Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T23:16:39.209Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Genuine fakes: Cloning extinct species as science and spectacle

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2016

Amy Fletcher
Amy Fletcher*
Affiliation:
Political Science Programme, University of Canterbury, Christchurch 8140, New Zealand [email protected]
Get access

Abstract

This case study of the Australian Museum's Thylacine Cloning Project analyzes a frame dispute that emerged during public communication of a scientific project, which lasted from 1999 to 2005, and was premised on the idea of resurrecting an extinct species. In choosing the Tasmanian tiger—an iconic Australian marsupial officially declared extinct in 1986—the promoters of the cloning project ensured extensive media coverage. However, the popular and scientific attention generated by the idea of bringing back an extinct species challenged the Museum's efforts to frame the project in terms of scientific progress. The project repeatedly shifted from science to spectacle, as multiple stakeholders used the mass media to negotiate the scientific feasibility of trying to reverse extinction through the application of advanced biotechnology. The case study findings are relevant both to the emerging social issues surrounding the use of paleogenomics in wildlife conservation, and to the theoretical development of frame analysis as applied to scientific controversies.

Keywords

Ancient DNAconservation geneticsextinctionframe analysispaleogenomicsThylacine Cloning ProjectTasmanian tiger
Type
Research Articles
Information
Politics and the Life Sciences , Volume 29 , Issue 1 , March 2010 , pp. 48 - 60
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1.Ben-Aaron, Diana, “Retrobreeding the woolly mammoth,” Technology Review 1984, 87:85.Google Scholar
2.Mattili, John I., “Our shaggy elephant,” Technology Review 1984, 87:4. See also, Salsberg, Corey A., “Resurrecting the woolly mammoth: Science, law, ethics, politics and religion,” Stanford Technology Law Review, 2000, 1:1–30.Google Scholar
3.Higuchi, R., Bowman, B., Freiberger, M., Ryder, O.A., and Wilson, A.C., “DNA sequences from the quagga, an extinct member of the horse family,” Nature 1984, 312 (5991):282–284.Google Scholar
4.Pääbo, Svante, “Uber den Nachweis von DNA in altagyptischen Mumien,” Das Altertum 1984, 30: 213–218. See also, Pääbo, Svante, “Preservation of ancient DNA in Egyptian mummies,” Journal of Archaeological Science, 1985, 12:411–417.Google Scholar
5.Audio, Stéphane and Béraud-Colomb, Eliane, “Ancient DNA is thirteen years old,” Nature Biotechnology 1997, 15:855–858.Google Scholar
6.The text of the Convention on Biological Diversity entered into force on December 29 1993, http://www.cbd.int/.Google Scholar
7.For more information on the films, see IGN Entertainment, “Top 25 Movie Franchises of All Time,” November 30, 2006, http://au.movies.ign.com/articles/748/748325p1.htmlGoogle Scholar
8.Wynne, Brian, “Elephants in the room where publics encounter ‘science’: A response to Darrin Durant,” Public Understanding of Science 2008, 17:21–33.Google Scholar
9.Petersen, Alan, “Biofantasies: Genetics and medicine in the print news media,” Social Science & Medicine 2001, 52:1255–1268.Google Scholar
10.Petersen, , p. 1258.Google Scholar
11.Fletcher, Amy Lynn, “Clearing the air: The contribution of frame analysis to understanding climate policy in the United States,” Environmental Politics 2009, 18 (5):800–816.Google Scholar
12.Phillips, Nelson and Hardy, Cynthia, Discourse Analysis: Investigating the Processes of Social Construction (London: Sage Publications, 2002).Google Scholar
13.Hagendijk, Rob and Meeus, Jan, “Blind faith: Fact, fiction, and fraud in a public controversy over science,” Public Understanding of Science 1993, 2:391–415.Google Scholar
14.Nisbet, Matthew, “Framing science: A new paradigm in public engagement,” in Communicating Science: New Agendas in Communication, Kahlor, LeeAnn and Stout, Patricia A., eds. (New York and London: Routledge, 2009), pp. 40–67.Google Scholar
15.Nisbet, , p. 46.Google Scholar
16.McBeth, Mark, Shanahan, Elizabeth A., and Jones, Michael D., “The science of storytelling: Measuring policy beliefs in Greater Yellowstone,” Society and Natural Resources 2005, 18 (5): 413–429.Google Scholar
17.Pääbo, Svante, Poinar, Hendrik, Serre, David, Jaenicke-Després, Viviane, Hebler, Juliane, Rohland, Nadin, Kuch, Melanie, Krause, Johannes, Vigilant, Linda, and Hofreiter, Michael, “Genetic analysis from ancient DNA,” Annual Review of Genetics 2004, 38:345–379.Google Scholar
18.Pääbo, et al., p. 346.Google Scholar
19.Thomas, M.Gilbert, P., Bandelt, Hans-Jürgen, Hofreiter, Michael and Barnes, Ian, “Assessing ancient DNA studies,” Trends in Ecology and Evolution 2005, 20(10):541–544.Google Scholar
20.Hofkin, Bruce V., Wright, April, Altenbach, Jennifer, Rassman, Kornelia, Snell, Heidi M., Miller, Robert D., Stone, Anne C., and Snell, Howard L., “Ancient DNA gives green light to Galapagos land iguana repatriation,” Conservation Genetics 2003, 4(1):105–108.Google Scholar
21.Bunce, Michael, Szulkin, Marta, Lerner, Heather R. L., Barnes, Ian, Shapiro, Beth, Cooper, Alan, and Holdaway, Richard N., “Ancient DNA provides new insights into the evolutionary history of New Zealand's extinct giant eagle,” PloS Biology June 2005, 3(1):0044–0046.Google Scholar
22.Melville, Jane, “Disappearing dragons,” Australian Academy of Science Newsletter April/July 2005, 62:5, http://www.science.org.au/publications/newsletters/Documents/aas62.pdfGoogle Scholar
23.Rosenbaum, H.C., Brownell, R. L. Jr., Brown, M. W., Schaeff, C., Portway, V., White, B.N., Malik, S., Pastene, L.A., Patenaude, N.J., Baker, C.S., Goto, M., Best, P.B., Clapham, P.J., Hamilton, P., Moore, M., Payne, R., Rowntree, V., Tynan, C.T., Bannister, J.L., and DeSalle, R.D., “Worldwide genetic differentiation of Eubalaena: Questioning the number of right whale species,” Molecular Ecology 2000, 9:1793–1802.Google Scholar
24.Pääbo, et al.Google Scholar
25.Wayne, Robert K., Leonard, Jennifer A., and Cooper, Alan, “Full of sound and fury: The recent history of ancient DNA,” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 1999, 30:458.Google Scholar
26.Meyer, Anna, Hunting the Double Helix: How DNA is Solving Puzzles of the Past (New York: Allen & Unwin, 2005).Google Scholar
27.Parks and Wildlife Service Tasmania, Threatened Species: Thylacine—Tasmanian Tiger (Hobart: Department of Tourism, Parks, Heritage and the Arts, 2003), http://www.parks.tas.gov.au/index.aspx?base=4765Google Scholar
28.Smith, Nicholas, “The howl and pussy: Feral cats and wild dogs in the Australian imagination,” The Australian Journal of Anthropology 1999, 10(3):298–305.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
29.Victoria, Museum, Information Sheet No. 10283: Thylacine (Thylacinus cynocephalus) (Melbourne: Museum Victoria, 2005), http://pandora.nla.gov.au/pan/67322/20070129-0000/www.museum.vic.gov.au/infosheets/10283.pdfGoogle Scholar
30.Guiler, Eric, The Tasmanian Tiger (Hobart: St. David's Park Publishing, 1991).Google Scholar
31.Tasmanian Fauna Board, “Memorandum from the Chairman of the Fauna Board to the Attorney General, Tasmania,” June 25, 1936, Photocopy. Accessed at the State Archives of Tasmania, Hobart, July 2007.Google Scholar
32.Paddle, Robert, The Last Tasmanian Tiger: The History and Extinction of the Thylacine (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000).Google Scholar
33.Australian Museum Online, “Attempting to make a genomic library of an extinct animal,” 2002, http://www.austmus.gov.au/thylacine/summary.htmGoogle Scholar
34.BBC Online, “Tasmanian tiger may growl again,” May 14, 1999, http://news.bbc.co.Uk/2/hi/science/nature/343702.stmGoogle Scholar
35.Australian Museum Online.Google Scholar
36.Wynne, , p. 24.Google Scholar
37.Nisbet, , p. 46.Google Scholar
38.Barbeliuk, Anne, “Ethical issues may halt tiger cloning,” The Mercury September 21, 1999.Google Scholar
39.Mooney, Nick, “Resurrecting the Tassie tiger sounds exotic but let's first save what's left,” Sydney Morning Herald May 31, 2002, http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/05/30/1022569815123.htmlGoogle Scholar
40.Sydney Morning Herald, “Extinct for the time being,” November 24, 2001, http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/09/25/1032734208957.htmlGoogle Scholar
41.Hopkins, Andrea, “Rebirth of the Tasmanian tiger attempted,” The Globe and Mail August 29, 2000.Google Scholar
42.Australian Museum Online.Google Scholar
43.Greer, Allen, “Cloning the thylacine: Not quite a showpiece of Australian science,” Quadrant July-August 2009:28–39.Google Scholar
44.Kezwer, Gil, “Australian scientist proposes recipe for cloning extinct tiger,” Canadian Medical Association Journal September 1999, 161(6):680.Google Scholar
45.Rovira, Sergi Cortinas, “Metaphors of DNA: A review of the popularisation processes,” Public Understanding of Science 2008, 7(1): 1–7. Rovira refers the reader to Pierre Fayard, “Divulgacion y pensamiento estrategico,” Arbor, 1991, 551/552:27–36.Google Scholar
46.Australian Museum, Annual Report 1998/1999, p. 5, http://australianmuseum.net.au/Uploads/Documents/1532/1998_1999_full_report.pdfGoogle Scholar
47.Australian Museum, Annual Report 1999/2000, pp. 4–5, http://australianmuseum.net.au/document/19992000-Annual-Report/.Google Scholar
48.Australian Museum, Annual Report 2001/2002, p. 5, http://australianmuseum.net.au/document/20012002-Annual-Report/.Google Scholar
49.Australian Musuem, 2001/2002, p. 5. Ibid.Google Scholar
50.Maegraith, Donna, “Tassie tiger still dead as a dodo despite Discovery's mega roar,” The Australian June 6, 2002.Google Scholar
51.SeeThomas, R.H., Schaffner, W., Wilson, A.C. and Pääbo, S., “DNA phylogeny of the extinct marsupial wolf,” Nature 1989, 340:465–467.Google Scholar
52.Taggert, Stewart, “Will Tasmanian tiger clone work?” Wired.com June 10, 2002, http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2002/06/52959Google Scholar
53.Greer, , p. 35.Google Scholar
54.Head, Lesley, “Tasmanian tiger: RIP,” Sydney Morning Herald May 15, 2000, http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/09/25/103273420957.htmlGoogle Scholar
55.Sydney Morning Herald, 2001.Google Scholar
56.Cooke, Robert, “Twas a spoof of mammoth proportions,” Boston Globe July 18, 1984, p.1.Google Scholar
57.Email correspondence with author, September 2004.Google Scholar
58.Archer, Mike, “Not dead, just stuffed,” The Bulletin March 23, 2005, 123(13).Google Scholar
59.Birnbaum, Daniel, Coulier, François, Pebusque, Marie-Josèphe, and Pontarotti, Pierre, “Paleogenomics: Looking into the past to the future,” Journal of Experimental Zoology, 288: 21–22.Google Scholar
60.Sydney Morning Herald, 2002.Google Scholar
61.Nicholls, Henry, “Ancient DNA comes of age,” PLoS Biology, 3(2):0192–0196, http://http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC548952/.Google Scholar
62.Williams, Robyn, Radio National Interview with Professor Alan Cooper and Professor Mike Archer, November 17, 2001, http://www.abc.net.au/rn/science/ss/stories/s421160.htmGoogle Scholar
63.Barbeliuk, Anne, “Thylacine cloning hit as mission impossible,” The Mercury September 10, 1999.Google Scholar
64.Saunders, Richard and Saunders, Geoff, “A man for all ages,” The Skeptic, Autumn 2003: 14–17.Google Scholar
65.Squires, Nick, “Scientists lobby for reserve for future Tasmanian tiger clone,” The South China Morning Post March 26, 2004.Google Scholar
66.Grace, Robyn, “U.S. researchers on board to clone thylacine,” AAP General News (Australia), October 12, 2005.Google Scholar
67.Keen, Paul, “The ‘balloonomania’: Science and spectacle in 1780s England,” Eighteenth-Century Studies, 39(2):507–535.Google Scholar
68.SeeGoldman, Steve, “The great balloon hoax,” Not dated. Accessed May 25, 2010, http://www.historybuff.com/library/refballoon.htmlGoogle Scholar
69.Wynne, , p. 21.Google Scholar
70.Sydney Morning Herald, 2001.Google Scholar
71.ABC Online, “The extinction of extinction,” March 22, 2005.Google Scholar
72.ABC News, “Tasmanian tiger DNA comes alive in a mouse,” May 20, 2008, http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/05/20/2249778.htm?section=justinGoogle Scholar
73.Folch, J., Cocero, M.J., Chesné, P., Alabart, J.L., Dominguez, V., Cognié, Y., Roche, A., Fernández-Árias, A., Marti, J.I., Sanchez, P., Echegoyen, E., Beckers, J.F., Sanchez Bonastre, A., and Vignon, X., “First birth of an animal from an extinct subspecies (Capra pyrenaica pyrenaica) by cloning,” Therigenology 2009, 71(6):1026–1034.Google Scholar
74.Shanks, Pete, “Two more ‘Lazarus’ projects,” Biopolitical Times February 3, 2010, http://www.biopoliticaltimes.org/article.php?id=5057Google Scholar