Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- List of Tables
- List of Maps
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 The provincial era
- 2 The Ly dynasty
- 3 The Tran dynasty
- 4 The Le dynasty
- 5 The beginning of inter-regional warfare
- 6 The Fifty Years War
- 7 The south and the north diverge
- 8 The Thirty Years War
- 9 The Nguyen dynasty
- 10 The French conquest
- 11 Franco-Vietnamese colonial relations
- 12 Indochina at war
- 13 From two countries to one
- Retrospective
- Bibliographic essay
- Figures
- Tables
- Maps
- Index
Retrospective
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 May 2013
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Figures
- List of Tables
- List of Maps
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 The provincial era
- 2 The Ly dynasty
- 3 The Tran dynasty
- 4 The Le dynasty
- 5 The beginning of inter-regional warfare
- 6 The Fifty Years War
- 7 The south and the north diverge
- 8 The Thirty Years War
- 9 The Nguyen dynasty
- 10 The French conquest
- 11 Franco-Vietnamese colonial relations
- 12 Indochina at war
- 13 From two countries to one
- Retrospective
- Bibliographic essay
- Figures
- Tables
- Maps
- Index
Summary
Considering the events discussed in this book, no conclusion can be drawn in the sense of discovering some deep logic governing a presumed destiny of the Vietnamese people. Knowledge of the Vietnamese past in the English language accumulated in the late twentieth century in the shadow of war; academics, journalists, and politicians accorded the chief privilege of shaping that accumulation to the group of Vietnamese fortunate enough to have allies that remained relatively steadfast until the last battle. What accumulated came from wartime propaganda based on a stridently nationalistic version of Vietnamese history that featured, first, an affirmation of Vietnamese identity pre-dating contact with the ancient Chinese and, second, dominant themes of rebellion against colonial oppression and resistance to foreign aggression; neither of these ideas can be sustained by a study of existing evidence about the past.
More appropriate than a conclusion is a retrospective in the sense of a reappraisal that keeps close to surviving materials from the past and that aims to see the Vietnamese and their ancestors through their own eyes in various times and places. To some extent, what we see is “just one random thing after another”; but this in itself is important because it alerts us to the fallacy of putting faith in a rigid overarching narrative of “the Vietnamese people” or “the Vietnamese nation.” There is no discernible pattern to explain how times of prosperity and well being alternated with times of misery and violence. As this book demonstrates, the Vietnamese past is, among other things, a great swath of failed experiments in social organization and governance.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- A History of the Vietnamese , pp. 620 - 626Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2013