Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rcrh6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T04:43:38.005Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Political Religion: A User’s Guide

Review products

A. JamesGregor, Totalitarianism and Political Religion. An Intellectual History (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2012), 320 pp., $65, ISBN 0-80-478130-5.
MichaelBurleigh, Sacred Causes. The Clash of Religion and Politics, from the Great War to the War on Terror (New York: Harper Collins, 2007), 557 pp., ISBN 0-06-058095-7.
LarsBruun, Karl ChristianLammers & GertSørensen (eds.), European Self-Reflection between Politics and Religion. The Crisis of Europe in the Twentieth Century (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013), 247 pp., ISBN 1-137-30828-3.

Show more reviewed productsShow more reviewed products

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 October 2015

GEARÓID BARRY
GEARÓID BARRY*
Affiliation:
School of Humanities, NUI Galway, Galway, Ireland; [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In an article published in September 1939, in the very eye of the storm of twentieth-century Europe's ‘age of extremes’, the British historian Christopher Dawson attempted to get to grips with the temper of his times. Opining on what he saw as the failure of nineteenth-century liberal individualism and its deleterious encroachment on spiritual values, he wrote:

Now the coming of the totalitarian state marks the emergence of a new type of politics which recognises no limits and seeks to subordinate every social and intellectual activity to its own ends. Thus the new politics are in a sense more idealistic than the old; they are political religions based on a Messianic hope of social salvation. But at the same time they are more realist since they actually involve a brutal struggle for life between rival powers which are prepared to use every kind of treachery and violence to gain their ends.

When not researching medieval Christian encounters with the Mongols, Dawson wrote history with a grand narrative sweep such as he admired in the work of the German historian Oswald Spengler. His output has recently sparked a revival of interest, with claims that he was one of most significant Catholic historians of the century. Yet this Augustinian pessimist was only one of a broader band of contemporary intellectuals – not all of them religious apologists – to brandish the label of ‘political religion’ as a descriptor, and as a moral warning. Seventy years on, the same moral seriousness characterises several of the books under review here, especially those addressing the more terrifying consequences of political religion in its various forms. For as A. James Gregor declares when introducing his intellectual history of Totalitarianism and Political Religion, ‘the unnumbered dead of the past century’ are surely owed some posthumous explanation:

Amid all the other factors that contributed to the tragedy, there was a kind of creedal ferocity that made every exchange a matter of existential importance. The twentieth century was host to systems of doctrinal conviction that made unorthodox belief a capital affront, made conflict mortal, and all enterprise sacrificial (Gregor, xi).

Type
Review Article
Information
Contemporary European History , Volume 24 , Special Issue 4: Urban Societies in Europe , November 2015 , pp. 623 - 638
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Dawson, Christopher, ‘The Claims of Politics’, Scrutiny, 8, 2 (1939), 136–41, here 138Google Scholar.

2 For biography of Dawson (1889–1970), see Hitchcock, James, ‘Christopher Dawson’, American Scholar, 62, 1 (1993), 111–18Google Scholar. See also Birzer, Bradley J., Sanctifying the World: The Augustinian Life and Mind of Christopher Dawson (Front Royal, Va.: Christendom Press, 2007)Google Scholar and the on-going series of republications, ‘The Works of Christopher Dawson’, The Catholic University of America Press, General Editor Don. J. Briel, available at http://cuapress.cua.edu/books/series.cfm (last visited 20 May 2014).

3 David D. Roberts has given an excellent and extensive discussion of ‘political religion’ and its uses and disadvantages as an analytical category, to which I am indebted; Roberts, David D., ‘“Political Religion” and the Totalitarian Departures of Inter-war Europe: On the Uses and Disadvantages of an Analytical Category’, Contemporary European History, 18, 4 (2009), 381–414CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Reviewing the recent literature on fascism, for example, António Costa Pinto has written of ‘classificatory “essentialism”’ and the ‘intuitive and dysfunctional use of the concept of totalitarianism’. Pinto, António Costa, ‘European Fascism: The Unfinished Handbook’, Contemporary European History, 21, 2 (2012), 287–300, here 298CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Gentile, Emilio, The Sacralization of Politics in Fascist Italy trans. Keith Botsford (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1996)Google Scholar, a translation of Il culto del littorio: La sacralizzazione della politica nell’Italia fascista (Rome and Bari: Laterza, 1993).

6 Roberts, ‘Political Religion’, 383; Gentile, Emilio, ‘The Sacralisation of Politics: Definitions, interpretations and reflections on the question of secular religion and totalitarianism’, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions, 1, 1 (2000), 18–55, here 22CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also, Gentile, Politics as Religion, trans. George Staunton (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2006), translation of Gentile, Le religioni della politica. Fra democrazie e totalitarismi (Rome and Bari: Laterza, 2001).

7 Roberts, ‘Political Religion’, 382; Kershaw, Ian, ‘Hitler and the Uniqueness of Nazism’, Journal of Contemporary History, 39, 2 (2004), 239–54, here 250CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Roberts, ‘Political Religion’, 387.

9 Roberts, ‘Political Religion’, 385; Payne, Stanley G., A History of Fascism, 1919–1945 (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1995), 494Google Scholar.

10 Dagnino, Jorge, ‘The Intellectuals of Italian Catholic Action and the Sacralisation of Politics in 1930s Europe’, Contemporary European History, 21, 2 (2012), 215–33, here 233CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Maier, Hans, ‘Political Religion: A Concept and its Limitations’, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions, 8, 1 (2007), 5–16, here 9CrossRefGoogle Scholar: Werfel's biography is extraordinary; an early novel relating to the Armenian genocide of 1915 was widely read, not least in the United States. His final wartime escape to America included a period of sanctuary at the Marian shrine at Lourdes, in gratitude for which Werfel wrote The Song of Bernadette (1941) made into a Hollywood movie in 1943 in which the peasant girl's steadfast faith is pitted against the caution of clerics and the sneering of secularist officials. United States Holocaust Museum, ‘Franz Werfel’, Holocaust Enclyopedia, http://www.ushmm.org/wlc/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007049 (Last visited 30 June 2015).

12 Passmore, Kevin, ‘The Ideological Origins of Fascism before 1914’, in Bosworth, R. J. B., ed., The Oxford Handbook of Fascism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009), 11–31, here 14Google Scholar.

13 Roberts, ‘Political Religion’, 391; Kershaw, ‘Hitler and the Uniqueness of Nazism’, 250.

14 Overy, Richard, The Dictators: Hitler's Germany and Stalin's Russia (London: Allen Lane, 2004)Google Scholar.

15 Pollard, John, ‘“Clerical Fascism”: Context, Overview and Conclusion’, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religion, 8, 2 (2007), 433–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Box, Zira and Baz, Ismael, ‘Spanish Fascism as a Political Religion (1931–41)’, Politics, Religion and Ideology, 12, 4 (2011), 371–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Douglas, R. M., ‘Handmaids of the Revolution: Ailtirí na hAiséirighe, Women and Irish Fascism’, Politics, Religion and Ideology, 13, 2 (2012), 237–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Jackson, Paul, ‘“Union or Death”: Gavrilo Princip, Young Bosnia and the Role of “Sacred Time” in the Dynamics of Nationalist Terrorism’, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions, 7, 1 (2006), 45–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Becker, Annette, War and Faith: The Religious Imagination in France, 1914–1930 (Oxford and New York: Berg, 1998)Google Scholar, translation of La guerre et la foi. De la mort et la mémoire: 1914-années 1930 (Paris: Armand Colin, 1994); Becker, , ‘Faith, Ideologies, and the “Cultures of War”’, in Horne, John, ed., A Companion to World War I (Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 2010), 234–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Passmore, ‘The Ideological Origins of Fascism before 1914’, 13.

19 Passmore, ‘The Ideological Origins of Fascism before 1914’, 14.

20 Dal Lago, Enrico, William Lloyd Garrison and Giuseppe Mazzini: Abolition, Democracy and Radical Reform (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 2013), 73Google Scholar.

21 Dal Lago, William Lloyd Garrison and Giuseppe Mazzini, 75.

22 Riall, Lucy, ‘Martyr Cults in Nineteenth-Century Italy’, The Journal of Modern History, 82, 2 (2010), 255–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar; for an Irish comparison, see Newsinger, John, ‘“I Bring Not Peace But A Sword”: The Religious Motif in the Irish War of Independence’, Journal of Contemporary History, 13, 3 (1978), 609–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar; On the nineteenth-century revival of Catholicism and the transnational resonance of the cult of the pope as a ‘living martyr’, see Viaene, Vincent, ‘International History, Religious History, Catholic History: Perspectives for Cross-Fertilization (1830–1914)’, European History Quarterly, 38, 4 (2008), 578–607CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 Mazower, Mark, Governing the World: The History of an Idea (London: Allen Lane, 2012), 155Google Scholar.

24 Burleigh, Michael, Earthly Powers: The Clash of Religion and Politics in Europe from the French Revolution to the Great War (New York: Harper Collins, 2005)Google Scholar. For a highly critical review of Sacred Causes (2007), see Tony Judt, ‘Defender of the Faith’, The New York Times, 11 Mar. 2007. A more mixed appreciation of Burleigh's twin volumes can be found in Jackson, Paul, ‘Re-enchanting Europeans: Michael Burleigh and Political Religion Theory’, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions, 9, 1 (2008), 123–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Kaiser, Wolfram, Christian Democracy and the Origins of European Union (Cambridge: Cambridge Unviersity Press, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Chenaux, Philippe, L’Église catholique et le communisme en Europe, 1917–1989: De Lénine à Jean-Paul II (Paris: Cerf, 2009), 21–8Google Scholar.

27 Wolf, Hubert, Pope and Devil: The Vatican Archives and the Third Reich (Cambridge, Mass. and London: Belknap Press, 2010)Google Scholar.

28 Burleigh, Michael, Blood and Rage: A Cultural History of Terrorism (London: Harper Collins, 2009)Google Scholar.

29 Similar reservations can be found in Brian Sandbergh's review of Alessandro Orsini, Anatomy of the Red Brigades: The Religious Mind-Set of Modern Terrorists. H-War, H-Net Reviews. October, 2013. URL: http://w.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?id=37917

30 For another perspective, see Mark Mazower, ‘Under the Ustasha’, London Review of Books, 6 Oct. 2011, 29–30.

31 Payne, Stanley G., ‘The NDH State in Comparative Perspective’, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religion, 7, 4 (2006), 409–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Sturzo to Sangnier, 29 Aug. 1929, ILS, fasc. 436, c. 20, Istituto Luigi Sturzo, Rome; On Marc Sangnier's Franco-German interwar peace movement and its religious dimensions, see Barry, Gearóid, The Disarmament of Hatred: Marc Sangnier, French Catholicism and the legacy of the First World War, 1914–45 (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012), 1–20 and 158–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 Winter, Jay, Dreams of Peace and Freedom: Utopian Moments in the Twentieth Century (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2006)Google Scholar.

34 Ceadel, Martin, Pacifism in Britain, 1914–45: The Defining of a Faith (Oxford: Clarendon, 1980)Google Scholar.