Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-29T02:54:12.381Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Laudianism’ in Scotland? St Giles’ Cathedral, Edinburgh, 1633–39 — A Reappraisal

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 April 2016

Andrew Spicer
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The liturgical and sacramental policies of the 1630s had a direct impact upon the architecture and furnishings of English cathedrals and parish churches. Archbishop Laud, in particular, was associated with the restoration of altars, which meant the rearrangement of church interiors and the removal of pews so that communion tables could be erected at the east end of the church. There was also a concerted effort to take down seating galleries and, externally, to remove buildings and shops which encroached upon the churchyard or abutted the church. The impact of these religious policies on the architecture and the literature of the period has been the subject of detailed examination by historians such as Peter Lake, Stanford Lehmberg and John Newman. Yet the authorship of these policies remains hotly contested, with some historians seeing them as deriving directly from the king, while others have argued that the responsibility lies firmly with Archbishop William Laud. Nonetheless ‘Laudian’ provides a convenient shorthand term when discussing these differing ecclesiological strands of the period.

Type
Research Article
Information
Architectural History , Volume 46 , 2003 , pp. 95 - 108
Copyright
Copyright © Society of Architectural Historians of Great Britain 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Fincham, K., ‘The Restoration of altars in the 1630s’, Historical Journal, 44 (2001), pp. 919-40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 See for example the visitation articles and orders issued for Exeter, Gloucester and Worcester Cathedrals and Boston parish church. The Works of the Most Reverend Father in God, William Laud D.D., ed. Scott, W. and Bliss, J., 7 vols (Oxford, 1853), 5, pp. 480-81Google Scholar,482,491,494,498-99. Lehmberg, S., Cathedrals under Siege: Cathedrals in English Society, 1600-1700 (Philadelphia, 1996), pp. 11–13 Google Scholar.

3 Lake, P., ‘The Laudian Style: Order, Uniformity and the Pursuit of Holiness in the 1630s’, in The Early Stuart Church, 1603-1642, ed. Fincham, K. (Basingstoke, 1993), pp. 161-85CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lehmberg, Cathedrals under Siege; Newman, J., ‘Laudian Literature and the Interpretation of Caroline Churches in London’, in Art and Patronage in the Caroline Courts, ed. Howarth, D. (Cambridge, 1993), pp. 168-88Google Scholar.

4 See Fincham, ‘The Restoration of altars’, pp. 919-21 for an overview of the debate and the literature.

5 Lake, ‘The Laudian Style’, pp. 162-63.

6 Morrill, J., ‘A British Patriarchy? Ecclesiastical imperialism under the early Stuarts’, in Religion, Culture and Society in Early Modern Britain, ed. Fletcher, A. and Roberts, P. (Cambridge, 1994), pp. 231-36Google Scholar.

7 Works of William Laud, 3, p. 314.

8 Donaldson, G. & Radford, C. A. Ralegh, ‘Post-Reformation Church at Whithorn’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, 85 (1950-52), pp. 117-33Google Scholar.

9 Hannay, R. K. & Watson, G. P. H., ‘The Building of the Parliament House’, The Book of the Old Edinburgh Club, 13 (1924), pp. 1–78 Google Scholar. As the title suggests, this article principally discusses the construction of a new Parliament building, but this is placed in the context of other urban building projects in Edinburgh, most notably the refurbishment of St Giles’.

10 Howard, D., Scottish Architecture from the Reformation to the Restoration, 1560-1660 (Edinburgh, 1995), p. 192 Google Scholar; Gifford, J., McWilliam, C. and Walker, D., Buildings of Scotland: Edinburgh (London, 1984), p. 106 Google Scholar; Hay, G., ‘The Late Medieval Development of the High Kirk of St Giles, Edinburgh’, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, 107 (1975-67), p. 243 Google Scholar.

11 Thurley, S., ‘The Stuart Kings, Oliver Cromwell and the Chapel Royal, 1618-1685’, Architectural History, 45 (2002), pp. 241 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 242.

12 Cameron, J. K., The First Book of Discipline (Edinburgh, 1972), p. 94 Google Scholar. These two paragraphs owe an initial debt to Donaldson, ‘Post-Reformation Church at Whithorn’, pp. 129-31.

13 Howard, Scottish Architecture, pp. 168-88; Spicer, A., ‘“Accommodating of thame selfis to heir the worde”: Preaching, pews and Reformed worship in Scotland, 1560-1638’, History, 87 (2003)Google Scholar; Spicer, A., The Reformation Church: Architecture and Society (Manchester, forthcoming)Google Scholar.

14 I. B. Cowan, , The Parishes of Medieval Scotland, (Scottish Record Society, 1967), 93, pp. 2, 22–23 Google Scholar, 53.

15 The Booke of the Universali Kirk of Scotland, ed. Thomson, T. (Edinburgh, 1839-45), PP. 280 Google Scholar,706; Register of the Privy Seal of Scotland, 8 vols (1908-66), 6, pp. 314-15.

16 Extracts from the Records of the Burgh of Glasgow, AD 1573-1642, ed. Marwick, J. D. (Scottish Burgh Records Society, 1876), ii, p. 20 Google Scholar.

17 MacDonald, A. R., The Jacobean Kirk, 1567-1625: Sovereignty, Polity and Liturgy (Aldershot, 1998), p. 94 Google Scholar, 119-21,143; Foster, W. R., The Church before the Covenants: The Church of Scotland, 1596-1638 (Edinburgh, 1978), pp. 6–31 Google Scholar.

18 Funerals of a Right Reverend father in God. Patrick Forbes of Corse, Bishop of Aberdene, ed. Lindsay, David (Aberdeen, 1635), pp. 64–65 Google Scholar; Records of Old Aberdeen, ed. Munro, A. A. (New Spalding Club, 1899), 20, p. 54 Google Scholar.

19 Records of the Burgh of Glasgow, pp. 301, 308.

20 Bentinck, C. D., Dornoch Cathedral and Parish (Inverness, 1926), pp. 187-89Google Scholar.

21 Bentinck, Dornoch Cathedral, pp. 211-12.

22 The Earl of Stirling’s register of royal letters, relative to the affairs of Scotland and Nova Scotia from 1615 to 1635, ed. Rogers, C. (Edinburgh, 1885), 2, p. 471 Google Scholar; Cooper, , ‘Dunkeld Cathedral’, Transactions of the Scottish Ecclesiological Society, 6 (1912-15), p. 34 Google Scholar; The Acts of the Parliament of Scotland, 1124-1707, ed. Thomson, T. and Innes, C., 12 vols (London, 1814-75), 5. pp. 52–53 Google Scholar; Hay, G., The Architecture of Scottish Post-Reformation Churches, 1560-1841 (Oxford, 1957), p. 27 Google Scholar.

23 Baillie, R., The Letters and Journals of Robert Baillie, ed. Laing, D., 3 vols (Bannatyne Club, 1841), 1, p. 163 Google Scholar.

24 Charters and other documents relating to the City of Glasgow, AD 1175-1649 , ed. Marwick, J. D. (Scottish Burgh Records Society, 1894) I, Pt 2, p. 351 Google Scholar.

25 Donaldson, ‘Post-Reformation Church at Whithorn’, p. 121.

26 Royal Commission on the Ancient & Historical Monuments of Scotland, Argyll: An Inventory of Monuments, 7 vols (Edinburgh, 1971-92), 4, pp. 52, 78, 94, 149.

27 Fleming, D. Hay, The Reformation in Scotland (London, 1910), pp. 607-08Google Scholar; Works of William Laud, 3, p. 313; W. Prynne, , Hidden Workes of Darkenes Brought to Publike Light (London, 1645), p. 164 Google Scholar. This also had the effect of raising fears that the King intended to restore abbeys with the parliamentary powers to the Kirk. Mullan, D. G., Episcopacy in Scotland: The History of an Idea, 1560-1638 (Edinburgh, 1986), p. 173 Google Scholar.

28 Morrill, ‘A British Patriarchy?’, p. 233.

29 Works of William Laud, 5, p. 496.

30 Imrie, J. I. and Dunbar, J. G., Accounts of the Masters of Works, 2 vols (Edinburgh, 1957,1982), 2, pp. lxxxvi–lxxxvii Google Scholar, 441; McCullough, P. E., Sermons at Court. Politics and Religion in Elizabethan and Jacobean preaching (Cambridge, 1998), pp. 20–23 Google Scholar, 29; Spicer, The Reformation Church; Calderwood, D., The History of the Kirk of Scotland, ed. Thomson, T., 8 vols (Wodrow Society, 1842-47), 7, pp. 246-47Google Scholar; Thurley, ‘The Stuart Kings, Oliver Cromwell and the Chapel Royal’, p. 241.

31 Row, J., The History of the Kirk of Scotland, ed. Laing, D. (Wodrow Society, 1842), p. 362 Google Scholar.

32 Donaldson, G., The Making of the Scottish Prayer Book of 1637 (Edinburgh, 1954), pp. 42–43 Google Scholar.

33 McMillan, W., The Worship of the Scottish Reformed Church, 1550-1638 (London, 1931), p. 98 Google Scholar.

34 The minister was also condemned for erecting an altar and rails, another minister was similarly charged. Baillie, , Letter and Journals, 1, pp. 164-65Google Scholar.

35 Baillie, , Letters and Journals, 1, pp. 160-61Google Scholar; Machines, A. I., Charles I and the Making of the Covenanting Movement, 1625-1641 (Edinburgh, 1991), pp. 144-47Google Scholar.

36 Register of the Privy Council of Scotland, Second Series, 1622-1660, 8 vols (Edinburgh, 1899-1908), 5, pp. 136-37; Extracts from the Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, ed. Marwick, J. D. et al. (Scottish Burgh Records Society, 1869-), 8, pp. 133-34Google Scholar.

37 Edinburgh City Archives, Dean of Guild accounts, 1552-67, pp. 123, 124, 277; Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 3, pp. 27-28, 42-44, 45, 49, 70; A. Spicer, ‘Iconoclasm and Adaptation: The Reformation of the Churches in Scotland and the Netherlands’, in The Archaeology of the Reformation, ed. D. Gaimster and R. Gilchrist (2003).

38 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 3, p. 66.

39 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 4, p. 87; Stevenson, D., The Scottish Revolution, 1637-1644: the Triumph of the Covenanters (Newton Abbot, 1973), pp. 401-02Google Scholar.

40 Stevenson, Scottish Revolution, pp. 401-02; Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 3, p. 259; Lees, J. C., St Giles’ Edinburgh: Church, College, Cathedral (Edinburgh, 1889), p. 157 Google Scholar.

41 Lynch, M., ‘Introduction: Scottish Towns, 1500-1700’, in The Early Modern Town in Scotland, ed. Lynch, M. (London, 1987), p. 28 Google Scholar, 35. See also the attempts to extend the East Kirk ‘for there was not sufficient rowme for people resorting to that kirk, nor for commodious ministratioun of the Lord’s Supper’. Booke of the Universali Kirk, p. 861; Calderwood, , The History of the Kirk of Scotland, 6, p. 739 Google Scholar; Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 6, pp. 221, 224, 228, 235, 239, 249, 251, 260.

42 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 6, p. 197.

43 Hannay & Watson, ‘Building of the Parliament House’, pp. 17-18.

44 Works of William Laud, 5, pp. 143, 207; Newman, J., ‘The Architectural Setting’, in The History of the University of Oxford. IV Seventeenth-Century Oxford, ed. Tyacke, N. (Oxford, 1997), p. 161 Google Scholar. See also Geraghty, A., ‘Wren’s Preliminary Design for the Sheldonian Theatre’, Architectural History, 45 (2002), p. 275 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 Macinnes, Charles I and the Making of the Covenanting Movement, p. 152, n. 40.

46 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 8, p. 134.

47 Edinburgh City Archives, List of subscribers to the repair of St Giles’, 1636 to 1637; Howard, Scottish Architecture, pp. 191-92; Gifford, Edinburgh, pp. 172-75.

48 Works of William Laud, 3, p. 315.

49 Edinburgh City Archives, Dean of Guild Accounts 1568-1601, p. 399; Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 3, p. 173, 7, p. 142; Spicer, ‘“Accommodating of thame selfis to heir the worde”’.

50 Register of Royal Letters, 2, p. 797.

51 Brown, P. Hume, Early Travellers in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1891), pp. 83–84 Google Scholar.

52 Works of William Laud, 3, p. 315.

53 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 8, pp. 134,136,137,147,154,155.

54 Edinburgh City Archives, Treasurers Accounts 1636-50.

55 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 8, p. 191.

56 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 8, p. 213.

57 Atherton, I., ‘Viscount Scudamore’s “Laudianism”: the religious practices of the first Viscount Scudamore’, Historical Journal, 34 (1991), pp. 567-96CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Merritt, J. F., ‘Puritans, Laudians, and the phenomenon of church-building in Jacobean London’, Historical journal, 41 (1998), pp. 935–60 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Newman, ‘Laudian Literature and the Interpretation of Caroline Churches’, pp. 168-88; Spicer, The Reformation Church.

58 Row, The History of the Kirk of Scotland, pp. 369-70.

59 See Harris, J. and Higgott, G., Inigo Jones, Complete Architectural Drawings (New York, 1989), pp. 238-47Google Scholar; Summerson, J., ‘Inigo Jones: Covent Garden and the Restoration of St Paul’s Cathedral’, in his The Unromantic Castle and other essays (London, 1990), pp. 54–62 Google Scholar. The restoration included the refitting of the choir which was undertaken in c. 1632, Newman, ‘Laudian literature and Caroline churches’, p. 172.

60 On Ireland, see Capern, A. L., ‘The Caroline Church: James Ussher and the Irish Dimension’, Historical Journal, 39 (1996), pp. 69–70 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Works of William Laud, 6, pp. 361-62.

61 Works of William Laud, 3, pp. 314-15; ‘Unpublished letters of Archbishop Laud and Charles I’, ed. Hutton, W. H., English Historical Review, 7 (1892), p. 715 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 MacGibbon, D. and Ross, T., The Castellated and Domestic Architecture of Scotland, 5 vols (Edinburgh, 1887), 5, P. 155 Google Scholar.

63 Howard, Scottish Architecture, pp. 188,190.

64 Gifford, Fife, p. 169; Howard, Scottish Architecture, pp. 188-90.

65 Ecclesiastical Records. Selections from the Synod of Fife, pp. 129,135,141.

66 Spicer, A., ‘“To the glory of God and for his worship”: the consecration of post-Reformation churches in Scotland’, in Sacred Space: The Redefinition of Sanctity in post-Reformation Europe, ed. Coster, W. and Spicer, A. (Cambridge, forthcoming)Google Scholar.

67 Records of the Burgh of Edinburgh, 8, p. 174.

68 Tyacke, N., Anti-Calvinists: The rise of English Arminianism, c. 1590-1640 (Oxford, 1987), p. 116 Google Scholar, 118.

69 Fincham, ‘The Restoration of altars in the 1630s’, pp. 922-28.

70 North Country Diaries, ed. Hodgson, J. C. (Surtees Society, 124,1915), pp. 13–14 Google Scholar.

71 The Correspondence of John Cosin, D.D., Lord Bishop of Durham, ed. Ornsby, G. (Surtees Society, 52,1868), pp. 215-16Google Scholar.

72 Stevenson, The Scottish Revolution, pp. 56-87; Machines, Charles I and the Making of the Covenanting Movement, pp. 158-61.

73 [Balcanquhall, Walter], A Large Declaration concerning the late Tumults in Scotland (London, 1639), p. 23 Google Scholar. On the redefinition of sanctity in post-Reformation Scottish churches, see Spicer Ȉ“To the glory of God and for his worship”’.