Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T09:52:06.008Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Unbuilt Hertford: T. G. Jackson's Contextual Dilemmas

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 April 2016

William Whyte
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In 1984 Hertford celebrated seven hundred years as an Oxford College. Such a monumental event deserved commemoration, and was marked despite the fact that Hertford was actually founded in 1874. This celebration was not the product of deceit or ignorance — merely creative accountancy. Although nominally a Victorian foundation, the college can claim an admittedly erratic descent from the original Hart Hall, which dates from around 1284. Over the years, it was associated with other academic halls; absorbed by Exeter College; refounded — briefly — as Hertford College; replaced by Magdalen Hall; and then, in 1874, it took the form we know today. This confusion of origins is reflected in the college's fabric. As Hertford's first historian put it, ‘Since its establishment the history of the College has been written largely in its buildings.' Above all, this means T. G. Jackson's work: his ‘Bridge of Sighs', his staircase — the ‘bastard child of Blois’ as Pevsner puts it, his chapel, hall, and accommodation blocks. All share a common free classicism. But, as a series of neglected, ignored, and previously undiscovered drawings reveal, this classicism was not set in stone from the start. There were near-Gothic alternatives too. This variant Hertford was not included in Sir Howard Colvin's Unbuilt Oxford, and it deserves further research. It gives an insight into T. G. Jackson's ways of working. It offers a vision of a wholly different Hertford. Above all, it reveals a truly Victorian dilemma: the. response of historicists to their historical context; the search for an appropriate style.

Type
Research Article
Information
Architectural History , Volume 45 , 2002 , pp. 347 - 362
Copyright
Copyright © Society of Architectural Historians of Great Britain 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Goudie, Andrew (ed.), Seven Hundred Years of an Oxford College (Oxford, 1984).Google Scholar

2 Oxford, University Archives, HC 1/2/3 Hebdomadal Council Minutes 1879–96, pp. 92, 94.

3 Saul, Nigel, ‘Hart Hall — the Early Centuries', Hertford College Magazine, 65 (1979), p. 10.Google Scholar

4 McConica, James, “The Rise of the Undergraduate College', in The History of the University of Oxford, III, ed. McConica, J. (Oxford, 1986), pp. 1–68 (p. 54).Google Scholar

5 Dunbabin, J. P. D., ‘College Estates and Wealth, 1660-1815', in History of the University of Oxford, v, ed. Sutherland, L. S. and Mitchell, L. G. (Oxford, 1986), pp. 269–307 (p. 298).Google Scholar

6 Mallet, C. E., History of the University of Oxford, 3 vols (London, 1927), III, pp. 423–26.Google Scholar

7 Hamilton, S. G., Hertford College (London, 1903), pp. 146–47.Google Scholar

8 Sherwood, Jennifer and Pevsner, Nikolaus, The Buildings of England: Oxfordshire (London, 1974), pp. 138–41.Google Scholar

9 Only one of these designs has ever been referred to before. See Bettley, James, The Oxford Buildings of Sir Thomas Jackson, catalogue of an exhibition at the Examination Schools, Oxford (1983), p. 16 Google Scholar. The variant Bridge of Sighs has remained apparently undisturbed in the College archives since 1897.

10 For T. G. Jackson's other unexecuted work, see Colvin, Howard, Unbuilt Oxford (New Haven and London, 1983)Google Scholar, ch. 9.

11 Mordaunt Crook, J., Dilemma of Style (London, 1989)Google Scholar, especially ch. 6.

12 An exception is Mordaunt Crook, J., ‘T. G. Jackson and the Cult of Eclecticism', in In Search of Modern Architecture, ed. Searing, H. (New York, 1982), pp. 102–20.Google Scholar

13 Oxford Journal, 13 October 1900, p. 5.Google Scholar

14 Oxford Magazine, 43 (1924–25), p. 126.Google Scholar

15 On Hertford, see Howell, Peter, ‘Oxford Architecture, 1800–1914', in The History of the University of Oxford, VII, ed. Brock, M. G. and Curthoys, M. C. (Oxford, 2000), pp. 729–80 (p. 753).Google Scholar

16 See William Whyte, T. G. Jackson and the Rhetoric of Education (Oxford University, M.St. Thesis, 1997), pp. 9–17 Google Scholar. Both Bettley, James, ‘T. G. Jackson and the Examination Schools', Oxford Art Journal, 6:1 (1983), pp. 57–66 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Wilcock, Roland, The Building of Oxford University Examination Schools (Oxford, 1983)Google Scholar are also useful, if occasionally unclear.

17 Oxford, Trinity College Archives, I/C/3 Jackson Building: plans and elevations; I/C/4 President's Lodgings: plans and elevation; Building News, 1 July 1887.

18 Oxford, Brasenose College Archives, B.14.2 Working Drawings of the New Buildings; Allfrey, E. W., ‘The Architectural History of the Buildings', Brasenose Quartercentenary Monographs, III (1909)Google Scholar.

19 Architectural Review, 1 (1896–97), p. 146 Google Scholar; Architecture, 2 (1897), p. 85.Google Scholar

20 The Builder, 46 (1884), p. 784 Google Scholar, and 59 (1890), p. 109.

21 Green, V. H. H., The Commonwealth of Lincoln College (Oxford, 1979), pp. 524, 555.Google Scholar

22 Vickery, Margaret Birney, Buildings for Blustockings (London, 1999), pp. 92–94.Google Scholar

23 Oxford, Merton College Archives, 1.5a College Register 1877-1914 and College Letter Book from 1883 to 1902.

24 Jackson, T. G., Recollections, ed. Jackson, Basil H. (Oxford, 1950), p. 185.Google Scholar

25 Oxford Journal, 11 October 1873, p. 6 Google Scholar; 13 October 1906, p. 5; 12 October 1907, p. 6.

26 Oxford Magazine, 15 (1896–97), p. 57.Google Scholar

27 Oxford, Hertford College Archives, Bound Volume of Plans and Elevations, 1888–1913.

28 Bettley, , The Oxford Buildings of Sir Thomas Jackson, p. 15.Google Scholar

29 Oxford, Bodleian Library, GA Oxon a 53, Topographical Prints — Hertford, 41.

30 Hamilton, S. G., ‘Dr Newton and Hertford College', Oxford Historical Society, 32 (1896), pp. 284–85.Google Scholar

31 Not by his son, Edward William Garbett, as most modern authorities suggest. Colvin, Howard, Biographical Dictionary of British Architects, 3rd edn (New Haven and London, 1995), p. 391.Google Scholar

32 Hamilton, , Hertford, p. 132.Google Scholar

33 Carlos, E. I. (ed.), Oxonia Antiqua Restaurata, 2nd edn (London, 1843), p. 60.Google Scholar

34 Sherwood, and Pevsner, , Oxfordshire, pp. 138–41Google Scholar; Saul, , ‘Hart Hall', p. 10.Google Scholar

35 Downes, Kerry, Hawksmoor, 2nd edn (London, 1979), pp. 138–47.Google Scholar

36 Ziegler, Philip, The Sixth Great Power: Barings 1762–1929 (London, 1988), p. 192.Google Scholar

37 For which, Brock, M. G., ‘A “Plastic Structure'”, in History of the University of Oxford, VII, ed. Brock, and Curthoys, , pp. 3–60.Google Scholar

38 Lawes, A. H., A Catalogue of the Archives of Hertford College, Oxford (London, 1985), p. 7 Google Scholar.

39 Hamilton, Hertford.

40 Goudie, , Oxford College, pp. 46–47 Google Scholar.

41 The Times, 6 March 1922, p. 14.

42 Hertford College Magazine, 11 (1922), pp. 3–4.Google Scholar

43 Jackson, T. G., Modern Gothic Architecture (London, 1873), pp. 112–13.Google Scholar

44 Allfrey, E. W., ‘The Architectural History of the Buildings', Brasenose Quartercentenary Monographs, 3 (Oxford, 1909), pp. 56–62.Google Scholar

45 Colvin, , Unbuilt Oxford, pp. 148–51.Google Scholar

46 Bettley, , ‘Jackson and the Examination Schools', pp. 57–66.Google Scholar

47 Vickery, , Buildings for Bluestockings, pp. 92–94.Google Scholar

48 Electrical Laboratory: The Builder , 96 (1909), pp. 556–57.Google Scholar

49 As Pevsner notes, and approves: Sherwood, and Pevsner, , Oxfordshire, p. 139.Google Scholar

50 Jackson, T. G., Reason in Architecture (London, 1906), pp. 1, 14 Google Scholar; Architecture (London, 1924), pp. 247–69.Google Scholar

51 Hertford College Magazine, 1 (1910), p. 6.Google Scholar

52 Oxford Times, 22 February 1913, p. 11.Google Scholar

53 The Builder, 76 (1899), p. 200.Google Scholar

54 London, Drapers’ Hall, MB59 Assistants’ Minutes 1893–98, pp. 352, 368,400,411–12.

55 I must thank Mr Richard Norton for lending me transcripts of letters relating to their excursion of 1902. See also, Norton, Richard, ‘Henry Boyd and Thomas Graham Jackson: their rowing exploits', Hertford College Magazine, 82 (1995–97), pp. 106–11.Google Scholar

56 Oxford Times, 22 February 1913, p. 9.Google Scholar

57 The Times, 6 March 1922, p. 14.Google Scholar

58 The Builder, 121 (1921), p. 35.Google Scholar

59 The standard account of this is Colvin, H. M., ‘Architecture', in History of the University of Oxford, v, ed. Sutherland, and Mitchell, , pp. 831–56.Google Scholar

60 Macleane, Douglas, Pembroke College (1900; London, 1998), pp. 228–29.Google Scholar

61 Howell, , ‘Oxford Architecture, 1800-1914', p. 731.Google Scholar

62 Watkin, David, Life and Work of C. R. Cockerell R.A. (London, 1974), pp. 197–206.Google Scholar

63 Acland, H. W., The Oxford Museum (London, 1859), p. 28.Google Scholar

64 Atlay, J. B., Sir Henry Wentworth Acland: a memoir (London, 1903), p. 207.Google Scholar

65 Greening Lamborn, E. A., The Story of Architecture in Oxford Stone (Oxford, 1912), p. 82.Google Scholar

66 Oxford Journal, 14 October 1871, p. 6.Google Scholar

67 Smith, Goldwin, in Evelyn Abbott and Lewis Campbell, The Life and Letters of Benjamin Jawett, 2 vols (London, 1897), I, p. 177.Google Scholar

68 Whyte, William, ‘“Rooms for the Torture and Shame of Scholars“: the new examination schools and the architecture of reform', Oxoniensia Google Scholar (forthcoming).

69 Jackson, , Modern Gothic Architecture, p. 56 Google Scholar; see also Whyte, , ‘Jackson', pp. 13–16.Google Scholar

70 Smith, Goldwin, ‘Oxford Old and New', Oxford Magazine, 4 (1886), p. 229.Google Scholar

71 Freeman, E. A., ‘Architecture in Oxford', The Architect, 38, p. 363.Google Scholar

72 Arnold, Matthew, Essays in Criticism (London and Cambridge, 1865), p. xviii.Google Scholar

73 Oxford Journal, 13 October 1888, p. 6.Google Scholar

74 Oxford Magazine, 6 (1887–88), p. 2.Google Scholar

75 Alden's Oxford Guide (1889), p. 21.Google Scholar

76 Jackson, , Recollections, p. 56.Google Scholar

77 Oxford, University Archives, ST 26 (Sheldonian Theatre), 1890–1917.

78 Cambridge University Reporter, 30 (1898–99), pp. 591–92Google Scholar; Cambridge, University Archives, University Register 46.1, Senate House (1900–23), pp. 50, 55–558.

79 Jackson, , Recollections, p. 121.Google Scholar

80 Jackson, , Architecture, p. 295.Google Scholar

81 Alden's Oxford Guide (1888), p. 21.Google Scholar

82 The Builder, 84 (1903), p. 541.Google Scholar

83 Alden's Oxford Guide (1909), p. 23.Google Scholar

84 Sherwood, and Pevsner, , Oxfordshire, p. 141.Google Scholar

85 Hertford College Magazine, 1 (1910), p. 6.Google Scholar

86 Oxford, Hertford College Archives, 4/1/1 Governing Body Minutes, p. 255 (17 March 1899).

87 Oxford, Bodleian Library G.A. Oxon a 53, Topographical Prints — Hertford, 51.

88 Hertford College Magazine, 8 (1914)Google Scholar, frontispiece.

89 Building News, 111 (1916), p. 358.Google Scholar

90 Hertford College Magazine, 15 (1926), p. 1.Google Scholar

91 The Builder, 84 (1903), p. 541.Google Scholar

92 Crook, , ‘Cult of Eclecticism', pp. 105–06.Google Scholar

93 Cambridge Review, 35 (1913–14), p. 450.Google Scholar

94 Cambridge Review, 34 (1912–13), p. 558.Google Scholar

95 The Times, 26 February 1913, p. 6.Google Scholar

96 Oxford Magazine, 17 (1899–1900), p. 379.Google Scholar

97 Saul, Nigel, ‘A bridge between town and gown', in Goudie, , Seven Hundred Years, pp. 53–56.Google Scholar

98 Oxford Magazine, 31 (1912–13), p. 264.Google Scholar

99 Uncatalogued drawing in Hertford College Archives. Signed, and dated May 189-.

100 Magazine of Art, 8 (1889), pp. 332–40.Google Scholar

101 Oxford Journal, 13 October 1888, p. 6.Google ScholarPubMed

102 Crook, , Dilemma of Style, p. 152.Google Scholar

103 Oxford Magazine, 8 (1889–90), p. 52.Google Scholar

104 The Builder, 84 (1903), p. 541.Google Scholar

105 Oxford Times, 22 February 1913, p. 11.Google ScholarPubMed

106 Hertford College Magazine, 9 (1914), p. 45.Google Scholar

107 RIBA Journal, 3rd series, XIX (1912), p. 280.Google Scholar

108 Hertford College Magazine, 11 (1922), p. 3.Google Scholar

109 The Times, 6 March 1922, p. 14.Google ScholarPubMed

110 Tyack, Geoffry, Oxford: an architectural guide (Oxford, 1998), pp. 274–76.Google Scholar

111 Stedman, Algernon M. M., Oxford: its social and intellectual life (London, 1878), p. 29.Google Scholar

112 Journal of the RIBA, 3rd series, XIX (1912), p. 291.Google Scholar

113 Fletcher, C. R. L., A Handy Guide to Oxford, rev. edn (London, 1926), p. 78.Google Scholar

114 Building News, 111 (1916), p. 344 Google Scholar; for the original design, see Oxford, Hertford College Archives, Bound Volume of Plans, 29 July 1911.

115 Hertford College Magazine, 19 (1930), pp. 1–2.Google Scholar

116 Sherwood, and Pevsner, , Oxfordshire, p. 141.Google Scholar

117 For an attack on Jackson's Hertford work, see Kersting, Anthony F. and Ashdown, John, The Buildings of Oxford (London, 1980), p. 106.Google Scholar

118 This was perceived as a real need. See Rashdall, Hastings, ‘Hertford College', in Mark, Andrew, The Colleges of Oxford (London, 1891), p. 459.Google Scholar

119 Hertford College Magazine, 11 (1922), p. 3.Google Scholar