Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T20:46:41.197Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Gnosticism’ in Fourth-Century Britain: the Frampton Mosaics Reconsidered

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

Dominic Perring
Dominic Perring
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology, University of York, [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Recent years have seen a renewed interest in the significance of the mosaic designs employed in Roman houses. Studies have concentrated on establishing the mythological sources of the images chosen, and on describing the social and architectural contexts within which such art was used. It has long been noted that some of the subjects preferred in fourth-century Britain suggest allegorical references to the hereafter, although it has also been observed that the ‘search for profound and coherent allegories may exaggerate the significance which the wealthy British patrons imparted to the floors of the great halls or dining-rooms of their villas’. Ling, in particular, has cautioned against reading exaggerated meanings into ambivalent images that may simply have been chosen to vaunt erudite taste.

Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 34 , November 2003 , pp. 97 - 127
Copyright
Copyright © Dominic Perring 2003. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

AbuZayd, S. 1989: ‘The acts of Thomas and the unity of the dualistic world in the Syrian Orient“, ARAM 1.2, 217–52Google Scholar
Arthur, P. 1977: ‘Eggs and pomegranates. An example of symbolism in Roman Britain’, in Munby, J. and Henig, M. (eds), Roman Life and Art in Britain, British Archaeological Reports 41(ii), Oxford, 367–74Google Scholar
Barrett, A.A. 1977: ‘A Virgilian scene from the Frampton Roman villa, Dorset’, Antiq. Journal 57, 312–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barrett, A.A. 1978: ‘Literary classics in Roman Britain’, Britannia 9, 307–14CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beeson, A. 1996: ‘Pegasus the Wonder Horse and his portrayal on Romano-British mosaics’. Mosaic 23, 18–23Google Scholar
Beeson, A. 2000: ‘The Frampton Trident Bearer’, Mosaic 27, 4–7Google Scholar
Bhaldraithe, E. de 1991: ‘Strainers and other instruments in early Church ritual’, in Watts, D.. Christians and Pagans in Roman Britain, London & New York, 231–3Google Scholar
Birley, A.R. 1993: Review of Collingwood, R.G. and Wright, R.P., RIB. Vol. 2. Instrumentum Domesticum (Personal Belongings and the Like), JRS 83, 237–9Google Scholar
Black, E.W. 1986: ‘Christian and pagan hopes of salvation in Romano-British mosaics’, in Henig, M. and King, A. (eds), Pagan Gods and Shrines of the Roman Empire, Oxford University School of Archaeology Monograph 8, Oxford, 147–58Google Scholar
Black, E.W. 1987: The Roman Villas of South East England, British Archaeological Reports 171. OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowersock, G.W. 1990: Hellenism in Late Antiquity, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowes, K. 2001: ‘“Nee sedere in villam“. Villa-churches, rural piety, and the Priscillianist controversy’, in Burns, T.S. and Eadie, J.W. (eds), Urban Centres and Rural Contexts in Late Antiquity, Michigan. 323–48Google Scholar
Brandenburg, H. 1968: ‘Bellerophon Christianus?’, Römische Quartalschrift 63, 49–86Google Scholar
Brandenburg, H. 1969: ‘Christussymbole in frühchristlichen Bodenmosaiken’, Römische Quartalschrift 64, 75–138Google Scholar
Brilliant, R. 1979: ‘Mythology’, in Weizmann, K. (ed.), Age of Spirituality: Late Antique and Early Christian Art, Third to Seventh Century, New York, 129–98Google Scholar
Brown, P. 1992: Power and Persuasion in Late Antiquity, Madison, WisconsinGoogle Scholar
Brown, P. 1998: Late Antiquity, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Carandini, A. 1982: Filosofiana: the Villa of Piazza Armerina, PalermoGoogle Scholar
Chuvin, P. 1990: A Chronicle of the Last Pagans, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Cosh, S.R. 1996: ‘A possible Achilles at Frampton’, Mosaic 23, 13–15Google Scholar
Crummy, P. 1980: ‘Mosaics from Middleborough, Colchester’, Mosaic 2, 5–9Google Scholar
Cunliffe, B.W. 1971: Excavations at Fishbourne 1961–69 Vol. 1, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Dickmann, J.-A. 1997: ‘The peristyle and the transformation of domestic space in Hellenistic Pompeii’, in Laurence, R. and Wallace-Hadrill, A. (eds), Domestic Space in the Roman World: Pompeii and Beyond, JRA Suppl. Ser. 22, Michigan, 121–36Google Scholar
Dunbabin, K.M.D. 1999: Mosaics of the Creek and Roman World, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Eisler, R. 1925: Orphisch-dionysische Mysteriengedanken in der christlichen Antike, Liepzig & BerlinGoogle Scholar
Elderkin, G.W. 1924: ‘The continuity of pagan and eucharistie symbolism’, in Kantharos: Studies in Dionysiac and Kindred Cult, Princeton, 41–7Google Scholar
Eisner, J. 1998: Imperial Rome and Christian Triumph, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Eriksen, R.T. 1980: ‘Syncretic symbolism and the Christian Roman mosaic at Hinton St Mary: a closer reading’, Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History and Archaeological Society 102, 43–8Google Scholar
Esmonde-Cleary, A.S. 1989: The Ending of Roman Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Farrar, R.A.H. 1956: ‘The “Frampton Villa“, Maiden Newton’, Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History and Archaeological Society 78, 81–3Google Scholar
Ferguson, J. 1970: The Religions of the Roman Empire, LondonGoogle Scholar
Flood, F.B. 1999: ‘Light in stone. The commemoration of the Prophet in Umayyad architecture’, in Jones, J. (ed.), Bayt al-Maqdis. Jerusalem and Early Islam, Oxford, 311–59Google Scholar
Fox, G.E. 1887: ‘The Roman Villa at Chedworth, Gloucestershire’, Archaeological Journal 44, 322–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frend, W.H.C. 1968: ‘The Christianization of Roman Britain’, in Barley, M.W. and Hanson, R.P.C. (eds), Christianity in Britain, 300–700, Leicester, 46–9Google Scholar
Frend, W.H.C. 1984–1985: ‘Syrian parallels to the Water Newton treasure?’, Jahrbuch für Antike und Christentum 27–8, 146–50Google Scholar
Frend, W.H.C. 1992: ‘Pagans, Christians, and “the Barbarian Conspiracy” of A.D. 367 in Roman Britain’, Britannia 23, 121–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frere, S.S. 1987: Britannia: a History of Roman Britain (3rd edn), LondonGoogle Scholar
Friedländer, P. 1939: Spätantiker Gemäldezyklus in Gaza, VaticanGoogle Scholar
Friedman, J.B. 2000: Orpheus in the Middle Ages, New YorkGoogle Scholar
Guthrie, W.K.C. 1966: Orpheus and Greek Religion: a Study of the Orphic Movement, New YorkGoogle Scholar
Guy, C.J. 1981: ‘Roman circular lead tanks in Britain’, Britannia 12, 271–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harries, J. 1992: ‘Christianity and the city in Gaul’, in Rich, J. (ed.), The City in Late Antiquity, London, 77–98Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1977a: ‘Roman gemstones: figuretype and adaptation’, in Munby, J. and Henig, M. (eds), Roman Life and Art in Britain, British Archaeological Reports 41 (ii), Oxford, 341–6Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1977b: ‘Death and the maiden: funerary symbolism in daily life’, in Munby, J. and Henig, M. (eds), Roman Life and Art in Britain, British Archaeological Reports 41 (ii), Oxford, 347–66Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1984: ‘James Engleheart's drawing of a mosaic at Frampton, 1794’, Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History and Archaeological Society 106, 146Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1986a: ‘“Ita intellexit numine inductus tuo“: some personal interpretations of deity in Roman religion’, in Henig, M. and King, A. (eds), Pagan Gods and Shrines of the Roman Empire, Oxford University School of Archaeology Monograph 8, Oxford, 159–70Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1986b: ‘Late Roman mosaics in Britain, myth and meaning’, Mosaic 13, 13–20Google Scholar
Henig, M. 1995: The Art of Roman Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Henig, M. 1997: ‘The Lullingstone mosaic: art, religion and letters in a fourth-century villa’, Mosaic 24, 4–7Google Scholar
Henig, M. 2002: The Heirs of King Verica. Culture and Politics in Roman Britain, StroudGoogle Scholar
Henig, M., and Soffe, G. 1993: ‘The Thruxton Roman villa and its mosaic pavement’, Journal of the British Archaeological Association 146, 1–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Highet, G. 1957: The Classical Tradition, New YorkGoogle Scholar
Huskinson, J. 1974: ‘Some pagan mythological figures and their significance in early Christian art’, Papers British School Rome 42, 68–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hutchinson, V. 1986: Bacchus in Roman Britain, British Archaeological Reports 151, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Johns, C.M. 1986a: ‘Faunus at Thetford: an early Latian deity in late Roman Britain’, in Henig, M. and King, A. (eds), Pagan Gods and Shrines of the Roman Empire, Oxford University School of Archaeology Monograph 8, Oxford, 93–104Google Scholar
Johnson, P. 1983: ‘The Ilchester Lindinis Officina’, Mosaic 8, 5–8Google Scholar
Johnston, D.E. 1987: ‘Dolphins in Romano-British mosaics’, Mosaic 14, 18–22Google Scholar
Jonas, H. 1958: Gnostic Religion, BostonGoogle Scholar
Jones, C.P. 1991: ‘Dinner theatre’, in Slater, W.J. (ed.), Dining in a Classical Context, Ann Arbor, 185–98Google Scholar
Jung, C.G. 1979: ‘Transformation symbolism in the Mass’, in Campbell, J. (ed.), Eranos. Papers from the Eranos Yearbooks 2: The Mysteries, New York, 274–336Google Scholar
Koortbojian, M. 1995: Myth, Meaning and Memory on Roman Sarchophagi, LondonGoogle Scholar
Legge, F. 1964: Forerunners and Rivals of Christianity, New YorkGoogle Scholar
Ling, R. 1997: ‘Mosaics in Roman Britain: discoveries and research since 1945’, Britannia 28, 259–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lissarrague, F. 1990: ‘Around the krater: an aspect of banquet imagery’, in Murray, O. (ed.), Sympotica. A Symposium on the Symposion, Oxford, 196–209CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lysons, S. 1817: Reliquiae Britannico-Romanae iii, LondonGoogle Scholar
Mango, M.M. 1986: Silver from Early Byzantium: the Kaper Koraon and Related Treasures, BaltimoreGoogle Scholar
Meates, G.W. 1979: The Lullingstone Roman Villa. I: The Site, Kent Archaeological Society Monograph 1, MaidstoneGoogle Scholar
Meyer, M.W., and Robinson, J.M. 1981: The Nag Hammadi Library in English (2nd edn), San FranciscoGoogle Scholar
Murray, O. 1990: ‘Sympotic history’, in Murray, O. (ed.), Sympotica. A Symposium on the Symposion, Oxford, 3–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muth, S. 1998: Erleben von Raum – Leben im Raum: zur Funktion mythologischer Mosaikbilder in der römisch-kaiserzeitlichen Wohnarchitektur, HeidelbergGoogle Scholar
Pageis, E. 1979: The Gnostic Gospels, LondonGoogle Scholar
Painter, K.S. 1967: ‘The Roman site at Hinton St Mary’, BM Quarterly 32, 15–31Google Scholar
Painter, K.S. 1971: ‘Villas and Christianity in Roman Britain’, BM Quarterly 35, 156–75Google Scholar
Painter, K.S. 1977: The Mildenhall Treasure, LondonGoogle Scholar
Painter, K.S. 1999: ‘The Water Newton silver: votive or liturgical?’, Journal of the British Archaeological Association 152, 1–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pellizer, E. 1990: ‘Outlines of sympotic entertainment’, in Murray, O. (ed.), Sympotica. A Symposium on the Symposion, Oxford, 177–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perring, D. 1991: Roman London, LondonGoogle Scholar
Perring, D. 2002: The Roman House in Britain, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perring, D. 2003: ‘Deconstructing the Frampton pavements: Gnostic dialectic in Roman Britain?’, in Carr, G., Swift, E. and Weekes, J. (eds), TRAC 2002: Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual Theoretical Archaeology-Conference, Canterbury 2002, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Petts, D. 2003: ‘Votive hoards in late Roman Britain: pagan or Christian?’, in Carver, M. (ed.), The Cross Goes North. The Age of Conversion in Northern Europe, AD 300–1300, York, 109–18Google Scholar
Reece, R. 1980: ‘A date for Hinton St Mary?’, Mosaic 2, 21–2Google Scholar
Roberti, M.M. 1984: Milano Romana, MilanGoogle Scholar
Roberts, A., and Donaldson, D. (eds) 1950–1957: The Ante-Nicene Fathers: Translations of the Writings of the Fathers down to AD 325, Grand RapidsGoogle Scholar
Rogers, C.F. 1903: Baptism and Christian Archaeology, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Rossi, G.B. de 1867: Roma Sotterranea, RomeGoogle Scholar
Rossiter, J. 1991: ‘Convivium and villain late antiquity’, in Slater, W.J. (ed.), Dining in a Classical Context, Ann Arbor, 199–214Google Scholar
Rossiter, J. 2002: ‘Houses in Roman Britain’, Journal of Roman Archaeology 15, 625–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rowsome, P. 2000: Heart of the City: Roman, Medieval and Modern London Revealed by Archaeology at I Poultry, LondonGoogle Scholar
Rudkin, D. 1981: ‘Recent discoveries at Fishbourne Roman palace’, Mosaic 4, 8–10Google Scholar
Rudolph, K. 1983: Gnosis: The Nature and History of Gnosticism (transl. Wilson, R.), EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Russel, J.C. 1994: The Germanization of Early Medieval Christianity. A Sociohistorical Approach to Religious Transformation, New York & OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schaff, P. 1889: History of the Christian Church: Ante-Nicene Christianity: AD 100–325, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Scott, S. 2000: Art and Society in Fourth-Century Britain: Villa Mosaics in Context, Oxford University School of Archaeology Monograph 53, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Shepherd, J.D. 1998: The Temple of Mithras, London: Excavations by W.F. Grimes and A. Williams at the Walbrook, EH Archaeological Report 12, LondonGoogle Scholar
Slofstra, J. 1995: ‘The villa in the Roman West: space decoration and ideology’, in Metzler, J., Millett, M., Roymans, N. and Slofstra, J. (eds), Integration in the Early Roman West, Dossier d'Archéologie du Musée National d'Histoire et d'Art 4, Luxembourg, 77–90Google Scholar
Smith, B.F. 1956: Architectural Symbolism of Imperial Rome and the Middle Ages, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
Smith, D.J. 1969: ‘The mosaic pavements’, in Rivet, A.L.F. (ed.), The Roman Villa in Britain, London, 71–125Google Scholar
Smith, D.J. 1977: ‘Mythological figures and scenes in Romano-British mosaics’, in Munby, J. and Henig, M. (eds), Roman Life and Art in Britain, British Archaeological Reports 41(i), Oxford, 105–94Google Scholar
Smith, J.T. 1997: Roman Villas: a Study in Social Structure, London & New YorkGoogle Scholar
Stupperich, R. 1980: ‘A reconsideration of some fourth-century British mosaics’, Britannia 11, 289–301CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Teçusan, M. 1990: ‘Logos sympotikos: patterns of the irrational in philosophical drinking: Plato outside the symposium’, in Murray, O. (ed.), Sympotica. A Symposium on the Symposion, Oxford, 238–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thomas, C. 1981: Christianity in Roman Britain to AD 500, LondonGoogle Scholar
Toynbee, J.M.C. 1953: ‘Christianity in Roman Britain’, Journal of the British Archaeological Association 3rd ser. 16, 1–24Google Scholar
Toynbee, J.M.C. 1964a: Art in Britain under the Romans, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Toynbee, J.M.C. 1964b: ‘A new Roman pavement found in Dorset’, JRS 54, 7–14Google Scholar
Toynbee, J.M.C. 1968: ‘Pagan motifs and practices in Christian art and ritual in Roman Britain’, in Barley, M.W. and Hanson, R.P.C. (eds), Christianity in Britain, 300–700, Leicester, 177–92Google Scholar
Tybout, R.A. 2001: ‘Roman wall-painting and social significance’, Journal of Roman Archaeology 14, 33–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallace-Hadrill, A. 1988: ‘The social structure of the Roman house’, Papers British School at Rome 56, 43–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walters, B. 1982: ‘Fourth-century “Orphic” halls in Britain’, Mosaic 7, 23–6Google Scholar
Walters, B. 1984: ‘The Orpheus mosaic in Littlecote Park England’, Mosaico Ravenna, 433–42Google Scholar
Watts, D. 1991: Christians and Pagans in Roman Britain, London & New YorkGoogle Scholar
West, S. 1976: ‘The Romano-British site at Icklingham’, East Anglian Archaeology 3, 63–126Google Scholar
Weston, J.L. 1907: ‘The Grail and the rites of Adonis’, Folk-Lore 18 (reprinted in Mathews, J. (ed.), Sources of the Grail, Edinburgh, 1996, 431–48)Google Scholar
Wheeler, R.E.M., and Wheeler, T.V. 1936: Verulamium. A Belgie and Two Roman Cities, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
White, M.L. 2000: ‘Architecture: the first five centuries’, in Esler, P.F. (ed.), The Early Christian World, London & New York, 693–746Google Scholar
Williams, M.A. 1999: Rethinking Gnosticism, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
Witts, P. 1995: ‘Bacchus on Romano-British mosaics’, Mosaic 22, 15–19Google Scholar
Witts, P. 2000: ‘Mosaics and room function: the evidence from some fourth-century Romano-British villas’, Britannia 31, 291–324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Witts, P. 2001: ‘Universal messages: iconographie similarity between the mosaics of Antioch and Britain’, Mosaic 28, 13–17Google Scholar