Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Editor's preface
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction
- Part I The semantic tradition
- 1 Kant, analysis, and pure intuition
- 2 Bolzano and the birth of semantics
- 3 Geometry, pure intuition, and the a priori
- 4 Frege's semantics and the a priori in arithmetic
- 5 Meaning and ontology
- 6 On denoting
- 7 Logic in transition
- 8 A logico-philosophical treatise
- Part II Vienna, 1925–1935
- Notes
- References
- Index
8 - A logico-philosophical treatise
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 March 2012
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Editor's preface
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction
- Part I The semantic tradition
- 1 Kant, analysis, and pure intuition
- 2 Bolzano and the birth of semantics
- 3 Geometry, pure intuition, and the a priori
- 4 Frege's semantics and the a priori in arithmetic
- 5 Meaning and ontology
- 6 On denoting
- 7 Logic in transition
- 8 A logico-philosophical treatise
- Part II Vienna, 1925–1935
- Notes
- References
- Index
Summary
Whenever I have met unbelievers before, or read their books, it always seemed to me that they were speaking and writing in their books about something quite different, although it seemed to be about that on the surface. … Listen, Parfyon. You asked me a question just now; here is my answer. The essence of religious feeling does not come under any sort of reasoning or atheism, and has nothing to do with any crimes or misdemeanors. There is something else here, and there will always be something else – something that the atheists will forever slur over; they will always be talking of something else. – Prince Myshkin.
Dostoevsky, The IdiotThe logic of mysticism shows, as is natural, the defects which are inherent in anything malicious. While the mystic mood is dominant, the need of logic is not felt; as the mood fades, the impulse to logic reasserts itself, but with a desire to retain the vanishing insight, or at least to prove that it was insight, and that what seems to contradict it is illusion.
Russell, Our Knowledge of the External WorldIt isn't easy to decide whether Wittgenstein should be included among the members of the semantic tradition or among its most ferocious enemies. On the surface, at any rate, Wittgenstein's problems and techniques were those of the semanticists; beneath the surface, however, things are less clear.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Semantic Tradition from Kant to CarnapTo the Vienna Station, pp. 141 - 168Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1991