Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T01:51:20.279Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Early Medieval Antonine Wall*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 April 2015

Adrián Maldonado
Adrián Maldonado*
Affiliation:
University of [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Archaeological fieldwork in the Forth-Clyde isthmus has been dominated by the World Heritage Monument of the Antonine Wall, the Roman frontier built in the second century a.d. Considerably less attention has been given to the evidence for post-Roman experience of the Wall and how it was remembered (and forgotten) in the subsequent centuries. This paper will briefly summarise historical notices of the Antonine Wall, then consider the archaeological and toponymic evidence for early medieval occupation. The role of the Forth-Clyde isthmus as a political frontier is shown to be less significant to our understanding of this period than the evidence for mobility, memory and the contested legacy of Rome in early medieval Scotland.

Keywords

Antonine WallForth-Clyde isthmusearly medieval Scotlandreusememoryplace-names
Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 46 , November 2015 , pp. 225 - 245
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2015. Published by The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

Pre-1974 county abbreviations used: ANG

Angus

BWK

Berwickshire

BTE

Bute

DMF

Dumfriesshire

DNB

Dunbartonshire

ELO

East Lothian

FIF

Fife

KCD

Kincardineshire

LAN

Lanarkshire

MLO

Midlothian

PEB

Peeblesshire

PER

Perthshire

ROX

Roxburghshire

SLK

Selkirkshire

STL

Stirlingshire

WLO

West Lothian

WIG

Wigtownshire

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Abercromby, J., Ross, T., and Anderson, J. 1902: ‘Account of the excavation of the Roman station at Inchtuthil, Perthshire, undertaken by the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland in 1901’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 36, 182–242CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alcock, L. 2003: Kings and Warriors, Craftsmen and Priests in Northern Britain AD 550–850, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Alcock, L., Alcock, E., and Driscoll, S. 1989: ‘Reconnaissance excavations on Early Historic fortifications and other royal sites in Scotland, 1974–84: 3, Excavations at Dundurn, Strathearn, Perthshire, 1976–77’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 119, 189–226CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Armit, I. 1999: ‘The abandonment of souterrains: evolution, catastrophe or dislocation?’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 129, 577–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ashmore, P.J. 1980: ‘Low cairns, long cists and symbol stones’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 110, 346–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailey, G. 1996: ‘The graveyards of Falkirk district: Part 1’, Calatria 9, 1–34Google Scholar
Bailey, G. 1997: ‘Excavation of Roman, medieval and later features at Carriden Roman fort annexe in 1994’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 127, 577–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailey, G. 2003: ‘The graveyards of Falkirk district: Part 7, Carriden Old Parish Churchyard’, Calatria 18, 1–38Google Scholar
Bailey, G. 2007: ‘An early timber hall at Callendar Park, Falkirk’, Calatria 24, 37–58Google Scholar
Barber, J. 1982: ‘The Deil's Dyke, Nithsdale’, Transactions of the Dumfries and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society, 3rd Ser., 62, 29–50Google Scholar
Barrow, G. 1983: ‘The childhood of Scottish Christianity’, Scottish Studies 27, 1–15Google Scholar
Barrow, G. 2003: The Kingdom of the Scots: Government, Church and Society from the Eleventh to the Fourteenth Century (2nd edn), EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Bede, Ecclesiastical History of the English People, Eds Colgrave, B. and Mynors, R. (1991), Oxford Medieval Texts, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Bell, T. 2005: The Religious Reuse of Roman Structures in Early Medieval England, BAR British Series 390, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Breeze, D. 1996: Roman Scotland, LondonGoogle Scholar
Breeze, D. 2006: The Antonine Wall, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Breeze, D. 2014: ‘Commemorating the Wall: Roman sculpture and inscriptions from Hadrian's Wall’, in Collins, R. and McIntosh, F. (eds), Life in the Limes: Studies of the People and Objects of the Roman Frontiers, Oxford, 59–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Breeze, D., Close-Brooks, J., and Ritchie, J. 1976: ‘Soldiers’ burials at Camelon, Stirlingshire, 1922 and 1975’, Britannia 7, 73–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Broun, D. 2007: Scottish Independence and the Idea of Britain from the Picts to Alexander III, EdinburghCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, I., and Vasey, P. 1989: ‘Arthur's O'on again: newly-discovered drawings by John Adair and their context’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 119, 353–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, E. 2003: ‘Royal inaugurations in Dál Riata and the Stone of Destiny’, in Welander, R., Breeze, D. and Clancy, T. (eds), The Stone of Destiny: Artefact and Icon, Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph Series, Edinburgh, 43–59Google Scholar
Campbell, E. 2007: Continental and Mediterranean Imports to Atlantic Britain and Ireland, AD 400–800, CBA Research Report 157, YorkGoogle Scholar
Cessford, C. 1999: ‘Relations between the Britons of southern Scotland and Anglo-Saxon Northumbria’, in Hawkes, J. and Mills, S. (eds), Northumbria's Golden Age, Stroud, 150–60Google Scholar
Cessford, C. 2001: ‘Post-Severan Cramond: a late Roman and Early Historic British and Anglo-Saxon religious centre?’ The Heroic Age 4, http://www.heroicage.org/issues/4/Cessford.htmlGoogle Scholar
Christison, D., Cunningham, J., Anderson, J., and Ross, T. 1898: ‘Account of the excavation of the Roman station at Ardoch, Perthshire, undertaken by the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland in 1896–97’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 32, 399–476CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clancy, T. 2004: ‘Philosopher-king: Nechtan mac Der-Ilei’, Scottish Historical Review 83 (2), 125–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clancy, T. 2009: ‘The cults of Saints Patrick and Palladius in early medieval Scotland’, in Boardman, S., Davies, J. and Williamson, E. (eds), Saints’ Cults in the Celtic World, Woodbridge, 18–41Google Scholar
Clarke, D. 2007: ‘Reading the multiple lives of Pictish symbol stones’, Medieval Archaeology 51, 19–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clarke, D., Goldberg, M., and Blackwell, A. 2012: Early Medieval Scotland: Individuals, Communities and Ideas, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Close-Brooks, J. 1986: ‘Excavations at Clatchard Craig, Fife’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 116, 117–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Collins, R. 2012: Hadrian's Wall and the End of Empire: The Roman Frontier in the 4th and 5th Centuries, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Collins, R., and Allason-Jones, L. (eds) 2010: Finds from the Frontier: Material Culture in the 4th–5th Centuries, CBA Research Report 162, YorkGoogle Scholar
Corder, S., Cowley, D.C., and Ward, T. 1999: ‘Abbey Knowe (Lyne parish), long cists’, Discovery and Excavation in Scotland, 76–7Google Scholar
Curle, A. 1905: ‘Description of the fortifications on Ruberslaw, Roxburghshire, and notices of Roman remains found there’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 39, 219–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dark, K. 2000: Britain and the End of the Roman Empire, StroudGoogle Scholar
Donnely, W. 1897: ‘Notes of a stone on the moor near Dullatur, called the Carrick Stone’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 31, 228–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Driscoll, S. 1998a: ‘Formalising the mechanisms of state power: early Scottish lordship from the 9th to the 13th centuries’, in Foster, S., Macinnes, A. and MacInnes, R. (eds), Scottish Power Centres, Glasgow, 32–58Google Scholar
Driscoll, S. 1998b: ‘Picts and prehistory: cultural resource management in early medieval Scotland’, World Archaeology 30 (1), 142–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Driscoll, S., and Forsyth, K. 2004: ‘The late Iron Age and Early Historic period: Dundonald Castle excavations 1986–93’, Scottish Archaeological Journal 26, 4–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Driscoll, S., O'Grady, O., and Forsyth, K. 2005: ‘The Govan School revisited: searching for meaning in the early medieval sculpture of Strathclyde’, in Foster and Cross 2005, 135–58Google Scholar
Drummond, P. 2014: An Analysis of Toponyms and Toponymic Patterns in Eight Parishes of the Upper Kelvin Basin, unpub. PhD thesis, University of GlasgowGoogle Scholar
Duffy, P. (ed.) 2003: Marshill, Alloa, GUARD report 1478, GlasgowGoogle Scholar
Dumville, D. 1994: ‘The eastern terminus of the Antonine Wall: 12th- or 13th-century evidence’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 124, 293–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dunwell, A., and Ralston, I. 1995: ‘Excavations at Inveravon on the Antonine Wall, 1991’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 125, 521–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dunwell, A., Bailey, G., Leslie, A., and Smith, A. 2002: ‘Some excavations on the line of the Antonine Wall, 1994–2001’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 132, 259–304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Durkan, J. 1998: ‘Cadder and environs, and the development of the Church in Glasgow in the twelfth century’, Innes Review 46 (2), 127–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eckardt, H., and Williams, H. 2003: ‘Objects without a past?’ in Williams, H. (ed.), Archaeologies of Remembrance: Death and Memory in Past Societies, London, 141–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fletcher, J. 1952: ‘Two Kirkintilloch antiquities: carved dragon head and short cist’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 86, 202CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forman, A. 1845: ‘Parish of Kirkintilloch’, New Statistical Account of Scotland 8, Edinburgh, 168–211Google Scholar
Forsyth, K. 2005: ‘Hic memoria perpetua: the early inscribed stones of southern Scotland in context’, in Foster and Cross 2005, 113–34Google Scholar
Forsyth, K. 2009: ‘The Latinus Stone: Whithorn's earliest Christian monument’, in Murray 2009, 19–24Google Scholar
Foster, S. 2004: Picts, Gaels and Scots (2nd edn), LondonGoogle Scholar
Foster, S., and Cross, M. (eds) 2005: Able Minds and Practiced Hands: Scotland's Early Medieval Sculpture in the 21st Century, Society for Medieval Archaeology Monograph, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Fraser, I. 2008: The Pictish Symbol Stones of Scotland, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Fraser, J. 2008: ‘Bede, the Firth of Forth, and the location of Urbs Iudeu’, Scottish Historical Review 87 (1), 1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fraser, J. 2009: From Caledonia to Pictland: Scotland to 795, New Edinburgh History Series, EdinburghCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fraser, J. 2013: ‘St Patrick and barbarian northern Britain in the fifth century’, in Hunter and Painter 2013, 15–27Google Scholar
Gardner, A. 2007: An Archaeology of Identity: Soldiers and Society in Late Roman Britain, Walnut Creek, CAGoogle Scholar
Gildas, The Ruin of Britain, and Other Works, Ed. Winterbottom, M. (1978), Arthurian Period Sources 7, LondonGoogle Scholar
Griffiths, H. 2001: ‘Britain in ruins: the Picts’ Wall and the union of the two crowns’, Rethinking History 7 (1), 89–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haldane, A. 1997: The Drove Roads of Scotland, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Halsall, G. 2012: ‘Northern Britain and the fall of the Roman Empire’, The Medieval Journal 2 (2), 1–25Google Scholar
Hanson, W. 2003: ‘The Roman presence: brief interludes’, in Edwards, K. and Ralston, I. (eds), Scotland After the Ice Age, Edinburgh, 195–216Google Scholar
Hanson, W., and Maxwell, G. 1983: Rome's North West Frontier: The Antonine Wall, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Harding, D. 2006: ‘Redefining the Northern British Iron Age’, Oxford Journal of Archaeology 25 (1), 61–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henshall, A. 1966: ‘Second report of cist burials at Parkburn Sandpit, Lasswade, Midlothian’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 98, 204–14CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hill, P. 1997: Whithorn and St Ninian: the Excavation of a Monastic Town, 1984–91, StroudGoogle Scholar
Hingley, R. 2010: ‘“The most ancient Boundary between England and Scotland”: genealogies of the Roman Walls’, Classical Receptions Journal 2 (1), 25–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hingley, R. 2012: Hadrian's Wall: A Life, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hingley, R., Witcher, R., and Nesbitt, C. 2012: ‘Life of an ancient monument: Hadrian's Wall in history’, Antiquity 86, 760–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holmes, N. 2003: Excavation of Roman Sites at Cramond, Edinburgh, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Hornshaw, T. 2000: ‘The Wall of Severus?’ Archaeologia Aeliana 28, 27–36Google Scholar
Hunter, F. 2007: Beyond the Edge of the Empire – Caledonians, Picts and Romans, RosemarkieGoogle Scholar
Hunter, F. 2010: ‘Beyond the frontier: interpreting late Roman Iron Age indigenous and imported material culture’, in Collins and Allason-Jones 2010, 96–109Google Scholar
Hunter, F. 2013: ‘Hillfort and hacksilber: Traprain Law in the late Roman Iron Age and Early Historic period’, in Hunter and Painter 2013, 3–10Google Scholar
Hunter, F., and Painter, K. (eds) 2013: Late Roman Silver: The Traprain Treasure in Context, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
James, S. 2001: ‘Soldiers and civilians: identity and interaction in Roman Britain’, in James, S. and Millett, M. (eds), Britons and Romans: Advancing an Archaeological Agenda, CBA Research Report 125, York, 77–89Google Scholar
Jobey, G. 1978: ‘Burnswark Hill, Dumfriesshire’, Transactions of the Dumfries and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society 53, 57–104Google Scholar
Jones, A. 2007: Memory and Material Culture. Topics in Contemporary Archaeology, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keppie, L. 2012: The Antiquarian Rediscovery of the Antonine Wall, EdinburghCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keppie, L., and Walker, J.J. 1985: ‘Auchendavy Roman fort and settlement’, Britannia 16, 29–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lowe, C. 2006: Exacavations at Hoddom, Dumfriesshire, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Macquarrie, A. 1997: The Saints of Scotland, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Maldonado, A. 2011a: Christianity and Burial in Late Iron Age Scotland, AD 400–650, unpub. PhD thesis, University of GlasgowGoogle Scholar
Maldonado, A. 2011b: ‘What does early Christianity look like? Mortuary archaeology and conversion in Late Iron Age Scotland’, Scottish Archaeological Journal 33 (1–2), 39–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maldonado, A. 2013: ‘Burial in early medieval Scotland: new questions’, Medieval Archaeology 57, 1–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mann, J., and Breeze, D. 1987: ‘Ptolemy, Tacitus and the tribes of north Britain, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 117, 85–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Masser, P. 2006: ‘Cramond Roman fort: evidence from excavations at Cramond Kirk Hall, 1998 and 2001’, Scottish Archaeological Internet Reports 20 http://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/archives/view/sair/contents.cfm?vol=20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mattingly, D. 2006: An Imperial Possession: Britain in the Roman Empire, 54 BC–AD 409, LondonGoogle Scholar
McCarthy, M. 2009: ‘Christianity in northern Britain in the late-Roman period: a critical assessment’, in Murray 2009, 57–70Google Scholar
McCord, N., and Tait, J. 1978: ‘Excavations at Kerse, East Polmont, Stirlingshire, July 1963’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 109, 151–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murray, J. (ed.) 2009: St Ninian and the Earliest Christianity in Scotland, BAR British Series 483, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Nesbitt, C., and Tolia-Kelly, D. 2009: ‘Embodied archaeologies of the linear monument’, Journal of Social Archaeology 9 (3), 368–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicolaisen, W. 1976: Scottish Place-Names: Their Study and Significance, LondonGoogle Scholar
O'Brien, C. 2010: ‘The emergence of Northumbria: artefacts, archaeology and models’, in Collins and Allason-Jones 2010, 110–19Google Scholar
Padel, O. 1994: ‘The nature of Arthur’, Cambrian Medieval Celtic Studies 27, 1–31Google Scholar
Petts, D. 2013: ‘Military and civilian: reconfiguring the end of Roman Britain in the North’, European Journal of Archaeology 16 (2), 314–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pitts, L., and St Joseph, J.K. 1985: Inchtuthil: The Roman Legionary Fortress, Britannia Monograph 6, LondonGoogle Scholar
Proudfoot, E. 1997: ‘Abernethy and Mugdrum: towards reassessment’, in Henry, D. (ed.), The Worm, the Germ, and the Thorn: Pictish and Related Studies Presented to Isabel Henderson, Balgavies, 47–63Google Scholar
RCAHMS 1956: An Inventory of the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Roxburghshire, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Rees, A. 2002: ‘A first millennium AD cemetery, rectangular Bronze Age structure and late prehistoric settlement at Thornybank, Midlothian’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 132, 313–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Robertson, A. 2001: The Antonine Wall: A Handbook to the Surviving Remains (5th edn), GlasgowGoogle Scholar
Rohl, D. 2014: More than a Roman Monument: A Place-centred Approach to the Long-term History and Archaeology of the Antonine Wall, unpub. PhD thesis, Durham UniversityGoogle Scholar
Rorke, M., Dennison, E.P., Stronach, S., and Coleman, R. 2009: Historic Kirkintilloch: Archaeology and Development. Scottish Burgh Survey, BoothamGoogle Scholar
Ross, T. 1898: ‘Notice of the remains of a mediaeval chapel found in the Roman station at Ardoch’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 32, 471–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Semple, S. 1998: ‘A fear of the past: the place of the prehistoric burial mound in the ideology of middle and later Anglo-Saxon England’, World Archaeology 30 (1), 109–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Semple, S. 2013: Perceptions of the Prehistoric in Anglo-Saxon England: Religion, Ritual, and Rulership in the Landscape, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sheridan, A., Goldberg, M., and Clarke, D. 2010: ‘Radiocarbon dates arranged through the National Museum of Scotland Archaeology Department during 2009/10’, Discovery and Excavation in Scotland 11, 205–6Google Scholar
Smith, S. 1939: ‘An indeterminate structure and a hearth found outside the Roman fort at Mumrills’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 73, 319–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smyth, A. 1984; Warlords and Holy Men: Scotland AD 80–1000, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Steer, K. 1961: ‘Excavations at Mumrills Roman fort, 1958–60’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 94, 86–132CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tatton-Brown, T. 1980: ‘Arthur's O'on and the main supply base for the Antonine Wall’, Britannia 11, 340–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, S. 1998: ‘Place-names and the early Church in Scotland’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society 28, 1–22Google Scholar
Taylor, S. 2006: ‘The early history and languages of West Dunbartonshire’, in Brown, I. (ed.), Changing Identities, Ancient Roots: The History of West Dunbartonshire from Earliest Times, Edinburgh, 12–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, S. 2011: ‘Pictish place-names revisited’, in Driscoll, S., Geddes, J. and Hall, M. (eds), Pictish Progress: New Studies on Northern Britain in the Early Middle Ages. The Northern World, Leiden, 67–118Google Scholar
Tipping, R., and Tisdall, E. 2005: ‘The landscape context of the Antonine Wall: a review of the literature’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 135, 443–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Watson, T. 1894: Kirkintilloch: Town and Parish, GlasgowGoogle Scholar
Watson, W. 1926: The History of the Celtic Place-Names of Scotland, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Whitworth, A. 2000: Hadrian's Wall: Some Aspects of its Post-Roman Influence on the Landscape, BAR British Series 296, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, H. 1998: ‘Monuments and the past in early Anglo-Saxon England’, World Archaeology 30 (1), 90–108CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilmott, T. 2000: ‘The late Roman transition at Birdoswald and on Hadrian's Wall’, in Wilmott and Wilson 2000, 13–24Google Scholar
Wilmott, T., and Wilson, P. (eds) 2000: The Late Roman Transition in the North, BAR British Series 299, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Wilson, D. 1992: Anglo-Saxon Paganism, LondonGoogle Scholar
Winlow, S., and Cook, G. 2010: ‘Two new dates from two old investigations: a reconsideration of the Women's Knowe, Inchtuthil and Kingoodie long cist cemetery, Invergowrie’, Tayside and Fife Archaeological Journal 16, 48–56Google Scholar
Witcher, R. 2010: ‘The fabulous tales of the common people, part 2: encountering Hadrian's Wall’, Public Archaeology 9 (4), 211–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Witcher, R., Tolia-Kelly, D., and Hingley, R. 2010: ‘Archaeologies of landscape: excavating the materialities of Hadrian's Wall’, Journal of Material Culture 15, 105–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Woolf, A. 2003: ‘The Britons: from Romans to barbarians’, in Goetz, H.-W., Jarnut, J. and Pohl, W. (eds), Regna and Gentes: the Relationship Between Late Antique and Early Medieval Peoples and Kingdoms in the Transformation of the Roman World, Transformation of the Roman World 13, Leiden, 345–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Woolliscroft, D. 2000: ‘More thoughts on why the Romans failed to conquer Scotland’, Scottish Archaeological Journal 22 (2), 111–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar