Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T05:29:31.962Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

IV. The Norman Church and Door at Stillingfleet, North Yorkshire

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2011

P. V. Addyman  and
Ian H. Goodall
Get access

Abstract

The great age and unusual character of the south door of St. Helen's Church, Stillingfleet, now in North Yorkshire but formerly in the East Riding, has engaged the attention of antiquaries since the early days of archaeological study. The door and the fine twelfth-century doorway in which it is set have been recorded repeatedly in drawings, photographs, manuscript notes, and published accounts. The systematic account of the church published by Charles Hodgson Fowler in 1877, on the occasion of his restoration of St. Helen's, together with the plans and elevations preserved with the faculty papers, is the basic point of reference (Fowler, 1877; Borthwick Inst. PR 21 STIL). Nevertheless since Hodgson Fowler's day few scholars concerned either with the historic buildings of the locality, or with the general trends of vernacular art in the eleventh and twelfth centuries, or with church ironwork, or church carpentry, have resisted the temptation to comment on the door. Most agree within relatively narrow limits about the date of the doorway, but opinion has been diverse about the date of the door itself. It is a complex structure evidently comprising much original woodwork with additions and alterations from a number of restorations, and there is various structural and decorative ironwork. Hodgson Fowler seems to have been responsible for a sensitive though far-reaching restoration and he was thus probably in possession of more facts about its construction and character than was any later worker until recently. He seems to have been in no doubt, taking the evidence as a whole, that both doorway and door belong to the twelfth century. Most later commentators have been more impressed by the supposed Scandinavian character of the decorative metalwork, and W. G. Collingwood followed by Talbot Rice, Pevsner, and more recently Baggs have questioned the contemporaneity of door and doorway, suggesting that the door might perhaps belong to the eleventh century, and it is included in Wilson's catalogue of Anglo-Saxon metalwork.

Type
Research Article
Information
Archaeologia , Volume 106 , 1979 , pp. 75 - 105
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Andersson, A., 1970. The Art of Scandinavia. Stockholm.Google Scholar
Auden, G. A., 1907. ‘A Viking Ship on a Church Door’, Saga Book of the Viking Club, V, 247–50.Google Scholar
Ayrton, M., and Silcock, A., 1929. Wrought Iron and its Decorative Uses. London.Google Scholar
Benton, G. M., 1940. ‘An Early Post-Conquest Doorway and Door-frame at Elmstead Church’, Trans. Essex Arch. Soc., N.S. XXII, 126–30.Google Scholar
Biddle, M., and Quirk, R. N., 1962. ‘Excavations near Winchester Cathedral, 1961’, Arch. J., CXIX, 150–94.Google Scholar
Bordeaux, R., 1858. Serrurerie du Moyen-Age. Oxford and Paris.Google Scholar
Bowen, L., 1941. ‘The Tropology of Medieval Dedication Rites’, Speculum, XVI, 469–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruce-Mitford, R. L. S., 1972. The Sutton Hoo Ship Burial: a Handbook. 2nd edn. London.Google Scholar
Bruce-Mitford, R. L. S., 1974. Aspects of Anglo-Saxon Archaeology. London.Google Scholar
Bruce-Mitford, R. L. S., et al., 1975. The Sutton Hoo Ship Burial: vol. 1, Excavations, Background, the Ship, Dating and Inventory. London.Google Scholar
Buckland, T. J., 1979. ‘The reindeer antlers of the Abbot's Bromley horn dance’, Folk Music J. 3, No. 5.Google Scholar
Caley, J., 1821. Sir William Dugdale, Monasticon Anglicanum (eds. J., Caley, H., Ellis, and B., Bandinal), 6 vols. in 8, 1817–30; vol. III, 1821. London.Google Scholar
Carter, J., 1791. Ancient Sculpture, II.Google Scholar
Carver, M. O. H., 1973. Architectural Illustration in Anglo-Saxon Manuscripts. Unpublished M.A. dissertation, University of Durham.Google Scholar
Clapham, A. W., 1934. English Romanesque Architecture after the Conquest. Oxford.Google Scholar
Clay, C. T., 1939. Early Yorkshire Charters, VI, The Paynel Fee (ed. Clay, C. T.) (Yorks. Arch. Soc. Record Ser., Extra Ser. III). Leeds.Google Scholar
Clay, J. W., 1913. Extinct and Dormant Peerages of the Northern Counties of England. London.Google Scholar
Collingwood, W. G., 1911. ‘Anglian and Anglo-Danish Sculpture in the East Riding, with Addenda to the North Riding’, Yorks. Arch. J. XXI, 252–302.Google Scholar
Cotman, J., 1838. Architectural Remains, vol. II.Google Scholar
D'Allemagne, M. H. R., 1906. ‘Les Pentures de portes au Moyen Age’, Congrès Archéologiques de France, p. 73.Google Scholar
Dodwell, C. R., 1961. The Various Arts, by Theophilus. London.Google Scholar
Drake, F., 1736. Eburacum: or the History and Antiquities of the City of York. London.Google Scholar
Evans, A. C., and Fenwick, V., 1971. ‘The Graveney Boat’. Antiquity, XLV, 89–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Farrer, W., 1915. Early Yorkshire Charters, II. Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Farrer, W., 1916. Early Yorkshire Charters, III. EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Fenwick, V., 1973. ‘Graveney’ in B., Greenhill (ed.), Three Major Ancient Boat Finds in Britain, pp. 9–17. London.Google Scholar
Ffoulkes, C., 1913. Decorative Ironwork from the XIth to the XVIIIth Century. London.Google Scholar
Fletcher, J. M., and Hughes, J. F., 1970. ‘Uses of X-rays for Density Determinations and Dendrochronology’, University of British Columbia, Faculty of Forestry Bulletin, 7, 41–54.Google Scholar
Fowler, C. H., 1877. ‘Stillingfleet Church’, Association of Architectural Societies Reports and Papers, XIV, 73–9.Google Scholar
Gage, J., 1834. ‘The Anglo-Saxon Ceremonial of the Dedication and Consecration of Churches’, Archaeologia, XXV, 235–74.Google Scholar
Gardner, J. S., 1927. Ironwork. Part I. From the Earliest Times to the End of the Mediaeval Period; revised by Watts, W. W.. London.Google Scholar
Glynne, Sir Stephen, 1893. ‘Notes on Yorkshire Churches’, Yorks. Arch. J. XII, 433–63.Google Scholar
Greenhill, B., 1976. Archaeology of the Boat. London.Google Scholar
Hawkes, S. C., Davidson, H. R. E., and Hawkes, C., 1965. ‘The Finglesham Man’, Antiquity, XXXIX, 17–32.Google Scholar
Hewett, C. A., 1974a. English Cathedral Carpentry. London.Google Scholar
Hewett, C. A., 1974b. Church Carpentry: A Study Based on Essex Examples. London and Chichester.Google Scholar
Hewett, C. A., 1978. ‘Anglo-Saxon Carpentry’, Anglo-Saxon England, VII, 205–29.Google Scholar
Hollister-Short, G. J., 1969. ‘Symbolism in Medieval Wrought Ironwork’, The Connoisseur (October 1969), 91–7.Google Scholar
Hollister-Short, G. J., 1970. ‘Precursors of the Thirteenth-century Great Hinge’, The Connoisseur (February 1970), 108–12.Google Scholar
Johnston, P. M., 1923. ‘Stillingfleet’ in Revd. Ditchfield, P. H. (ed.), ‘Report of the Congress at York’, J.BA.A. 2nd ser., XXIX, 55–6.Google Scholar
Kinander, R., 1961. Sveriges Runinskrifter, Smalands Runinskrifter, I.Google Scholar
[Laughton, W. H.], 1975. The Parish Church of St. Helen. York (no date and author stated).Google Scholar
Lindqvist, S., 1941. Gotlands Bildsteine, I. Stockholm.Google Scholar
Lindsay, J. S., 1964. An Anatomy of English Wrought Iron, 1000–1800. London.Google Scholar
Lueer, H., 1904. Geschichte der Metallkunst. Munich.Google Scholar
Lundberg, E., 1927. ‘Järnbeslagna dörrar från Romansk tid i Östergötland’, Rig, X, 49–60.Google Scholar
Lundberg, E., 1929. ‘Järnbeslagna dörrar från Romansk tid i Östergötland. Nya Studien’, Rig, XII, 61–72.Google Scholar
Lundberg, E., 1940. Byggnadskonsten i Sverige under Medeltiden 1000—1400.Google Scholar
Mackeprang, M., 1943. ‘Fyenske jaernbundne kirkedore fra middelaldezen’, Aaboger for Nordisk Oldkyndighed og Historie, 1–30.Google Scholar
Markham, Sir Clements W., 1876–1896. A History of the Parish of Stillingfleet in the County of York. MS. written 1876, re-written 1896; in Stillingfleet parish chest.Google Scholar
Matfield, R. S., 1971. ‘Neutron Radiography’, Atom, Bulletin of United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority, 174, 1–16.Google Scholar
Morris, J. E., 1906. The East Riding of Yorkshire. London.Google Scholar
Nevinson, J. L., 1965. ‘The Costumes’ in Sir Frank, Stenton (ed.), The Bayeux Tapestry, pp. 70–5. London.Google Scholar
Noel-Hume, I., 1970. A Guide to Artifacts of Colonial America. New York.Google Scholar
Ould, E. A., 1875. ‘Norman Doorway, Stillingfleet, Yorkshire del. et lith. June 75’ in J. Douglas, Abbey Square Sketch Book, II, pl. 50.Google Scholar
Ould, E. A., 1880. ‘Norman Doorway at Stillingfleet, delt. 1874’, The British Architect, 14, July-December 1880, 259.Google Scholar
Pevsner, N., 1972. Yorkshire: York and the East Riding. London.Google Scholar
Polge, H., and Keller, R., 1969. ‘La Xylochronologie, perfectionncment logique de la dendrochronologie’, Ann. Sci. For. 26 (2), 225–56.Google Scholar
, R.C.H.M.Essex i, 1916. Royal Commission on Historical Monuments, Essex. Vol. I: North-West. London.Google Scholar
, R.C.H.M.Essex iii, 1922. Royal Commission on Historical Monuments, Essex. Vol. III: North-East. London.Google Scholar
, R.C.H.M.York iii, 1972. Royal Commission on Historical Monuments, The City of York. Vol. III: South West of the Ouse. London.Google Scholar
Rodwell, W., 1976. ‘The Archaeological Investigation of Hadstock Church, Essex: an Interim Report’, Antiq. J. LVI, 55–71.Google Scholar
Romdahl, A., 1914. ‘Rogslösadörren och en grupp romanska smiden i de gamla Götalandskapen’, Fornvannen, IX, 231–45.Google Scholar
Romeyn, I., 1913. The Register of John le Romeyn, Lord Archbishop of York, 1286–1296, Part I. Publications of the Surtees Soc., 123.Google Scholar
Romilly Allen, J., 1907. ‘A Viking Ship on a Norman Door at Stillingfleet, Yorkshire’, The Reliquary and Illustrated Archaeologist, New Ser. XII, 127–8.Google Scholar
Sheahan, J. J., and Whellan, T., 1856. History and topography of the City of York; The Ainsty Wapentake; and the East Riding of Yorkshire, vol. II. Beverley.Google Scholar
Stapleton, T., 1848. ‘Holy Trinity Priory, York’ in Memoirs illustrative of the History and Antiquities of the County and City of York, communicated to the Annual Meeting of the Archaeological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland held at York, July 1846. London.Google Scholar
Stenton, Sir Frank, 1965. The Bayeux Tapestry. 2nd edn. London.Google Scholar
Stone, L., 1955. Sculpture in Britain: the Middle Ages. London.Google Scholar
Swanton, M. J., 1974. ‘Finglesham Man: a Documentary Postscript’, Antiquity, XLVIII, 313–15.Google Scholar
Swanton, M. J., 1976. ‘“Dane-skins”: Excoriation in Early England’, Folklore, XXXVII, 21–8.Google Scholar
Talbot Rice, D., 1952. English Art, 871–1100. Oxford.Google Scholar
Thomson, Lady E., 1955. Clifton Lodge. London.Google Scholar
Treasury Magazine, 1908. The Treasury Magazine, X, 417.Google Scholar
, V.C.H. i, 1907. The Victoria History of the Counties of England, A History of Yorkshire, I (ed. Page, W.). London.Google Scholar
V.C.H. iii, 1976. The Victoria History of the Counties of England, A History of Yorkshire, East Riding, III. London.Google Scholar
White, W., 1840. History, Gazetteer, and Directory, of the East and North Ridings of Yorkshire. Sheffield.Google Scholar
Wilson, D. M., 1964. Anglo-Saxon Ornamental Metalwork 700–1100 in the British Museum—a Handlist. London.Google Scholar
Yates, E., 1939. ‘Notes on Medieval Church Ironwork’ J.B.A.A. 3rd ser. IV, 175–85.Google Scholar
Zarnecki, G., 1953. Later English Romanesque Sculpture 1140–1260. London.Google Scholar