Article contents
Of Women and Washing Machines: Employment, Housework, and the Reproduction of Motherhood in Socialist China*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 17 February 2009
Extract
Biology is not supposed to be destiny in socialist China. In contrast to class societies where supposedly “men occupy the position of the ruling class… and women become the household slaves of men and the instruments for producing more men,” in China men and women together are said to hold up the sky (biantian). Women are no longer enslaved by reproduction; if they are oppressed, it is merely because remnants of feudal thinking, superstition and backwardness still exist in China. Or so it is argued by representatives of the Chinese leadership. Here I will posit a different view. Rather than blaming feudalism or China's lack of development, I suggest that contemporary political and economic decisions have reinforced sex inequality in China. In this article, I argue that social and economic policies since the Third Plenum of the llth Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party have created conditions which impose on women (and men) sex-differentiated roles in production and reproduction. These new public policies sustain the traditional definition of women as household labourers and reproducers of men.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The China Quarterly 1985
References
1. Jiating riyong daquan (Zhejiang: Zhejiang kexue jishu chubanshe, 1979), p. 1.Google Scholar
2. See Engels, Friedrich, The Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State (New York: International Publishers, 1973)Google Scholar for the original (translated) discussion of this. For a recent iteration of Engels' views, see Keqing, Kang, “Meiyou Zhongguo gongchandang, jiumeiyou Zhongguo funude jiefang,” Hongqi, No. 14 (16 07 1981), pp. 19–23.Google Scholar
3. For an extended discussion of the theoretical nexus between production and reproduction, see O'Brien, Mary, The Politics of Reproduction (London: Routledge, Kegan Paul, 1981)Google Scholar, especially the section on Marxism, pp. 140–84.
4. See Nancy Chodorow, a feminist social scientist who took Freud's ideas and revised and applied them to the gendering of people. See The Reproduction of Mothering (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1978).Google Scholar
5. After Chodorow, a number of psychologists and other social scientists attempted to determine what the roles of men and women should be if one wants to change the negative effects of gendering on children and adults. For a recent example, see Bern, Sandra, “Gender schema theory and its implications for child development: raising gender aschematic children in a gender schematic state,” SIGNS, Vol. 8, No. 4 (Summer 1983), pp. 598–616.Google Scholar
6. Current policy in the Soviet Union, especially that directed towards encouraging women of the Great Russian Nationality group to have more children, is a good example here as are government proclamations of women's domestic duties in conservative Islamic societies.
7. “Enhancing the role of women in socialist modernization.” Women of China, No. 3 (03 1983), p. 1.Google Scholar Other examples include “Gonggu he fazhan shehuizhuyi jiehun jiatingguanxi,” Dazhong ribao, 16 04 1981, p. 1.Google Scholar
8. Zijiu, Liu, “Shilun laodong jiuye he tigao laodong shengchanlude guanxi,” Hongqi, No. 4 (16 02 1980), p. 12.Google Scholar
9. Emerson, John Philip, “The labor force of China, 1957–80,” China Under The Four Modernizations, Selected papers submitted to the Joint Economic Commission, Congress of the United States (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1982), p. 241.Google Scholar
10. Emerson, ibid. p. 258.
11. Weizai, Meng, “Liming chao,” Zhongshan, No. 4 (1982), pp. 4–47.Google Scholar Also see Yalin, Wang and Jinrong, Li, “Urban worker's housework,” Social Sciences in China, Vol. 3, No. 2 (1982), pp. 147–65.Google Scholar
12. “Enhancing the role of women in socialist modernization,” Women of China, No. 3 (03 1983), p. 2.Google Scholar
13. “Views on topical women's issues,” Women of China, No. 5 (05 1983), pp. 3–7Google Scholar; “Beijingshi rendedaibiao zhengxie weiyuan zai xiaozu taolun huishang fayan zhaiyao,” Rentnin ribao, 30 04 1981, p. 3Google Scholar; “The Fifth National Women's Congress,” Beijing Review, No. 38 (19 09 1983), p. 6.Google Scholar
14. “The Fifth National Women's Congress.”
15. State Statistical Bureau, Statistical Yearbook of China, 1981 (Hong Kong: Economic Information Company, 1982), pp. 99–103.Google Scholar
16. Ibid. p. 123. Also see Emerson, , “The labor force of China,” pp. 261–62Google Scholar; and “Enhancing the role of women in socialist modernization.”
17. Zhenxin, Zhang, “Yuansheng nanhai she renzhi changqing,” Zhongguo funu, No. 11 (1982), p. 15.Google Scholar Also see Gongren ribao, 4 08 1982, p. 3.Google Scholar
18. “Tarnen qieshi guanxin nugong de laodong he shenghuo,” Gongren ribao, 11 03 1981, p. 2.Google Scholar
19. See Xinhua, 19 01 1983Google Scholar, in JPRS, 82880 (16 02 1983)Google Scholar; “For the healthy growth of China's 300 million children,” Beijing Review, 31 05 1982, p. 20Google Scholar; China Daily, 1 05 1982, p. 1Google Scholar; Shanxi ribao, 17 11 1982Google Scholar, in JPRS 82678 (19 01 1983).Google Scholar
20. Xinhua, 10 08 1983Google Scholar in FBIS, 11 08 1983, p. K–6.Google Scholar
21. Emerson, , “The labor force of China,” p. 261.Google Scholar
22. See Ta Kung Pao, 2 06 1983, p. 10Google Scholar; also Lan, Zhao, “Life of city dwellers,” Women of China, No. 1 (01 1983), pp. 2–7Google Scholar; Kang Keqing's address to Women's Federation Executive Committee, FBIS, 24 10 1980Google Scholar; “Views on topical women's issues,” and “The Fifth National Women's Congress.”
23. Naitao, Wu, “Rural women and the new economic policies,” Beijing Review, 7 03 1983, p. 19.Google Scholar
24. See “Take the road to common prosperity,” Beijing Review, No. 39 (26 09 1983), p. 4Google Scholar; “In the changing countryside,” Women of China, 07 1983, pp. 1–2Google Scholar, and Scherer, John, China Facts and Figures Annual 1982 (Gulf Breeze, Fl: Academic International Press, 1982), pp. 276–79.Google Scholar Average increases do not mean that the lives of all peasants have improved.
25. Scherer, John, China Facts and Figures Annual 1983 (Gulf Breeze, Fl: Academic International Press, 1983), pp. 154–55; 466.Google ScholarEmerson, , “The labor force of China,” p. 241Google Scholar, suggests that women made up more than 40% of the agricultural labour force in 1979.1 base the 50% figure on Scherer's estimate of 150 million peasant women in rural work in 1981, out of a total agricultural labour force of 300 million. This percentage is close to that mentioned by leading Chinese cadres.
26. Andors, Phyllis, The Unfinished Liberation of Chinese Women, 1949–1980 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1983), p. 165.Google Scholar
27. “Beijing Radio on protection of female infants,” JPRS, 83105 (21 03 1983), p. 124Google Scholar; “Yige zhende yinqi zhongshi de dawenti,” Renmin ribao, 7 04 1983, p. 4.Google Scholar For an opposing view, see Yaozhong, Li, Hande, Liu and Jiren, Cao, Renkou yanjiu, No. 4 (10 1981), pp. 25–29.Google Scholar
28. Zhenxin, Zhang, “Yuansheng nanhi shi renzhi changqing,” Zhongguo funu. No. 11 (11 1982), p. 15.Google Scholar Also see Gongren ribao, 4 08 1982, p. 3.Google Scholar
29. “An important measure for birth control.” Beijing Review, No. 28 (11 07 1983), pp. 24–25.Google Scholar
30. “Sample survey of birth rate of China's population,” Beijing Review, No. 39 (26 09 1983), p. 24.Google Scholar
31. “Old concepts hinder women's real emancipation,” Beijing Review, No. 36 (5 09 1983), p. 26Google Scholar; State Statistical Bureau, Statistical Yearbook, 1981, p. 458.Google Scholar
32. Hartmann, Heidi, “The family as the locus of gender, class and political struggle: the example of housework,” SIGNS, Vol. 6, No. 3 (Spring 1981), pp. 366–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
33. Nanjing xinhua ribao, 30 03 1960Google Scholar, in Selections from China's Mainland Press, No. 2261 (19 05 1960).Google Scholar Also see Zhongguo funu, 16 05 1959Google Scholar; Davin, Delia, Woman-Work (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1976)Google Scholar; Cangping, Yan. “Kongzhi renkou zhenchangyu woguo funude jinyibu jiefang,” Renmin ribao, 20 01 1981, p. 5Google Scholar; and “Yong Xianjinde kexue wenhua he zhizhi wuzhuang guangda funu,” Guangming ribao, 8 03 1980, p. 1.Google Scholar
34. “Industrial reorganization,” Beijing Review, 26 04 1982, p. 10.Google Scholar Also see “Dali fazhan xiaofei pinshengchan manzu renmin xuyao,” Renmin ribao, 3 07 1981, p. 3.Google Scholar
35. Guangyuan, Yu, “What is the aim of socialist production?” Beijing Review, No. 8 (23 02 1981), p. 17.Google Scholar
36. Xinhua, 30 11 1980Google Scholar, in FBIS, 2 12 1980, p. L-23.Google Scholar
37. Chengrui, Li and Zhongji, Zhang, “Zenyang kan sannianlai renminshenghuode bianhua,” Hongqi, No. 8 (16 04 1982), pp. 25–28Google Scholar; and FBIS, 7 07 1982.Google Scholar
38. See Ta Kung Pao, 24 02 1983, p. 4Google Scholar; “More consumer goods for peasants,” Beijing Review, 12 07 1982, p. 7.Google Scholar
39. Ta Kung Pao, 11 11 1982, p. 6Google Scholar; Xinhua, 20 02 1981Google Scholar, in FBIS, 23 02 1981.Google Scholar
40. Lei, Liang and Yifeng, Chi, “Workers ideas on marriage,” Women of China, No. 5 (05 1983), p. 17.Google Scholar
41. See Ta Kung Pao, 5 05 1983, p. 6Google Scholar; Ta Kung Pao, 27 01 1983, p. 6Google Scholar and “Manzurenmin de xuyao shishehuizuyi jianshede chonggao shiming.” Hongqi, No. 14 (16 07 1981), pp. 10–18.Google Scholar
42. Yalin, Wang and Jinrong, Li, “Urban worker's housework,” pp. 154–55.Google Scholar
43. “Call issued for better child care,” China Daily, 8 01 1983, p. 1.Google Scholar
44. Ta Kung Pao, China Handbook (Hong Kong: Ta Kung Pao, 1982), pp. 405–406.Google Scholar
45. Xinyan, Yu, “Yaozhongshi jiating jiaoyu,” Hongqi, No. 15 (1 08 1982), pp. 42–45.Google Scholar
46. Ratios derived from tables on education in “Education,” Beijing Review, No. 40 (3 10 1983), p. 26.Google Scholar The Statistical Yearbook of China states that 99.3% of kindergarten teachers are female. The 81% figure is given by Women of China, No. 3 (03 1983, p. 1.Google Scholar
47. See Beijing xinhua, 17 03 1983Google Scholar, in FBIS, 22 03 1983, p. R1.Google Scholar
48. “For the healthy growth of China's 300 million children,” Beijing Review, 31 05 1982, p. 21.Google Scholar
49. Personal interviews, Shandong (Summer 1982).
50. “Care for the youngsters,” Beijing Review, No. 22 (2 06 1980), p. 7Google Scholar; “Care for 380 million,” Beijing Review, No. 14 (6 04 1981), p. 5.Google Scholar
51. “For the healthy growth of China's 300 million children,” p. 24.Google Scholar
52. “The Fifth National Women's Congress.”
53. See Xinhua, 21 10 1980Google Scholar, in FBIS, 22 10 1980Google Scholar; Lan, Zhao, “Life of city dwellers,” Women of China, No. 1 (01 1983). pp. 2–7Google Scholar; Beijing ribao, 18 11 1979, p. 1Google Scholar; “Diversified economic forms encouraged,” Beijing Review, No. 38 (19 09 1983) p. 7.Google Scholar
54. Manni, Tan, “Lightening the load for working mothers,” China Reconstructs, 03 1980, pp. 19–22.Google Scholar
55. Yaobang, Hu, “Create a new situation in all fields of socialist modernization,” Twelfth National Congress of the CPC (Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1982), p. 76.Google Scholar
56. “Enhancing the role of women in socialist modernization,” Women of China, No. 3 (03 1983), pp. 1–3.Google Scholar
57. Chunyuan, Wang and Zheguang, Chen, “Zhongque chuli hunyin jiating wenti,” Hongqi, No. 5 (1 03 1982), pp. 37–59.Google Scholar
58. “Socialist home education,” Liaowang Observation-Post, in Beijing Review (31 05 1982), p. 26Google Scholar, and “Muqin yaozuo zinu de kaimo,” Renmin ribao, 29 03 1981, p. 3.Google Scholar
59. FBIS, 10 03 1980.Google Scholar Discussions I had with women in China during summer 1982 support this as well.
60. “Women holding up half the sky is a true comment,” Xinhua, 1 09 1983Google Scholar, in FBIS, 6 09 1983Google Scholar, p. K-16. Also see “Guo Liwen on current, pressing tasks for women,” Xinhua, 28 01 1983Google Scholar, in JPRS, 83105 (21 03 1983), p. 51.Google Scholar
61. “The improvement of people''s quality is an important aspect of women's work,” Xinhua, 1 09 1983Google Scholar, in FBIS, 6 09 1983, p. K-17.Google Scholar
62. “Guo Liwen on current pressing tasks for women.”
63. “Shengnan shengnu de wenti,” Zhongguo funu, No. 10 (1982), p. 46.Google Scholar
64. “Yige zhende yinqizhongshide dawenti,” Renmin ribao, 7 04 1983, p. 4.Google Scholar
65. Zhongguo qingnian bao, 9 11 1982, p. 3.Google Scholar
66. Song, Li, “Tichang hunyin jiating guanxizhongde daode wenming,” Beijing ribao, (4 09 1981), p. 3.Google Scholar
67. “Views on topical women's issues,” Women of China, No. 5 (05 1983), pp. 3–7.Google Scholar
68. Renkou yanjiu, 29 01 1982, pp. 11–14Google Scholar, in JPRS, 29 03 1982, p. 29.Google Scholar
69. Yalin, Wang and Jinrong, Li, “Urban worker's housework,” p. 163.Google Scholar
70. “Sample survey of birth rate of China's population,” p. 25Google Scholar; also see Tien, H. Yuan, “China: demographic billionaire,” Population Bulletin, Vol. 38, No. 2 (04 1983).Google Scholar
71. See, for instance, “Shengnan shengnu de wenti,” Zhongguo funu, No. 10 (1982), p. 46Google Scholar, and “Shengnu haiyou hezui?,” Zhongguo funu, No. 11 (1982), pp. 30–31.Google Scholar
72. The most recent argument along these lines is Ruth Cowan, Schwartz, More Work for Mother: The Ironies of Household Technology from the Open Hearth to the Microwave (New York: Basic Books, 1983).Google Scholar
73. Yalin, Wang and Jinrong, Li, “Urban worker's housework,” p. 152.Google Scholar
74. The ACWF newly-established legal advisory panel has reported that over half of their clients have complained of persecution by their husbands for failing to give birth to sons. The number of divorces in 1982 was the highest since the Third Plenum, with a total of 370,000 approved. Ma Yuan, deputy director of the civil division of the Supreme People's Court, says that “more women have been asking for divorces because they cannot stand their bullying husbands.” See Beijing Review, No. 37 (12 09 1983), pp. 5–6.Google Scholar Also see Beijing Xinhua, 16 07 1983Google Scholar, in FBIS, 19 07 1983Google Scholar, p. K12; “Zhongnan qingnu haide wojia porenwang,” Zhongguo funu, No. 10 (1982), p. 44Google Scholar; and Xinhua, 27 07 1983Google Scholar, in FBIS, 2 08 1983, p. K19.Google Scholar
75. A good example here is the letter to the editor 15 peasant women from Anhui province wrote to Renmin ribao. In the letter they betrayed a frustration and antipathy to the system, since they “simply cannot understand why 32 years after China's liberation, we women are still so heavily weighed down by backward feudal concepts.” See Renmim ribao, 23 03 1983, p. 5.Google Scholar
- 55
- Cited by