Robert L. Tignor
Robert L. Tignor
Affiliation:
Princeton University Princeton, New Jersey
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the early months of 1920 a group of leading Egyptians founded Bank Misr. Destined to be the major financial arm of an emerging Egyptian bourgeoisie and the hub of a far-flung industrial and commercial empire, Bank Misr was established amidst the revolutionary turmoil of Egypt in 1919 and 1920. It reflected the nationalist and antiforeign sentiments of these troubled years. Its architect, Tal'at Harb, epitomized many of these characteristics. An ardent Muslim and a defender of Arab-Islamic civilization against its Western and Eastern detractors, he was a dedicated nationalist and a critic of rapacious and exploitative European capitalism. Bank Misr was founded as a supremely Egyptian institution and an expression of nationalist aspirations. Its founders hoped that the Bank might facilitate the emergence of an independent Egyptian bourgeoisie. They also wanted to use its resources to establish new commercial, industrial, and financial companies separate from European capital and working exclusively for the economic well-being of Egypt. But many questions immediately emerged. Could an institution founded in the furor of the revolution and headed by an inexperienced staff even survive, let alone spearhead, far-reaching industrial and commercial changes in the Egyptian economy? What would be its relations with foreigners and especially foreign capital? What role would foreign experts play in the life of the Bank? The purpose of this essay is to investigate how the Bank dealt with these problems by looking at the evolving relationship of the Bank with foreign capital. Put simply it can be said that as the Bank evolved and matured, it began to modify many of its original nationalist, populist, and antiforeign sentiments. It was forced to form alliances with the same groups it had so vigorously denounced at its birt. A close observation of the relationship between Bank Misr and foreign capital should cast light on the effort to create an autonomous Egyptian bourgeoisie. It will show the problems inherent in this vision and the compromises that had to be made as difficulties arose. It will also demonstrate the power of European capitalism in Egypt and its capacity to come to terms with even the most vigorous nationalist organizations.

Type
Articles
Information
International Journal of Middle East Studies , Volume 8 , Issue 2 , April 1977 , pp. 161 - 181
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1977

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Égypte, , Commission du Commerce et de l'Industrie, Rapport (Cairo, 1918).Google Scholar

2 Ibid, p. 56.

3 Secret Report on the Egyptian Delegation, August 11, 1919, Public Record Office (hereafter PRO), Foreign Office (hereafter FO) 371/3718 f. 24930.

4 al-Akhbār, 05 17, 1920.Google Scholar

5 There are a number of biographies of Tal'at Harb. A great deal of information on his early career may be found in Hāfiz Mahmūd, Must;afa Kāmil al-Falkī, and Mahmūd Fathī 'Amr, , Tal'at Harb (Cairo, 1936).Google Scholar Tal'at Harb's own short account may be found in Majmū'a Khutub (Cairo, 1927–1938), 3, 79–84.Google Scholar

6 Harb, Tal'at, Tarbīya al-Mar'a (Cairo, 1899).Google Scholar

7 I have been unable to locate a copy of this book. My interpretation is based on descriptions of the work in al-Jarīda, February 3, 1910, and after, and on the study of Hāfiz Mahmūd, Tal'at Harb.

8 Harb, Tal'at, ‘Alāj Misr-al-Iqtisādī (Cairo, 191?), p. 29.Google Scholar

9 Ibid., pp. 38 ff.

10 al-Akhbār, 04 14, 1920Google Scholar; Harb, Tal'at, Majmū‘a Khutub, 3, 63–67Google Scholar; and Mahmūd, Hāfiz, Tal'at Harb, pp. 77 ff.Google Scholar

11 Stock Exchange Yearbook of Egypt (1939), p. 119.Google Scholar

12 See Tal'at Harb's speech of welcome for Sa'd Zaghlūl on April 13, 1921 in which he attacked foreigners for not having equipped Egypt with viable national institutions. Harb, Tal'at, Majmū'a Khutub, 1, 65.Google Scholar

13 See the charter of the Bank in Misr, Bank, al-Yūbīl al Dhahabī (Cairo, 197?), pp. 155 ff.Google Scholar

14 These two celebrations are fully covered in a fifteen-year anniversary scrapbook compiled by the Bank and located presently in the library of the Tal'at Harb Club in Cairo. Tal'at Harb's speech on the fifteenth anniversary is contained there: 'Id Bank Misr, pp. 4 ff.Google Scholar

15 Harb, Tal'at, Majmū'a Khutub, 1, 46.Google Scholar

16 Ibid., pp. 112–118.

17 al-Rāfi‘ī, 'Abd al-Rahman, Niqābāt al-Ta'āwun al-Zirā'īya (Cairo, 1914), p. 165.Google Scholar

18 Misr, Bank, al-Yūbīl al-Dhahabī, p. 54.Google Scholar

19 Issa, Hassan M., Capitalisme et Sociétés Anonymes en Égypte: Essai sur le Rapport entre Structure Sociale et Droit (Paris, 1970), pp. 256–257.Google Scholar

20 Harb, Tal'at, Majmū‘a Khutub, 1, 45–63.Google Scholar

21 Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1923), p. 13.Google Scholar

22 See his speech at al-Mahalla al-Kubra on September 14, 1923 (Harb, Tal'at, Majmū‘a Khutub, 1, 96).Google Scholar

23 Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1920), p. 12, and (1921), p. 15.Google Scholar

24 The procedure the Bank intended to employ in establishing new companies was elaborated in Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1923), pp. 14 ff.Google Scholar

25 Misr, Bank, al-Yūbīl al-Dhahabī, p. 262.Google Scholar

26 Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1926), p. 7.Google Scholar

27 Harb, Tal'at, Majmū'a Khutub, 1, 53.Google Scholar

28 Misr, Bank, Tagrīr (1920), p. 10.Google Scholar

29 British views of Adler and other German financiers working in league with Bank Misr can be found in No. 224, Allenby, to MacDonald, , 04 14, 1924, PRO FO 371/10029.Google Scholar

30 Misr, Bank, Tagrīr (1926), p. 13.Google Scholar

31 The charters may be found in Sahīfa al-Tijāra, 4, 2 (01 1928).Google Scholar

32 Misr, Bank, Inshā' al-Sinā'āt al-Ahlīya (Cairo, c. 1929), pp. 65 ff.Google Scholar

33 Ibid., p. 85.

34 Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1929), pp. 9 ff.Google Scholar

35 Telegram No. 29, Loraine, to Foreign Office, 01 27, 1931, PRO FO 371/15396.Google Scholar

36 Summary of the Confidential Report of the United Kingdom Trade Mission to Egypt, 04 1931 PRO FO 371/15398.Google Scholar

37 Loraine, , Annual Report on Egypt, 1931, p. 39, PRO FO 371/16124.Google Scholar

38 No. 156, Loraine, to Henderson, , 02 13, 1931, PRO FO 371/15396.Google Scholar

39 Henderson, to Colonial Office, 04 27, 1931, PRO FO 371/15396.Google Scholar

40 The agreement is to be found in No. 156, Loraine, to Henderson, , 02 13, 1931, PRO FO 371/15396.Google Scholar

41 Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1931), p. 21.Google Scholar

42 Memorandum by Sterndale-Bennett, J. C. of a conversation with Muntz, 04 10, 1938, PRO FO 371/21964.Google Scholar

43 Larkins, to the Department of Trade, 10 24, 1933, PRO FO 371/17034.Google Scholar

44 Larkins, to the Department of Trade, 02 24, 1934, PRO FO 371/18015.Google Scholar

45 No. 926, Sterndale-Bennett, to Eden, , 08 4, 1937, PRO FO 371/20891.Google Scholar

46 Foreign Office Minute, 04 20, 1938, PRO FO 371/21964.Google Scholar

47 Memorandum by Sterndale-Bennett, J. C., 04 10, 1938, PRO FO 371/21964.Google Scholar

48 L'Égypte Industrielle, 6, 2 (02 1930), 47–56.Google Scholar

49 L'Informateur, 09 14, 1934.Google Scholar

50 Examples of industrialists's demands for tariff reform may be found in “Appel de la Filature Nationale d'Égypte aux Pouvoirs Publics” in Économiste Égyptien. 06 8, 1930Google Scholar, and a report by Harb, Tal'at. 05 1938Google Scholar in Majmū'a Khutub, 3, 138–144.Google Scholar

51 Proposed Trade Negotiations with Egypt—Brief for the House of Commons, Board of Trade, 01 7, 1935, PRO FO 371/19045.Google Scholar

52 Égypte, Ministère des Finances, Annuaire Statistique, 1921–22 and 1932–33.

53 Telegram, No. 554, Lampson, to Foreign Office, 10 25, 1938, PRO FO 371/21956.Google Scholar

54 Larkins, to the Department of Trade, 12 23, 1933, PRO FO 371/19985.Google Scholar

55 Économiste Égyptien, 01 28, 1934Google Scholar and Revue d'Égypte Économique et Financière, 8, 111–112 (09 16–23, 1934), 10.Google Scholar

56 No. 610, Lampson, to Eden, , 05 21, 1936Google Scholar, enclosing memorandum by Selous, , 05 1936, PRO FO 371/20140.Google Scholar

57 See Owen, E. R J., “Lord Cromer and the Development of Egyptian Industry, 1883–1907,” Middle Eastern Studies, 2, 4 (07 1966), 282–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

58 See the article in the journal of the Alexandria Chamber of Commerce, Mijalla Gharfa al-Iskatidarīya, 1, 12 (07 1937), 10.Google Scholar

59 Misr, Bank, Taqrīr (1937), pp. 26–28.Google Scholar

60 Misr, Bank, al-Yūbīl al-Dhaliabī, pp. 74Google Scholar and Rushdī, Muhammad, al-Tatawwur al-Iqtisādī fī Misr (Cairo, 19?), pp. 45 ff.Google Scholar

61 Revue d'Égypte Économique et Financière, 15, 458 (05 24, 1941), 5–6.Google Scholar

62 Misr, Bank, al-Yūbīl al-Dhahabī, p. 186.Google Scholar