Element contents
Can Blockchain Solve the Hold-up Problem in Contracts?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 October 2021
Summary
A vexing problem in contract law is modification. Two parties sign a contract but before they fully perform, they modify the contract. Should courts enforce the modified agreement? A private remedy is for the parties to write a contract that is robust to hold-up or that makes the facts relevant to modification verifiable. Provisions accomplishing these ends are renegotiation-design and revelation mechanisms. But implementing them requires commitment power. Conventional contract technologies to ensure commitment – liquidated damages – are disfavored by courts and themselves subject to renegotiation. Smart contracts written on blockchain ledgers offer a solution. We explain the basic economics and legal relevance of these technologies, and we argue that they can implement liquidated damages without courts. We address the hurdles courts may impose to use of smart contracts on blockchain and show that sophisticated parties' ex ante commitment to them may lead courts to allow their use as pre-commitment devices.
- Type
- Element
- Information
- Online ISBN: 9781009004794Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication: 18 November 2021
References
Aghion, Philippe, and Holden, Richard. (2011) “Incomplete Contracts and the Theory of the Firm: What Have We Learned over the Past 25 Years?,” Journal of Economic Perspectives 25: 181–197.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aghion, Philippe, Mathias Dewatripont and Patrick Rey. (1994) “Renegotiation Design with Unverifiable Information,” Econometrica 62: 257–282.Google Scholar
Aghion, Philippe, Drew Fudenberg, Richard Holden, Takashi Kunimoto and Olivier Tercieux (2012) “Subgame-Perfect Implementation under Information Perturbations,” Quarterly Journal of Economics 127: 1843–1881.Google Scholar
Aghion, Philippe, Ernst Fehr, Richard Holden, and Tom Wilkening (2017) “The Role of Bounded Rationality and Imperfect Information in Subgame Perfect Implementation – An Empirical Investigation,” Journal of the European Economic Association 16: 232–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alaska Packers’ Ass’n v. Domenico, 117 F. 99 (9th Cir. 1902).Google Scholar
Allison, Ian. (Apr. 30, 2016) “Ethereum Reinvents Companies with Launch of the DAO,” available at www.ibtimes.co.uk/ethereum-reinvents-companies-launch-dao-1557576.Google Scholar
Altcointoday.com. (Apr. 22, 2017) “Bitcoin and Ethereum vs Visa and PayPal – Transactions per Second,” available at www.altcointoday.com/bitcoin-ethereum-vs-visa-paypal-transactions-per-second/.Google Scholar
Althauser, Joshua. (Aug. 18, 2017) “Australian Government Moves to Regulate Cryptocurrency Exchanges,” Cointelegraph, available at https://cointelegraph.com/news/australian-government-moves-to-regulate-cryptocurrency-exchanges.Google Scholar
Angel v. Murray, 322 A.2d 630 (R. I. 1974).Google Scholar
Antonopolous, Andreas M. (2nd ed., 2017) Mastering Bitcoin: Programming the Open Blockchain, O’Reilly Media.Google Scholar
Antràs, Pol. (2003) “Firms, Contracts, and Trade Structure,” Quarterly Journal of Economics 118: 1375–1418.Google Scholar
Arruñada, Benito, and Garicano, Luis. (2018) “Blockchain: The Birth of Decentralized Governance” Working Paper, available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3160070 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3160070.Google Scholar
Aru, Ikye. (Apr. 18, 2017) “Blockchain Transaction Anonymity Is Necessary Evil,” Cointelegraph, available at https://cointelegraph.com/news/blockchain-transaction-anonymity-is-necessary-evil.Google Scholar
Baker, George P., and Hubbard, Thomas N.. (2004) “Contractibility and Asset Ownership: On-board Computers and Governance in U. S. Trucking,” Quarterly Journal of Economics 119: 1443–1479.Google Scholar
Baker, Scott, and Malani, Anup. (2014) “Trial Court Budgets, the Enforcer’s Dilemma, and the Rule of Law,” University of Illinois Law Review 2014: 1573–1602.Google Scholar
Bakos, Yannis, and Halaburda, Hanna. (May 26, 2019) “Smart Contracts, IoT Sensors and Efficiency: Automated Execution vs. Better Information” NYU Stern School of Business, available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3394546 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3394546.Google Scholar
Arati, Baliga. (Apr.2017) “Understanding Blockchain Consensus Models” White Paper, available at www.persistent.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/WP-Understanding-Blockchain-Consensus-Models.pdf?pdf=Understanding-Blockchain-Consensus-Models.Google Scholar
Gill, Bar, Oren, and Omri Ben Shahar. (2004) “The Law of Duress and the Economics of Credible Threats,” Journal of Legal Studies 33: 391–430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beatty v. Guggenheim Exploration Co., 122 N.E. 378, 387 (N.Y. 1919).Google Scholar
Bitcoin.org. (2021) “Bitcoin Developers Guide,” available at https://bitcoin.org/en/developer-guide#block-chain.Google Scholar
Bitinfocharts.com. (2021a) “Bitcoin, Ethereum Transactions Historical Chart,” available at https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-eth.html#3m.Google Scholar
Bitinfocharts.com. (2021b) “Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, Dogecoin Transactions Historical Chart,” available at https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-eth-ltc-doge.html.Google Scholar
Blockgeeks.com. (2021a) “What Is Blockchain Technology? A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners: An In-depth Guide by BlockGeeks,” available at https://blockgeeks.com/guides/what-is-blockchain-technology/.Google Scholar
Blockgeeks.com. (2021b) “A Beginner’s Guide to Smart Contracts,” available at https://blockgeeks.com/guides/smart-contracts/.Google Scholar
Budish, Eric. (2018) “The Economic Limits of Bitcoin and the Blockchain” Working Paper, available at http://dx.doi.org/10.3386/w24717.Google Scholar
Buterin, Vitalik. (2014) “A Next Generation Smart Contract & Decentralized Application Platform: Ethereum Whitepaper,” available at www.the-blockchain.com/docs/Ethereum_white_paper-a_next_generation_smart_contract_and_decentralized_application_platform-vitalik-buterin.pdf.Google Scholar
Buterin, Vitalik. (Dec. 30, 2016) “A Proof of Stake Design Philosophy,” Medium, available at https://medium.com/@VitalikButerin/a-proof-of-stake-design-philosophy-506585978d51.Google Scholar
Castor, Amy. (Mar. 14, 2017) “A (Short) Guide to Blockchain Consensus Protocols,” Coindesk, available at www.coindesk.com/short-guide-blockchain-consensus-protocols/.Google Scholar
Chirelstein, Marvin A. (3rd ed. 1998) Concepts and Case Analysis in the Law of Contracts, Foundation Press.Google Scholar
Christidis, Konstantinos, and Devetsikiotis, Michael. (2016) “Blockchains and Smart Contracts for the Internet of Things,” IEEE Access 4: 2292–2303.Google Scholar
Chung, Tai-Yeong. (1991) “Incomplete Contracts, Specific Investments, and Risk Sharing,” The Review of Economic Studies 58: 1031–1042.Google Scholar
Crook, Jordan. (Jul. 6, 2017) “This Apple Patent Application Could Describe Facial Recognition for the Next iPhone,” Techcrunch, available at https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/06/this-apple-patent-could-describe-facial-recognition-for-the-next-iphone/.Google Scholar
Crossman, Penny. (May 23, 2017) “Banks pour $107M into blockchain consortium R3, American Banker,” American Banker, available at www.americanbanker.com/news/banks-pour-107m-into-blockchain-consortium-r3.Google Scholar
Davis v. Payne & Day, Inc., 348 P.2d 337, 339 (Utah 1960).Google Scholar
Dawson, Suzanne S., Pence, Robert J. and Stone, David S. (1987) “Poison Pill Defensive Measures,” Business Lawyer 42: 423.Google Scholar
Gerrit, de Geest, and Wuyts, Filip. (2000) “Penalty Clauses” in Gerrit, de Geest (ed.), Encyclopedia of Law and Economics Vol. 3: The Regulation of Contracts, Edward Elgar, 141.Google Scholar
Domenico v. Alaska Packers’ Ass’n, 112 F. 554 (N. D. Cal. 1901).Google Scholar
Easterbrook, Frank H. (1987) “Comparative Advantage and Antitrust Law,” California Law Review 75: 983–990.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Easterbrook, Frank H. (1996) “Cyberspace and the Law of the Horse,” University of Chicago Legal Forum 1996: 207.Google Scholar
Gibbons, Robert. (1992) Game Theory for Applied Economists, Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Goldberg, Victor P. (1976) “Regulation and Administered Contracts,” Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 7: 426–448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Graham, Daniel A., and Pierce, Ellen R.. (1989) “Contract Modification: An Economic Analysis of the Hold-up Game,” Law and Contemporary Problems 52: 9–32.Google Scholar
Gruson, Michael. (1980) “Governing Law Clauses in Commercial Agreements – New York’s Approach,” Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 18: 323–379.Google Scholar
Guerriero, Carmine. (Aug. 29, 2020) “Property Rights, Transaction Costs, and the Limits of the Market” Quaderni – Working Paper DSE N°1110, available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3058095 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3058095.Google Scholar
Guerriero, Carmine, and Pignataro, Giuseppe. (Jan. 19, 2021) “Endogenous Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm” Working Paper, available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3547522 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3547522.Google Scholar
Hart, Oliver, and Moore, John. (1988) “Incomplete Contracts and Renegotiation,” Econometrica 56: 755–785.Google Scholar
Hart, Oliver, and Moore, John. (1990) “Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm,” Journal of Political Economy 98: 1119–1158.Google Scholar
Hart, Oliver, and Moore, John. (2008) “Contracts as Reference Points,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 123: 1–48.Google Scholar
Hartsville Oil Mill v. United States, 271 U.S. 43 (1926).Google Scholar
Holden, Richard, and Malani, Anup. (2014) “Renegotiation Design by Contract,” University of Chicago Law Review 81: 151–178.Google Scholar
Holmstrom, Bengt. (1982) “Moral Hazard in Teams,” Bell Journal of Economics 13: 324–340.Google Scholar
Iansiti, Marco, and Lakhani, Karim R.. (2017) “The Truth About Blockchain,” Harvard Business Review 95: 118–127.Google Scholar
IRS. (2021) “List of Approved KYC Rules,” available at www.irs.gov/businesses/international-businesses/list-of-approved-kyc-rules.Google Scholar
Jolls, Christine. (1997) “Contracts as Bilateral Commitments: A New Perspective on Contract Modification,” Journal of Legal Studies 26: 203–237.Google Scholar
Kharpal, Arjun. (Aug. 9, 2017) “Initial Coin Offerings Have Raised $1.2 Billion and Now Surpass Early Stage VC Funding,” CNBC, available at www.cnbc.com/2017/08/09/initial-coin-offerings-surpass-early-stage-venture-capital-funding.html.Google Scholar
Klein, Benjamin, Crawford, Robert G. and Alchian, Armen A. (1978) “Vertical Integration, Appropriable Rents, and the Competitive Contracting Process,” Journal of Law and Economics 21: 297–326.Google Scholar
Lee, Timothy B. (Sep. 15, 2017) “It Looks Like China Is Shutting Down Its Blockchain Economy,” Arstechnica, available at https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/09/china-may-be-getting-ready-to-ban-bitcoin/.Google Scholar
López-Bayón, Susana, and Manuel, González-Díaz. (2010) “Indefinite Contract Duration: Evidence from Electronics Subcontracting,” International Review of Law and Economics 30: 145–159.Google Scholar
Marino, Bill. (Dec. 2, 2015) “Smart Contracts: The Next Big Blockchain Application,” available at https://tech.cornell.edu/news/smart-contracts-the-next-big-blockchain-application.Google Scholar
Maskin, Eric. (1977) “Nash Equilibrium and Welfare Optimality” mimeo, ultimately published as Eric Maskin. (1999) “Nash Equilibrium and Welfare Optimality,” Review of Economic Studies 66: 23–38.Google Scholar
Matonis, Jon. (Jan. 28, 2013) “Government Ban on Bitcoin Would Fail Miserably,” Forbes, available at www.forbes.com/sites/jonmatonis/2013/01/28/government-ban-on-bitcoin-would-fail-miserably/#5d5e61c61d25.Google Scholar
Moore, John, and Repullo, Rafael. (1988) “Subgame Perfect Implementation,” Econometrica 56: 1191–1220.Google Scholar
Nakamoto, Satoshi. (2008) “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System” White Paper, available at www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/training/annual-national-training-seminar/2018/Emerging_Tech_Bitcoin_Crypto.pdf.Google Scholar
Noldeke, Georg, and Schmidt, Klaus M.. (1995) “Option Contracts and Renegotiation: A Solution to the Hold-up Problem,” RAND Journal of Economics 26: 163–179.Google Scholar
Polinsky, A. Mitchell, and Shavell, Steven. (1998) “Punitive Damages: An Economic Analysis,” Harvard Law Review 111: 869–962.Google Scholar
Posner, R. A. (1977). Gratuitous promises in economics and law. The Journal of Legal Studies, 6(2), 411–426.Google Scholar
PWC. (Jan. 2013) “Know Your Customer: Quick Reference Guide,” available at www.pwc.com/gx/en/financial-services/assets/pwc-kyc-anti-money-laundering-guide-2013.pdf.Google Scholar
Rogerson, William P. (1984) “Efficient Reliance and Damage Measures for Breach of Contract,” RAND Journal of Economics 15: 39–53.Google Scholar
Rose v. Daniels, 8 R.I. 381 (1866).Google Scholar
Saleh, Fahad. (2021) “Blockchain without Waste: Proof-of-Stake,” Review of Financial Studies 34 : 1156–1190.Google Scholar
Selten, Reinhard (1975) “Reexamination of the Perfectness Concept for Equilibrium Points in Extensive Games,” International Journal of Game Theory 4: 25–55.Google Scholar
Serafine, Mary Lou. (1991) “Note, Repudiated Compromise after Breach,” Yale Law Journal 100: 2229.Google Scholar
Shavell, Steven. (2007) “Contractual Hold-up and Legal Intervention,” Journal of Legal Studies 36: 325–354.Google Scholar
Siegfried, Nils, Rosenthal, Tobias and Alexander, Benlian. (Jan. 2020) “Blockchain and the Industrial Internet of Things,” Journal of Enterprise Information Management, available at https://doi.org/10.1108/JEIM-06-2018-0140.Google Scholar
Sistrom v. Anderson, 51 Cal. App. 2d 213, 124 P.2d 372 (1942).Google Scholar
Stark, Josh. (Jun. 4, 2016) “Making Sense of Blockchain Smart Contracts,” Coindesk, available at www.coindesk.com/making-sense-smart-contracts/.Google Scholar
Steinberg Press, Inc. v. Charles Henry Publications, Inc., 68 N.Y.S.2d 793 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1947).Google Scholar
Szabo, Nick. (2021) “Smart Contracts: Building Blocks for Digital Market, Entropy #16,” available at www.fon.hum.uva.nl/rob/Courses/InformationInSpeech/CDROM/Literature/LOTwinterschool2006/szabo.best.vwh.net/smart_contracts_2.html.Google Scholar
Threedy, Debora L. (2000) “A Fish Story: Alaska Packers’ Association v. Domenico,” Utah Law Review: 185.Google Scholar
Tidmarsh, Jay. (Mar. 19, 2015) “Out of Court, Out of Luck,” US News & World Report, available at www.usnews.com/opinion/economic-intelligence/2015/03/19/consumer-protection-bureau-arbitration-report-provides-much-needed-data.Google Scholar
Tinn, Katrin. (2017) “Blockchain and the Future of Optimal Financing Contracts” Working Paper, available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3061532 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3061532.Google Scholar
Torbert, Preston M. (2017) “A Study of the Risks of Contract Ambiguity,” PKU Transnational Law Review 2: 1–114.Google Scholar
US Department of State. (Mar. 7, 2012) “Major Money Laundering Countries,” available at www.state.gov/j/inl/rls/nrcrpt/2012/vol2/184112.htm.Google Scholar
Wikipedia. (2021a) “Satoshi Nakamoto,” available at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Nakamoto.Google Scholar
Wikipedia. (2021b) “Sandbox (Software Development),” available at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandbox_(software_development).Google Scholar
Williamson, Oliver. (1975) Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications, Free Press.Google Scholar
Williamson, Oliver E. (1979) “Transaction-Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations,” Journal of Law and Economics 22: 233–261.Google Scholar
Zheng, Zibin, Xie, Shaoan, Dai, Hongning, Chen, Xiangping and Wang, Huaimin. (2018) “Blockchain Challenges and Opportunities: A Survey,” International Journal of Web and Grid Services 14: 352–375.Google Scholar
Zumwinkel v. Leggett, 345 S.W.2d 89, 93–94 (Mo. 1961).Google Scholar